Initial submission: 23/Sep/2019; Under review: 01/Dec/2019; Ready for decision: 01/Jan/2020; Revision response due date: 11/Mar/2020; With editor: 09/Feb/2020; Under review: 15/Sep/2020; Required reviews completed: 16/Sep/2020; Decision in process: 30/Sep/2020; accept: 20/Oct/2020.

(5) Thank | 曼珠沙华

2019. 10. 10, with journal; 2019.10.12 with editor: Dr. Qianbing Zhang (Monash University); 2019.10.16, with editor: Dr. Keh-Jian (Albert) Shou; 2020.04.22, under review; 2020.06.13, major revision; 2020.08.12, with editor - revision submitted to journal; 2020.08.13, revision sent back to authors (highlight needs revision) - revision submitted to journal (small formatting issues needed to be revised); 2020.08.14, revision submitted to journal - with editor; 2020.08.23, under review; 2020.09.26, accept. The review time is long, but I was very happy when I received the acceptance notice! It is my first article accepted by the journal in Q1. Cheers! I wish the journal better and better!

(5) Thank | 天天开心

With editor: 2018.4.7; With editor: 2018.4.28. Reviewer invited: 2018.5.7; Under review: 2018.5.7. Ready for decision: 2018.7.23. Under review: 2018.7.24. Maybe there was a conflict of opinions, and a third reviewer was found for arbitration. First decision: Major revision 2018.8.13. (Both were major revision, it may be that one reviewer’s comments were uploaded late, I was given two months of revision). With editor: 2018.10.11; Reviewer invited: 2018.10.16; Under review: 2018.10.16; Ready for decision: 2018.11.21; Second decision: 2018.11.21; Major revision with editor: 2018.12.17; Reviewer invited: 2018. 12.18. Ready for Decision: 2018.12.20. Accepted: 2018.12.20.

(40) Thank | 拼未来

I submitted on March 6, 2018. The status was With editor till June 2. June 2, 2018, Under review; July 6, 2018, Ready for decision; July 12, 2018, Decision pending. I still haven’t heard anything so far. The status under Final decision is decision pending, but under Letter it shows no decision made; what does this mean?

(17) Thank | jun

Dual communication is possible, you can send an email to the editor explaining the reasons for the return and revision with added funds, if the editor agrees then there is no problem.

(0) Thank | 布布大王

Does anyone know if TUST allows dual communication? Can additional funds be added during rework?

(0) Thank | Up and Up

Changes really don't bring good things. One reviewer first accepted and then rejected it. Praying for luck.

(0) Thank | 布布大王

6.13 2-2-1 One reviewer reviewed it very quickly.
6.16 Under Review Date updated, feels like every update is what the editor did, hope not to invite new reviewers to me...

(0) Thank | 布布大王

6.8 resubmit
6.10 UR
6.11 2-2-0 should be sent back to the first round of reviewers.

(0) Thank | 布布大王

6.02 STJ
6.07 UR 11-0-0
6.09 UR 11-2-0
6.12 UR 11-3-1 (Trembling with the speed of light review)

(0) Thank | Sivan

I submitted it in February last year, and it was revised in March. After submission, the editor added the previous reviewers and found three new reviewers. After the new reviewers' comments were submitted, it was revised again. It has been 16 days since the revision, but there has been no response. I am worried.

(0) Thank | 浮生

Do you have any friends in the field of firefighting? How is the speed of this journal reviewing articles related to tunnel fires? I saw on the journal's official website that the recently published articles are not particularly slow.

(0) Thank | Lfyuans

I don't know about the second review, don't panic, it is rare for the second review to be rejected.

(0) Thank | 布布大王

I started my internship in mid-May, and I am still waiting for the first review. It's a bit unsettling. How long has your senior brother been interning for?

(0) Thank | undefined

5.26 major revision, Editor-in-Chief Qianbing Zhang gave a 20-day revision period.

(0) Thank | 布布大王

Brother, when did you start dipping? My senior brother dipped for nearly a month in March.

(0) Thank | 布布大王

5.20 dip, need a major overhaul.

(0) Thank | accepter、、

5.23 dip Only two people have reviewed it, and two have run away. I need a major revision.

(0) Thank | 布布大王

Does anyone know how long the dip for this journal usually takes?

(2) Thank | undefined

May I know which editor handled this?

(0) Thank | MA F L

May I ask how long it takes to send for review after the major revision? It has been a month since the major revision, or is it still with the editor?

(0) Thank | 好运看我

I sent another 5, not sure what's going on, how about yours?

(0) Thank | easyy

Are the reviewers for the rework the same as the original ones? My paper was sent back for revision and then five more reviewers were assigned.

(0) Thank | easyy

After the major repair, there is still no movement from the Editor after 21 days...

(0) Thank | 好运看我

Just a note, feeling a bit anxious recently
12/24/22 submit
01/25/05 UR 4-0-0
02/09/25 UR 9-2-0
03/10/25 UR 9-2-1
04/07/25 UR 13-4-1 Second reviewer disappeared, editor added four more
04/30/25 RRC 13-4-2 Need a major revision

(0) Thank | 布布大王