It was submitted on June 8th and accepted on December 23rd. The review was very serious, and it was revised 3 times during it.

(13) Thank | isogeny

It was just accepted yesterday and the speed was pretty good. Maybe I just had a good luck. I heard that the review speed has been much slower in the past two years, and it even took some articles more than a year to be accepted.

(13) Thank | makeitbetter

This is still a very good journal. The editor is very serious. I changed it twice and thought it was over. I came back with a third revision and re-did some experiments and data.

(7) Thank | frost-forest@hotmail.com

30 Oct 2023 Submission
31 Oct 2023 Invitation for Reviewers
13 Jan 2024 Received a reply from one reviewer, but the editor went to find someone else, causing a delay here
19 Apr 2024 Revision requested - minor revisions after the first review
05 May 2024 Reviewer report(s) received
11 May 2024 Submission accepted
29 May 2024 Published online

It took nearly 6 months for the first review.

(2) Thank | 八重寄子

The translation of the text "速度一般般" into English is "average speed."

(2) Thank | 萍水相逢

"From submission to acceptance, it took 14 months."

(0) Thank | 科研渣强哥

At the beginning of the year, I submitted an article that has already been accepted. This journal used to be in Zone 1 in 2015, but now it's in Zone 3. The relevant field has cooled down a bit.

(4) Thank | 40 metres of machete

Submitted to received just 15 months ago, I wonder if there is anyone who has been waiting longer than me?

(0) Thank | 忘心

It has been over three months under review, and there is still no outcome.

(0) Thank | zeguo

Are the reviewers after modification the same as the ones during the initial review? It has been a month since I submitted the revised version, and the status is still "Editor Assignment Pending".

(0) Thank | zhulin_2016

It took nearly 13 months.

(1) Thank | daiside

Very good, but the speed is really slow. I submitted it around this time last year and it was confirmed for acceptance in December. Then I didn't hear anything again. Waiting for proofreading.

(15) Thank | daiside

Very good journal!There have been two articles.Ready to select for the third.

(5) Thank | winter.zhao.ict@gmail.com

The speed of the recent review has slowed down, and it has been submitted for half a month, and has not been submitted for review.Another review was also slow.I don't know how it happened

(2) Thank | 美好

The speed of review is ok, the first trial is about two months, the second trial is one month, the editor is about one week, and the review comments are pertinent.

(9) Thank | aaa

Review has been slowed down recently,I don't know what happened. An article was selectd in December last year and is still in the review.The editor tweeted twice and didn't work.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

has selectd for both, and it feels easier.The impact factor is also relatively high.

(1) Thank | Anonymous

The current impact factor is around 2, which is quite good in physics journals.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Reviewing speed is fast, from submission to acceptance (middle 2 major overhauls 1 minor repair) for a total of 4 months, reviewing expert opinions are very pertinent!

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Journal Homepage URL: http://www.editorialmanager.com/qinp/

(0) Thank | Anonymous