8.27 Submitted; 10.13 major revision required; there were three reviewers; one of them requested a major revision, a dozen comments were given, and the opinions were very pertinent. 10.29 Revised submission; 11.10 Second review required a revision, giving a small suggestion, and we revised and submitted it on the same day. 11.17 Accepted; 2021.1.2 online. The journal was very fast, and the review process was also very responsible. I hope Applied Physics A will get better and better.

(1) Thank | sky

8.27 Submission; 10.13 Major revision, three reviewers. One of them required a major revision, and a dozen comments were given. 10.29 Revised submission; 11.10 Second revision was required. They gave a small opinion and we revised it back on the same day, and then we are waiting for the result.

(1) Thank | sky

55th floor, (the review speed of) this journal was a bit slow. 2019.12.18, submitted; 2019.12.22, with editor; 2020.1.30, under review; 2020.2.6, major revision; 2020.2.27, submitted; 2020.3.14, accept.

(2) Thank | 不用刀的男人

After drafting my manuscript, I submitted to this journal on March 28th. I received generally positive reviews, most of which were constructive and helpful. Post-revisions, my manuscript was accepted on June 20th.

(0) Thank | arlafa@yeah.net.cn

What is the reason for rejection?

(0) Thank | yoha9527

Editor Assigned on 2025.05.02, rejected after 20 days of continuous review. Extremely low efficiency, please be cautious!!!

(0) Thank | rainday

2025.04.10 Submitted
2025.04.12 Editor Assigned
2025.04.28 Still Editor Assigned
It's really dragging on, this journal is going downhill. It was never like this before, people are getting frustrated...

(0) Thank | rainday

Reviewers Assigned status has been one month, are the reviewers reviewing in this journal in this status?

(0) Thank | 乔巴想发论文

4.12 UR

(0) Thank | Leo666

How long after receiving will the proof be ready?

(0) Thank | 困到自然醒

Currently, it is still in EA status.

(0) Thank | Leo666

It has been two weeks since submission, and we are still at the EA stage, which is quite slow.

(0) Thank | Leo666

One month goes by quickly.

(0) Thank | nnnyyy003

Hello, I wanted to ask if you have any news now?

(0) Thank | Titan_y

Mine too, after submitting for three or four days, the editor was arranged. After about two weeks, the date was updated, but the editor was still arranged. How long did it take for yours to be submitted for review?

(0) Thank | 许跑跑

11/20/2024 Major Revision
Three reviewers, with numerous review comments, received over 8000 responses.
11/25/2024 Revised manuscript submitted, awaiting feedback.

(0) Thank | 小葡萄爱吃甜草莓

How are you doing now? I am also doing the same.

(0) Thank | 发不出论文睡不着

The editor has been assigned for half a month now, but still hasn't received any manuscripts for review. It's really tough.

(0) Thank | 发不出论文睡不着

Submitted on Sep 20, 2024
Editor assigned on Sep 26, 2024
Editor assigned on Oct 10, 2024
It has been two weeks stuck at the stage of assigning an editor, which is unexpectedly slow. Just for reference.

(0) Thank | 撒盐少女

How long does it take for the status to change? Currently new submission.

(0) Thank | chen

One week.

(0) Thank | 别来无恙

How long after the editor assigned did it get sent for review? Mine has not been sent for review yet.

(0) Thank | xyzzzz?

Just Editor Assigned.

(0) Thank | 别来无恙

Has there been any changes in status? Mine was also submitted on the 18th, and the status has not changed yet.

(0) Thank | zzw

Have you updated your status? I submitted 12 days ago and it has been showing as "new submission." I have seen many comments saying that this journal is very fast in processing submissions, so I am wondering why it has been almost half a month and it still hasn't reached the editor. It's quite strange.

(1) Thank | 别来无恙