2020.05.20 Submission. 2020.11.5 The first review comments were returned. There were three reviewers, one of them accepted it directly, one of them agreed to accept it after revision, and last one required a major revision. The editor comment was that it can be accepted after revision as required. 2020.12.1 The revised manuscript submitted; 2020.12.2 Accepted.

(23) Thank | Yang Chao

The article was submitted in October 2019, and a reminder letter was written during the first review. There were three reviewers. The revision was submitted in the early March. It has taken more than three months for the second review, but there is no news. What’s more, two reminder letters were written during the second review, but I didn’t receive any news from the editor.

(0) Thank | 娴雅之选

Can there be journals more junk than this one? I have submitted my article for ten months and received no news. It was said to be a special issue, and would give a result within four months. But I only received an email in ten months saying that the manuscript is not suitable for this journal. It’s unbelievable!!! The most unacceptable thing is that if you reject a manuscript, why is there no review opinion? One year was just wasted and it was really deceiving. If you are a graduate, then it's bound to be delayed. A junk journal, super junk journal indeed. Oh, I just forgot, my junior and I had the same experience. His article took much longer than mine. It was rejected after 13 months without reviewer comments.

(6) Thank | ayang

4 Reviewers, too much. The cycle is too long, the number of articles in the year is also relatively small.

(0) Thank | 0.0

Taylor system is still With Journal Administrator.

(0) Thank | 的ded

Excuse me, I submitted my paper on the Taylor official website, but now I don't know why it has been redirected to the ScholarOne Manuscripts system. It is currently under review and not "out for review" as mentioned earlier. Did I submit it incorrectly? Can someone please clarify this for me?

(1) Thank | 的ded

Hello, I would like to inquire if the corresponding author confirmation is required. Thank you.

(0) Thank | Jiehaoyun

I also encountered this issue and also requested to upload the revised draft before February 20th. Can I add you on WeChat? I will add you.

(0) Thank | 活着就是折腾

I think it was submitted without formatting, and it was rejected because of the formatting. Even after resubmitting, it still is WJA after a month. May I ask, after being rejected, how long did it take for you to make the necessary formatting changes and become "with editor" upon resubmission?

(0) Thank | souluo

Submitted on September 4, received feedback on September 17, revised according to the journal's submission requirements and resubmitted. Then on December 22, two reviewers provided suggestions for revisions, requesting the revised version to be submitted by February 20, 2025.

(0) Thank | 活着就是折腾

The submission was made at the end of July in the 23rd year, and feedback from the first review was received at the end of May in the 24th year. After making revisions, it was resubmitted at the end of July, but there has been no response since then. According to the system, it is still in the hands of the administrator and has not been assigned to an editor yet. It is the slowest submission to the journal, and I am unsure if it will be rejected. If it is rejected, two years will have been wasted.

(0) Thank | 柏白柏

I have been reviewing for 11 months already, this journal is so slow.

(0) Thank | km123

7.21 submit
10.3 WE
10.23 Out for review (latest date change)

The status on the dashboard is accurate, but this journal is too slow.

(0) Thank | StephenLee

2024.8.28 submitted
10.14 out for reviewer
10.18 out for reviewer
10.21 out for reviewer

(0) Thank | 327

It has been more than five months since the submission on May 1st, 2024, and there is still no response. The reminder emails have also been ignored.

(0) Thank | dongsy

How long is your decision pending?

(0) Thank | accepted

12 March 2023 Manuscript Submitted
04 April 2023 With Editor
10 April 2023 Out for Review
01 August 2023 Revision Required, major revisions requested by 2 reviewers with professional feedback
25 October 2023 Revised Manuscript Submitted
20 November 2023 Manuscript Resubmitted, formatting issue led to rejection and resubmission
20 November 2023 With Journal Administrator
22 February 2024 Accepted, acceptance notification received

(0) Thank | jl

My dissertation also took 9 months to complete, it is the longest one I have ever worked on

(0) Thank | 327

The submission has been in the hands of the editor for nearly 5 months. A reminder was sent during the 3 months in between, but after waiting for over a month, it was rejected without even being reviewed. No feedback was provided. The journal is really slow! Time wasted for nothing. Those who are not time-sensitive can try submitting

(0) Thank | 科研王

Submitted for external review, stayed in the administrator's hands for 6 months, scary

(0) Thank | 123科研小白123

With editor, it usually takes around one to two days. If it is with the administration, then it will be within four months, depending on the situation. Generally, it will not exceed four months. The external review process will last around four months, and usually will not exceed this number

(0) Thank | 科研闲人

How long does this journal with editor usually take?

(0) Thank | 123科研小白123

Submitted on 2022.10.01
Rejected in January 2023 due to innovative content but poor grammar. The manuscript cannot be sent for review. It is suggested to revise and resubmit.
Resubmitted on 2023.02.07
Sent for review on the same day with editor on April 1st, 2023
Still out for review on April 10th, 2023
Minor revisions requested on August 1st, 2023. Both reviewers accept the manuscript with a total of around ten review comments.
Revision requested on August 25th, 2023 due to formatting issues.
Continued revision on August 30th, 2023
Considering acceptance on October 11th, 2023
Four reminders sent during the process, all received replies. It is advised to politely send reminders through the corresponding author's email directly to the editorial office (Four reminders sent in mid-March, mid-May, early September, and mid-September

(2) Thank | 科研闲人

Submitted in October 22, rejected in January 23 due to too many grammar errors despite innovative points, suggested to revise and resubmit. Resubmitted on February 7, status changed to "out for review" on April 1, and review process lasted until October 4 with some adjustments on the Army Day (August 1). Finally accepted in the early morning of November 10 after revisions. In summary, the manuscript was pushed four times, don't hesitate to follow up if necessary, but always use polite language and inquire via email. Generally, it takes about 40-50 days for acceptance after revisions

(0) Thank | 科研闲人

Are you for rework submission? Or for preliminary?

(0) Thank | 科研闲人