JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL AND ENGINEERING CHEMISTRY

Regarding the above comment of mine: I reply it here that now the article is accepted. Submitted: 29/Oct/2018; Under revision: 03/Dec/2018; Accept: 17/Jun/2019. Review turnaround time was 7.5 months.

(0) Thank | 皮革废料

The paper was submitted to this journal in last year. On 2018-10-29, paper was submitted; On 2018-12-10, reviewer comments were given. The comments were rubbish, basically there were no meaningful comments. On 2018-12-18, returned and with editor for more than three months. It has been under review for 79 days. Until now, it has been totally 7 months and still no news. It is really deceiving and I am considering withdrawing it. Regarding the above comment, I reply it here that now the article is accepted. Submitted: 29/Oct/2018; Under revision: 03/Dec/2018; Accept: 17/Jun/2019. Review turnaround time was 7.5 months.

(2) Thank | 皮革废料

The paper was submitted to this journal in last year. On 2018-10-29, paper was submitted; On 2018-12-10, reviewer comments were given. The comments were rubbish; basically there were no meaningful comments. On 2018-12-18 revised with editor for more than three months. Now it has been under review for 79 days. Until now, it has been totally 7 months still no news. It is really deceiving and I am considering withdrawing it or not.

(43) Thank | 皮革废料

Since I had not submitted for this journal before, and my article was rejected by JHM, I tried JIEC. The process was very slow. I guess I will remember this submission my entire life. After submitting in July,  the manuscript was with the editor and not submitted for review until October. The opinions of three reviewers were appropriate and I revised and resubmitted in January. Then I heard nothing. I don’t remember how many reminder emails I sent to every editor. Finally, in August I got a reply letting me know I’d hear back in a week. I received the rejection letter that night stating that the reviewer doesn’t recommend publication. It is best to submit to other journals.

(19) Thank | scuxzk@163.com

2018.2.14 Submission, just two months with the editor, and then reviewed for two months, after which it was rejected.I just want to say that Hao Hao is also a journal in the second district. How to arrange it so slowly.If the research of the thesis is relatively mediocre, it is not recommended that everyone select for this, and the requirements for innovation are higher.

(2) Thank | Wangwang

didn’t want to comment on this issue, but I’ve seen someone comment, I’ll also talk about it.I selectd for this journal twice. The review comments are good. But there is always a sentence saying that this journal has recently published too many articles in this field. What is the opinion?......In the end, it was rejected twice. I want to greet people

(5) Thank | lsx20131120a@163.com

more than two months, not yet with the editor, send mail reminderI forgot to arrange the editor, let me withdraw, and then select, and then send an email no one to care about me

(1) Thank | 夏天

3.29 Submission, with editor One month later under reviewIn mid-May, I rushed once, and the under review was updated once. It is estimated that it was re-submitted.At the end of June, it was reminded again.7.16 is back, the reviewer refused, the editor let the change re-submitTwo days revised and re-submited, the next day with editor7.22 directly received

(1) Thank | zyjinshu@126.com

has been submiting for nearly 10 months, still has not received the first trial news, too slow,

(1) Thank | cqupenghao

Speed ​​is a bit slow, but not bad

(0) Thank | ttt

Reviewed a Korean manuscript and gave the overhaul opinion without returningReceived directly into the reviewer's hand, speechless, from reviewing to receiving, it is also a month's time. Is this journal only open to Koreans?

(3) Thank | qqq

with editor 4 months, the manuscript has been repeated many times, no one is taking care of it.It is not recommended that everyone select for this journal, too slow

(1) Thank | kong

has been 7 months, the first-instance opinion has not been returned, and two reminder letters have been sent.

(1) Thank | mahuancontact@sina.com

selectd for more than 20 days, still with editor, how so slow ah

(1) Thank | Anonymous

submitted is witheditor, it is almost 10 days orWitheditor, I hope to speed up the review

(0) Thank | Anonymous

The past is witheditor, it is almost 10 days or witheditor, I hope to speed up the review speed

(0) Thank | haoxeuxi888@126.com

September 18 was submitted out, the review was quick, and it was returned in less than one month, giving a 30-day revision period.It was revised and accepted on November 14.Magazine influence factor rose quickly

(0) Thank | 木子少爷

JIEC Now the above article is of high quality, and the current submission rate is less than 30%. The article is very demanding and has a lot to do with the recent IF surge.

(2) Thank | Anonymous

I just want to say that the rejection is super fast 2 days if you want to try it or you can

(5) Thank | lixiaona510@126.com

This journal is difficult to submitted, and it has been sawn off by 3 pieces (one of which was sawn off by it and transferred to one of the top 3 publications of the chemical industry, IECR).), the fourth article was revised and acceptd.If the quality of the paper is OK, you can still try it, especially in the aspect of catalytic engineering. It is a bit more important

(2) Thank | yinganguo@126.com

is still very difficult, the review time is too long

(0) Thank | luanmingming2010@163.com

Why, I submitted the manuscript for 10 days, or with the editor, praying!

(2) Thank | Anonymous

This journal is a journal sponsored by the Korean Society of Chemical Engineering, published by elsevier, bimonthly, with 50 articles per issue.The paper was submitted in January this year, and it was sent out in a few days. However, because the reviewer did not review, the time was longer, and a reviewer was changed later. After two weeks, the result came out.In May, I returned to the revised opinion, and after four days of uploading the revised draft, I directly acceptd it.After a week on elsevier, see the journal in advance.It is estimated that it will be officially published after half a year.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Is this journal going to review the draft fee and the version is free??

(0) Thank | Anonymous