It took about two months for the first review. There were 2 reviewers, and the minor revision was required. The revised manuscript was submitted in a week (Because only one comment was raised by two reviewers, which was easy to reply). About a month later, it was accepted. The specific review process is attached, for your information: 2020-5-22, submission; 2020-7-26, minor revision; 2020-7-31, resubmitted revision; 2020-8-29 completed accept.

(7) Thank | ligoudan-academic

2020.08.04 submission; 08.06 under review. It is really fast, and I wish it will succeed!

(5) Thank | Chang

For the first submission, it was sent for review in one month. The review took up to 4 months, and half a month for revising. After the revision was submitted, it was with editor for half a month, and then it was sent for review. Now it is the second day of being sent for review. I don't know what the final result will be.

(7) Thank | 在尔少年

This is a very good journal. The initial review took more than 2 months, but our manuscript was directly accepted after the revisions. The editorial department is professional. After the review process is complete, there is a review fee of about $150 USD.

(3) Thank | Anonymous

8.13 Under Review, hoping the reviewer will be lenient and accept it.

(0) Thank | 寒石

5.16 STJ
5.21 WE
5.27 UR
There were many changes in the UR time in between.
8.10 Major gave one month, three reviewers
20 comments
8.11 Revisions
Hope it can be accepted smoothly.

(0) Thank | 寒石

Excuse me, have you found the Word template for this journal? It's not on the official website, so does that mean there are no format restrictions?!

(0) Thank | boharry

Excuse me, was this journal removed by the editor?

(0) Thank | dengggg

Hello, how can I contact the editorial department?

(0) Thank | gaosh111

Hello, how can I contact the editorial department?

(0) Thank | gaosh111

Slow is really slow, but if you hit the jackpot, you will still be satisfied. This "if" is still acceptable.
November 20, 2024 first draft
March 20, 2025 minor revisions
July 5, 2025 acceptance
July 25, 2025 sign agreement for proofreading, assign DOI number
Receive electronic version three or four days later.

(0) Thank | 爱喝水的鱼

The journal's official website states that the paper submission format is either LaTeX or Word, but it recommends using Springer's LaTeX template. Where can the Word template be found? Does anyone know?

(0) Thank | JINGTIANDAXIA

How is it going, have you been rejected?

(0) Thank | hohaiweiwei

Hello, may I ask how many reviewers are there in total?

(0) Thank | wtzx

2025.7.25 With Editor

(0) Thank | zhqdd

May 29 under review
July 24 under review
Status keeps updating.

(0) Thank | Shuo_H

Submitted to Journal on July 24, 2025.

(0) Thank | zhqdd

3.08 Under Review
7.24 Under Review
Going crazy

(0) Thank | 好景难遇

How are you doing? I invested on June 19th, it's been over a month and it's still the same.

(0) Thank | dengggg

It's been over twenty days since I submitted on 6.23 and it's still WE. Is there any contact information for the editor? Please remind them or just reject the submission directly.

(0) Thank | 一切顺利

2025.3.27 Submission of manuscript
2025.4.10 Assignment of reviewers
2025.5.20 Major revision
2025.6.8 Revision
2025.7.4 Acceptance

(0) Thank | he yang

Has it been repaired?

(0) Thank | wtzx

How is it going now? Have you got the results? How is the submission to the civil engineering journal going?

(0) Thank | 萌少在奋斗

3.12 was still Under Review, and it's still Under Review until 6.30. I can't hold on any longer.

(0) Thank | ysy250

Please provide feedback within approximately 25 days.

(0) Thank | wtzx