2019.12.15 submitted; 2020.03.30 major revision; 2020.4.29 submitted R1; 2020.05.13 minor revision; 2020.06.04 submitted R2; 2020.06.15 accepted.

(2) Thank | 小黄鱼要翻身

1.24, awaiting administrator procession; 2.7, associate editor assigned; 2.8, awaiting reviewer selection; 2.9, reviewer assignment; 2.12, awaiting reviewer scores; 3.12, reject. There were 2 reviewers, one of them required major revision, the other one rejected it, and the administrator rejected it.

(2) Thank | Alpha_Wang

2018.09.05 Submitted; 2019.01.14 Email for process; 2019.01.16 Revision 1; 2019. 01.28 Revision 1 submitted; 2019.04.01 Email for process; 2019.04.24 Revision 2; 2019.05.15 Revision 2 submitted; 2019.06.26 Accepted.

(4) Thank | 孤独的黑板擦

The previous impact factor was high and it has dropped to 1.5, but it is still a little higher than NDT. I recommend the reviewers. I submitted the manuscript on January 23, and I received a reply on March 21. The review speed is about two months, the modification time is not limited, they just say ASAP. At present, my revised manuscript has been submitted for 10 days and I am waiting.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

It's been five months since the first review and there's still no result. They don't reply to emails either. I'm not submitting anything to them again.

(0) Thank | lripart

I have been waiting for a recommendation for 10 days, it's unbearable.

(0) Thank | zrj12345

From submission to decision for revision, it took two and a half months.

(0) Thank | HKH—accept

How long did the first trial take?

(0) Thank | pangyushashou

It's been two months since the second trial, and it's been two weeks awaiting a recommendation. Tired.

(0) Thank | HKH—accept

How long did it take for you to move from "Awaiting Reviewer Scores" to the next stage?

(0) Thank | pangyushashou

This great magazine is not in Zone 1, nor is it a top journal in Zone 2.

(0) Thank | Barry

How long have you been waiting?

(0) Thank | pangyushashou

Hello, may I ask how long have you been waiting?

(0) Thank | pangyushashou

I just responded to what you said by saying I am afraid.

(0) Thank | heyu803

SHM will not drop down to a lower level this year, as they have already dropped from Zone 1 to Zone 2 and are no longer in the top tier. Now they are even worse than TIM and MEASUREMENT.

(0) Thank | s_u

Extremely slow, the first review took 2 months, followed by major revisions 4 months later, and then another 4 months before being hired.

(0) Thank | 密西密西

January 5, 2025 Accepted

(0) Thank | 正在努力发论文

If you are unable to send emails, you can try using a different browser. It seems that Edge browser is not compatible.

(0) Thank | 稻草人

The research field is a bit niche, and it is not easy to find reviewers.
Submitted on May 20, 2024 (sent three reminders during this period, the editor responded patiently each time)
Major revisions on October 8, 2024
Returned manuscript on October 16, 2024
Awaiting Reviewer Assignment on December 4, 2024.

(0) Thank | 正在努力发论文

Have your opinions come back now? It has been ten months and I still have not received any opinions. It has been over a month since it changed to "Awaiting Recommendation" and I want to send an email to follow up. However, there is an error message in the system when trying to contact the journal, so I am unable to send the email.

(0) Thank | Lucaa

Slow, slow.

(0) Thank | 井晚打老虎2500245760

Is this journal peer-reviewed?

(0) Thank | 攀峰计划

Two weeks after the major revision, it can be considered as accepted. Thanks to the reviewers, editors, and associate editors.

(0) Thank | 努力毕业丫

2024.8.12 Proof, three working days required
2024.8.13 Return for revision
2024.8.28 Publication
For reference only
This article concludes here, thank you again to the reviewers and editors!

(0) Thank | 亲我一下

Continuously updating
Submitted on 16th August 2024, awaiting admin processing on 18th August, AE: Not Assigned
Still not assigned on 24th August.
Rejected, not in line with the direction.

(0) Thank | Supremeng