I submitted three articles in 2019 to 2020, one got rejected, and two got accepted after revision. It is a very authoritative journal in the field of structure, and it is highly recognized at home and abroad. It is very rigorous, and sometimes the editors may be too cautious and easily reject manuscripts. The review cycle is really long.

(31) Thank | johnnys

I can only say that you should submit your manuscript carefully. I got a rejection after a year from submission. What a waste of time! And it is obvious that the reviewers are geographically discriminatory.

(10) Thank | poly

Nearly two months after the submission, external review was completed. Two of the three reviewers were positive, but the other one extremely negative, making it sound like my research is totally worthless, but did not give any constructive comments! The editorial office rejected my paper. However, the other two positive reviewers did point out some problems that I did not notice, very professional, and I appreciate that!

(1) Thank | wentong21@163.com

When I was about six months along, I nudged once. At that time, one of the three reviewers had not finished reviewing, and the editor was very understanding. I think it's okay to remind those who take longer.

(0) Thank | JIN1005

Hired on May 5, 2025, the overall process took nearly a year. Finally got hired.

(0) Thank | JIN1005

I am in the same situation, it has been 4 months since the first review and it is still under review. Should we follow up, brother?

(0) Thank | YYT_

Submission on 28th June 2024
Under review on 29th June 2024
Major revision on 14th January 2025
Under review on 1st March 2025
The editorial process is fast, but the review time is indeed long. Hope to be accepted after major revision.

(0) Thank | JIN1005

Normally, JSE does not have the status "with editor".

(0) Thank | JIN1005

After submitting the manuscript, it was Under Review the next day. Is this normal? In the past, it usually took at least a week for the status to change to UR when submitting to other journals. Is this journal's efficiency so high? Any friends who have encountered this before, please give some advice.

(0) Thank | 简宁

After this journal is revised for the editor only, will it take a long time for review?

(0) Thank | haimeishenwan

Usually it's three.

(0) Thank | LetPub-2024

Hello, may I ask how many reviewers are there in jse? It has been two and a half months since I submitted my paper, and I have been waiting in ur.

(0) Thank | AcceptOne

2024.4.11 submitted to journal
2024.5.29 major revision
2024.6.30 revisions submitted to journal
2024.7.18 accept

(1) Thank | LetPub-2024

Boss, may I ask how many reviewers are there for JSE? I just submitted a paper recently, and it is currently under external review. I hope the review process won't take too long.

(0) Thank | AcceptOne

Top journals in the field of structural engineering, submissions are accepted with a turnaround time of 10 months (including one major revision). Innovative work is encouraged to be submitted

(0) Thank | 工部侍郎

Top Journal in the Field of Civil Engineering Structures
24.1.10 submit
24.2.28 revise
2024.3.26 accept
Fast forward, JSE fighting!

(0) Thank | Juchan Lau-1

Flagship journal in the field of structural engineering, well-deserved

From submission to acceptance took 14 months, the review process is as long as the journal's history

(0) Thank | 爱思唯儿

02-28-2024 Decision - Accept (Final)
02-06-2024 Revised Submission Sent to Journal
02-06-2024 Decision - Revise for Editor Only
12-16-2023 Revised Submission Sent to Journal
11-28-2023 Decision - Revise for Re-Review
09-01-2023 New Submission Sent to Journal Office

(1) Thank | xiaohui2445

What does it mean by the journal being downgraded? It has always been in the third tier of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, I don't understand why you say it has been downgraded

(0) Thank | 十一月南瓜

It has always shown "Under Review"
No news yet even after the journal's impact factor has dropped

(0) Thank | = =

Has the external audit come back yet? Is it still in the hands of the editor, or has it not been sent for external audit?

(0) Thank | 小张fighting

Oh my god.. it's been 9 months since I submitted my paper for review.. I asked and they said it's still with the editor

(0) Thank | = =

Hello, may I ask if the first revision has been sent back to the reviewer? I have received the first revision, but the email said it would not be sent back to the reviewer. However, it has been a while and I have not heard anything

(0) Thank | gyx304227

January 18th submission
February 23rd rework
March 15th revised again
May 16th accepted

(0) Thank | 一起水论文

The submission was rejected after two months, with one reviewer recommending major revisions and another rejecting it. However, the associate editor suggested that it be revised and resubmitted as a new manuscript.

This journal has two LetPub review websites:
https://www.letpub.com.cn/index.php?journalid=9553&page=journalapp&view=detail
https://www.letpub.com.cn/index.php?journalid=5190&page=journalapp&view=detail

It would be better to merge them into one.

(0) Thank | = =