05/06/2019 submitted to journal; 07/31/2019 back to author; 12/27/2019 minor revise; 01/20/2020 revised submission back to journal; 01/30/2020 accepted. The journal had very detailed requirements. It was mainly myself who did not format the paper and references according to the journal’s requirements. Everything must be treated carefully. The review was still very fast. Most of the time was wasted by myself. Thanks to the journal!

(1) Thank | colin123

First of all, this journal is not slow in review like everyone said. My manuscript was reviewed for 2 months in the first round, and we submitted the revision one month later. It is accepted one week later. It mainly depends on whether the paper fits the scope of the journal. Note that the journal focuses on engineering.

(0) Thank | 2415698123@qq.com

Submission on November 9, 2024
Received external review comments on March 6, 2025 (one external review expert + editor, minor revisions)
Resubmission on March 13, 2025
Received comments on March 17, 2025 (formatting changes), returned the same day
Received comments on April 8, 2025 (one sentence revision in abstract), returned the same day
Accepted on April 25, 2025
Still waiting for Production.

(0) Thank | 欧阳锋的眼泪

Not just slow.

(0) Thank | 彩虹石

The external audit results are out, and they only required minor adjustments.

(0) Thank | 欧阳锋的眼泪

Not as fast as the comments say, it's been four months and still no news.

(0) Thank | 欧阳锋的眼泪

Good senior brother, guess who I am.

(0) Thank | 李恒

Is there a link to check the specific status of external review for this journal?

(0) Thank | stecurr

How long did it take from receiving the notification to the publication?

(0) Thank | 魏什么--

Submitted on 29th November 2023
Revised on 15th January 2024, with one month given
Second revision on 25th March 2024, with half a month given
Accepted on 9th May 2024
Overall, you will receive feedback every 1-1.5 months. The first revision was delayed until the last day due to other papers, while the second revision mainly involved minor issues, such as adding a complete legend in the figure

(0) Thank | 魏什么--

The sudden rejection came unexpectedly, why was it rejected?

(0) Thank | shenren001

Submitted on 29th November 23, returned for revision on 18th January 24, with one month given for modification

(0) Thank | 魏什么--

May I ask if there have been any updates during the period from submitting the application to receiving the first review on January 1st? It has been a long time and I am still under review

(0) Thank | 魏什么--

Too slow, too slow. It's been over a month since I submitted it in late November, and it's still Under Review

(0) Thank | 魏什么--

The journal has relatively detailed requirements, with many rounds of revisions. However, the response time is also relatively fast, and overall it is quite good. The process from revision to acceptance took a total of 4 months, with three reviewers.

(0) Thank | 静水流深555

It took seven months, from constantly modifying the format, to providing suggestions for major revisions and minor revisions. Finally, after a month of minor revisions, it was rejected.
12.09 Submission successful.
3.09 Suggestions for major revisions given, and it was revised and returned after a month.
4.10 Reply letter not properly organized, delayed submission of revised draft by one day.
5.23 Suggestions for minor revisions given, and it was revised and returned within 15 days (this time with a different editor coordinator, not the same one as the initial submission and previous communication).
6.02 Revised draft submitted according to suggestions for minor revisions.
7.04 Rejected.

(0) Thank | multivolve

I recommend this journal. The submission process is quite fast, but the editors are unusually strict with the formatting requirements. It took several revisions before meeting the requirements. However, they handled the article quickly.

Submitted on November 28, 2022.

First review returned on January 1, 2023. Given one month for revisions, but I procrastinated and submitted it at the last moment.

Revised version returned on February 1, 2023.

Second review returned on March 5, 2023. Made revisions for a few formatting issues (revised for editor only).

Revised version returned on March 7, 2023.

Accepted on March 10, 2023.

(0) Thank | 山水指尖

Can you please clarify what "xdm" refers to in the context of the manuscript?

(1) Thank | ll718

Recommend this journal, actually the speed is very fast. The reviewers are very professional, and the editors are very good. Due to not being able to submit the revised paper on time, a request for a submission extension was made.

20220512 Submission
20220613 Minor revisions for first review
20220803 Revised manuscript returned
20220825 Second review returned - Revise for Editor Only
20220902 Revised manuscript returned
20220906 Accepted

(1) Thank | dapengpeng

Excuse me, is this journal SCI? Thank you very much.

(0) Thank | yanyan2871

February submission, March requires overhaul, April modified and uploaded, received in June.The requirements are very fine, the response is very fast, and most of the time is my own waste

(0) Thank | 279979558@qq.com

Submitted in February, required overhaul in March, uploaded after April revision, received in June.The requirements are very fine, the response is very fast, most of the time is my own waste

(0) Thank | 279979558@qq.com

submission for one year, during the reminder several times, areThe same reply, according to a year later!

(0) Thank | ccc

selectd for one year, and the first trial gave advice, and it was based on it.

(0) Thank | kaixin

for a trial of 26 months, research and submitment, Bo 2 published, this speed is also drunk

(3) Thank | freshman