PHYSICA A-STATISTICAL MECHANICS AND ITS APPLICATIONS

This is the first article published on Physica. Share you the hard process of submission: 2018.12.28, submission; 2019.3.25, the comments of first review: revision. It was submitted after two months of revision; 2019.8.6, comments of second review: revision. It was submitted after one month of revision; 2019.10.31, comments of third review. It was revised and submitted on the same day; 2019.11.13, the acceptance letter was received. It is an excellent journal, which requires high quality articles, and the reviewers are very careful and strict.

(17) Thank | Annie

My first manuscript submitted to Physica is undergoing the peer review. It was submitted on December 28th, 2018. The comments of first review returned on March 25th, 2019. I sent it back after I revised the manuscript for two months. The comments of second review returned on August 6th, 2019. I revised the manuscript for a month and submitted it. From then on, the status has been under review. I feel very nervous! I hope for a good result. I will share the submission process in real time, for everyone to refer to.

(4) Thank | Annie

The review speed of the first review is still very fast, about a one month to get initial feedback.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

A methodical system for reviewing papers.

(0) Thank | cmooncs@rediffmail.com

The review of the journal is slower. After the first-instance reply, the processing is very fast. It is not bad. The first time I submitted it to this journal, I accepted it for half a year.

(1) Thank | rocklee

European PhysicsThe old-fashioned journal accredited by the Society, editor-in-chief HE Stanley is a member of the American Academy of Sciences, the mainstream journal of financial physics (economic physics). The first trial has more than two months of results, and the amendments are returned for trial again. More than three months are accepted. The overall time is about seven.About a month!

(28) Thank | 会飞的鱼

Very good journal, requires some innovation, and it takes a lot of effort to accept.

(21) Thank | great

Editor-in-Chief of the American Academy of Sciences, okay, the mainstream journal of financial physics and social dynamics

(14) Thank | ··········

Return to the revised opinion for one and a half months, and receive it two months after the repair.Received very quickly, one water journal.It is enough to select for one.

(0) Thank | 韦迎春他老爹

is very fast, it is accepted for two months, and it is received one month after the repair.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Submitted in April 2015, reviewed in December 2015.Minor repair in April 2016, accepted in May.The reviewer is very strict. He is a big cow in the industry. He has sent several articles

(7) Thank | 2564887303@qq.com

I feel that the review is very fast. I have a small repair result in one month. I am repaired after 10 days, and I have accepted it in 28 days. The article on the complex network is relatively good.

(3) Thank | Anonymous

The review period is a bit long. I selectd for 2 articles from June to October, minor repairs, and about 2 months for the second trial.I think the field is different. I think it is still a very good publication. I will know the reference to the journal article in the article I wrote.

(1) Thank | Anonymous

It seems that you are not as simple as you said. I have selectd for two. The reviewers are very demanding, and the revision is quite laborious.In the past, this journal still has a lot of big cows published articles on it, especially in the field of statistical physics and percolation

(2) Thank | Anonymous

1, the journal feels more and more complicated, many engineering classes also comeIrrigation; 2, I feel a lot of people from the country, a bit like a domestic vest; 3, the speed of publication is very fast, contempt for irrigation, although I just sent an article, soon, I feel that the reviewer can also recommend it, recommend to familiar peopleIt is still relatively simple, a little bit of a trend.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

A mainstream journal in the field of statistical physics, complexity science, complex network, and human dynamics. The grade is not very high. The middle and low end of JCR three districts, but the content of the article is very new, relativelySaid to be more good.Sometimes it is very fast, and it is published in 3 months, but it is ruined by harsh or more realistic reviewers. Our team has been pressing for months or even a year.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Magazine is OK, the speed is uncertain, the direction of the recent publication is a bit shifting, my direction is not suitable for submitteding, and I have lost a choice, sadness ah

(0) Thank | Anonymous

I have modified the one that I have acceptd. I feel that the editor is quite responsible. I sent a reply to EMAIL quickly, and the difficulty is not very big.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

last year in February to select for an article in the journal, so far no review comments have returned, still in the Under Review state, this efficiency is tooWow, at least the editor is very irresponsible, the manager said that it was assigned to the editor-in-chief (then selectd out on February 22nd, and will be sent to the trial on May 30th), so he was also the editor-in-chief, just like this editorThe journal has messed up, and I said that the PA impact factor will not go up, hehe...I was reminded that I didn’t hear back a few times. It was unlucky...

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Speed ​​is OK, the review comments are given in two months

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Journal Homepage URL: http://ees.elsevier.com/physa/

(0) Thank | Anonymous

I have been able to read and edit your articles, and the speed is very fast.Within 1-2 months.The editor is very responsible.

(1) Thank | Anonymous

This journal is still faster, the grade is average, it is easier to send.I have sent an article on it.

(1) Thank | Anonymous