Publish 02 January 2020, Published; Rereview Decision 14 December 2019, Manuscript Accepted; Rereview 14 December 2019, Rereview Complete; Final Manuscript Decision 08 December 2019, Repeat Review; Author Revision 07 December 2019, Author Revisions Complete; Preproduction Review 29 November 2019, Author Revision; First Manuscript Decision 27 November 2019, Major Revisions Required; Peer Review 27 November 2019, Peer Review Complete; Submit Manuscript 11 November 2019, Submission Complete.

(28) Thank | 知白守黑

Research direction: Rare earth luminescent materials; Submission period: 2 months and 20 days; Final status: Accepted; Submission experience: There were two reviewers, and the review speed was fast. The manuscript was submitted on May 21. The review comments came back on July 18 (There were major revision and minor revision). The revised manuscript was submitted on August 4, and it was accepted on August 13.

(0) Thank | 19猪猪侠

The review speed is very fast; three reviewers, but only one accepted the paper. I spent 10 days modifying the paper. The publication fee is more than 10,000 yuan RMB. As long as the article has new ideas, it will be considered here. Style Check 22 August 2017; Re-review Decision 22 August 2017; Rate Re-reviewers 22 August 2017; Re-review 20 August 2017; Final Manuscript Decision 18 August 2017; Author Revision 09 August 2017; Preproduction Review 08 August 2017; First Manuscript Decision 08 August 2017; Rate Reviewers 08 August 2017; Peer Review18 July 2017; Assign Editor 17 July 2017; Quality Check 16 July 2017; Submit Manuscript 16 July 2017.

(3) Thank | 372933244@qq.com

Submission on March 13th
Reviewed and completed on March 30th, with three reviewers providing feedback, both major and minor revisions were suggested. The reviewers are highly competent.
Revised manuscript sent back on April 10th
Second round of review on April 13th
Final review completed on April 28th, although two reviewers finished earlier on the 18th, while one was busy and completed on the 28th. The speed and efficiency were remarkable.
Acceptance email received on April 29th
Overall, the review quality demonstrated by the journal and the current quality of the article are approaching the level of second quartile journals. Moving forward, it is expected to rival or even surpass journals like OE (which generally have high citation rates in the field of materials). The review process was quite fast, but the journal's standards and the reviewers' competence are indeed top-notch, placing it in the third quartile of prestigious journals with low publication volume, requiring articles of a certain standard.

(0) Thank | yxgforletpub

not submitted

(0) Thank | krish

Before publication, there will be a cover article invitation. By creating a beautiful image, there is a certain chance of being selected as the cover article.

(0) Thank | jingda

Production 07 March 2022
Final Preproduction Review 07 March 2022
Final Manuscript Decision 06 March 2022
Author Revision 03 March 2022
Preproduction Review 03 March 2022
First Manuscript Decision 03 March 2022
Rate Reviewers 03 March 2022
Peer Review 08 February 2022
Assign Editor 08 February 2022
Quality Check 08 February 2022
Submit Manuscript 07 February 2022
Overall experience was very good, both reviewers gave positive feedback, and the manuscript was accepted with minor formatting changes. The impact factor is also decent, 3.442.

(0) Thank | jingda

Three reviewers, one chose to accept it directly, one suggested minor revisions, and one asked me to add some references. Overall, it went smoothly and was accepted in about a month from the submission date.

(0) Thank | jingda

Has anyone in the same field ever submitted a review article to analyze how long it usually takes to receive a response? It has been almost a month since I submitted my manuscript, and the status has been showing as "Peer Review" all this time. How friendly is this journal towards review articles? I am very worried about being rejected.

(0) Thank | jingda

Hello, I would like to ask if the peer review process will display the information of the reviewers? Or will it only show "peer review complete" after the external review is done? I have always been in the dark about whether my paper has been sent for external review. I've seen that some people have the reviewer progress displayed.

(0) Thank | zsn123

Overall, the journal experience was good. If in a hurry, the editorial team will quickly provide processing results. Reviewers are also very serious, one reviewer gave 9 major revision suggestions and 6 minor revision suggestions, with a high evaluation. At first, it was difficult to handle, but we tried our best to respond and made experimental improvements where possible. Generally, if the major revisions can achieve a score of 75 or above, they will be accepted with minor revisions. Keep up the good work.

(3) Thank | kesu

A small mistake was made in the selection, it should be "Accepted after modification".

(0) Thank | 隐隐约约

Production 28 April
Style Check 28 April
Final Manuscript Decision 20 April-28 April Manuscript Accepted
Author Revision 12 April-20 April Author Revisions Complete
Preproduction Review 11 April-12 April Author Revision
First Manuscript Decision 11 April Major Revisions Required
Rate Reviewers 11 April Reviewer Rating Completed
Peer Review 22 March-11 April Peer Review Complete
Assign Editor 22 March Editor Assigned
Quality Check 22 March Quality Check Passed
Submit Manuscript 21 March Submission Complete

(3) Thank | 隐隐约约

This is my status information, the overall speed is very fastBelow is my statusPublish 12 October 2018 PublishedStyle Check 03 October 2018 Style RevisionsRereview Decision 03 October 2018 Manuscript AcceptedAuthor Revision 10 August 2018 - 17 August 2018First Manuscript Decision Major Revisions RequiredRate Reviewers 09 August 2018CompletedPeer Review 17 July 2018 - 09 August 2018Quality Check 16 July 2018Submit Manuscript 16 July 2018

(1) Thank | 砚今

The first paper of the doctoral period, after the overhaul.The article needs some innovation.The review of journals under OSA is very fast, but if one of them refuses, it cannot be transferred to other journals of QSA.This is still very smooth overall.Three reviewers, one raised ten comments, suggested overhaul, and the other two were definitely working, so it was recommended to receive.After I answered the question seriously and revised the paper, I was accepted very soon. I am very happy.

(0) Thank | 砚今

Reviewed this journal once and gave it a reference.If you accept the invitation and confirm the review, the document will enter your review system, otherwise you will only see the summary section.After accepting the invitation to review, it is required to complete as much as possible within two weeks.Review comments are received, modified, rejected, and others.It seems that there is no overhaul or minor repair.I am trying to do optics. The opinions given are biased towards overhaul. The opinions of another person are not seen. The final editor is doing the rejection of the manuscript, and guessing that another person should have rejected the manuscript.

(0) Thank | safasdfasdfs

Submitted for 8 days, the editor began to process, and the reviewer was quicker. The four reviewers refused to review the manuscript. The two agreed, and the luck was good. After two weeks, they returned to the comments and overhauled.I gave ten days to modify it and returned after the revision. The two reviewers took more than a week to agree to the review, and I was worried that they would not.The second review should give the reviewer a week, but both of them were delayed, and it took a total of ten days to return and receive.Overall, the deputy editor is more responsible.Now these journals are getting worse and worse, 哎

(0) Thank | 机器猫

Why three months, there is no news yet.Is it a tragedy, ah?

(0) Thank | 木子

The review speed is very fast; 3 weeks for review comments, 10 days to modify the time, directly after the revision.The page fee is slightly more expensive, and the 10-page length is close to 10,000 CNY.The article should be new, and the research direction is in line with the main direction of the journal. It is still very good.published 03 October 2017Publish 28 September 2017Manuscript accepted 26 September 2017Final manuscript decision 26 September 2017Opinion revision 18 September 2017Preproduction review 16 September 2017First manuscript decision 16 September 2017Rate reviewers 16 September 2017Peer review 23 August 2017Assign editor 23 August 2017Quality check 22 August 2017Submit manuscript 22 August 2017

(4) Thank | 759994286@qq.com

There is only one reviewer, the industry big cow, at first it was major revision, but also nervous, received the mail and looked at it, the comments were very good, and also greatly improved the level of the paper.It is very efficient from submission to publication for a total of two months.The overall situation is quite smooth.The impact factor was close to 3.0, the SCI Division 2 of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, the layout is also very good, the overall is really a good journal, recommend it.

(4) Thank | 一身正气的红猪

Publish 28 February 2017Production 24 February 2017Style Check 24 February 2017Final Manuscript Decision 13 February 2017Author Revision 08 February 2017Preproduction Review 07 February 2017First Manuscript Decision 07 February 2017Rate Reviewers 07 February 2017Peer Review 12 December 2016Assign Editor 05 December 2016Quality Check 02 December 2016Submit Manuscript 02 December 2016

(0) Thank | 讷讷呢

The review speed is very fast. It will be fixed from submission to publication within two months, but the layout fee is a little expensive.

(0) Thank | lixqust

Review is fast, has been peer review completed for one month, the editor still does not give results

(2) Thank | 封神演义

is two reviewers, the review speed is very fast, and the journal staff's attitude is also very good.Personally feel that this journal is still good, and the layout is better.Since it is open to access, you need to receive a plate fee.

(1) Thank | liangwf

OME is a new journal launched by OSA in 2012. The review speed is fast. The quality of the above articles is similar to that of OE and OL. Later, it can be developed into a journal with better optical materials..In the last two years, there have been many new journals of optical materials, such as Wiely's Adv Opt Mater, RSC's J Mater Chem C, ACS's ACS Photonics, and optical materials can be submited in many professional journals. The competition will be fierce. I hope OMEThere is a better development.

(1) Thank | Anonymous