JOURNAL OF DAIRY SCIENCE

The reviewers were basically found after submission. It took about 2 months on average for the first review period, and it needed about one month after major revision. The review speed was relatively slow. Regardless of major revision or minor revision, the revision time is generally 40 days.

(0) Thank | 晓爽

This is a top journal in the industry. It is difficult to publish and the acceptance rate is only approximately 25%. Researcher Jiaqi Wang from Institute of Animal Science of CAAS and Xinwei Li from Jilin University are editorial board members of this journal.

(16) Thank | jake100

2019.6.30, submission; 2019.8.14, major revision; 2019.9.9, the revision was submitted; 2019.10.20, minor revision; 2019.11.3, accept. It took 4 months from submission to acceptance, and I felt the editor was very efficient. There were 2 reviewers in the first review, one of them read the article carefully and raised 55 comments. Another one may not in the relative field, so he didn’t understand it. He asked 5 questions and let me make further revision, but didn’t mention how to revise it. After three weeks of revision, the article was basically rewritten. I carefully answered the comments of the first reviewer. The reply was more than 5,000 words, and it also provided many supporting data that were not in the article. After the revision was submitted, the first reviewer read the reply carefully and asked to supplement some data to the article. The second reviewer still didn’t quite understand and asked a question. After the minor revision, the article should be sent for review again by the editor, and it was accepted directly. The overall feeling is that it is difficult to publish on this journal. The editor and reviewers were serious and responsible.

(5) Thank | tengfei

The review is slow, the reviewer's feedback is all over the place. Very limited number of comments.

(5) Thank | Susmittee

January 4, 2015April 7, 2015 OverhaulJune 30, 2015 BackAugust 15, 2015 OverhaulOctober 8, 2015 BackNovember 25, 2015December 11, 2015 BackJanuary 3, 2016 Overhaul The reviewer has no comments. The editorial comments given before the editor did not give him a satisfactory answer. The editor re-submitted the overhaul.January 10, 2016 BackJanuary 20, 2016 Overhaul The editor's opinion is still not very good.February 25, 2016 BackMarch 8, 2016 Minor repairs are still editors' opinions. Editors are very persistent.March 16, 2016 BackMarch 20, 2016 finally accepted....After more than a year, the hanging heart finally fell.Overall, the speed of review is moderate, a bit slow, and the review of the journal is very strict, especially the editor's rights are very big but also very professional

(3) Thank | 呵呵呵

Research direction for molecular monitoring of milk and dairy quality, has been submitted 2, one has been accepted, another major revision.Submitted 16/8/22Major revision 16/10/18Major revision submitted 16/10/24Major revision 16/11/7Minor revision submitted 16/11/14Accept 16/11/16

(4) Thank | Anonymous

The top journal of the dairy industry, the impact factor 2 has not changed much.The editor of

(0) Thank | Anonymous

looks like a fee, providing two options, one is to charge by page,The second is open access, but also charge

(1) Thank | Anonymous

Journal Homepage URL: http://www.elsevier.com/wps/find ... ription#description

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Research Direction: Dairy Cattle Metabolism Mechanism,Dairy quality, dairy cow nutrition and feed, lactation mechanism, dairy disease prevention

(0) Thank | Anonymous