After two major revisions and two minor revisions, the acceptance is granted. The review periods are 3 months, 5 weeks, 7 weeks, 1 month, and 3 weeks respectively. It is quite strict, but both the reviewers and editors are very responsible.

(0) Thank | styl

2023.03.06, created
2022.03.09, assigned to senior editor
2022.03.15, assigned to associate editor
2022.03.31, Awaiting reviewers score
2022.05.26, Awaiting AE Preliminary Decision

(0) Thank | niannianwang

Hello, I would like to ask if this journal has an "under review" status? It has been over a month since I submitted and it is still "awaiting reviewer assignment." What is the situation?

(0) Thank | XIAOHULU

Hello, I would like to ask if this journal has an "Under Review" status? It has been over a month since I submitted it and it is still "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment."

(0) Thank | XIAOHULU

In the end, it was still rejected, with two reviewers and over 40 review comments.

(0) Thank | obiebie

2022.06.23, CREATED
2022.07.06, assigned to Senior Editor
2022.07.18, assigned to Associate Editor
2022.07.20, Awaiting Reviewer Selection
2022.07.27, Awaiting Reviewer Assignment
2022.08.22, Awaiting Reviewer Selection

(0) Thank | obiebie

Revised response, that is the modified reply. We need to provide a detailed response to the modifications suggested by the reviewer

(0) Thank | 维尔娜菲茨杰拉德

Less, mostly spelled in full Chinese names

(0) Thank | 维尔娜菲茨杰拉德

What does "俢回" mean?

(0) Thank | 修然小公主

Can the author write their name in Chinese?

(0) Thank | 平原文波

The past was good, but the current downfall is frightening. It might be too difficult to return to the level of 3 points next year

(0) Thank | 凌霄高洁

Review Speed: 2.0 | Acceptance Rate: 25.0
Experience Sharing: Around 120 articles per year, with a relatively short review period of around 30 days. Short review cycles with low article volume correspond to high rejection rates and higher difficulty

(0) Thank | 折梅白旋

Review speed: 1.0. Experience sharing: ScholarOne's submission system is quite unique, but a one-month review cycle is still acceptable. This journal is very formal, but the number of publications is too low, making it difficult to get published

(0) Thank | 墟散雅凡

Review speed: 2.0 | Submission hit rate: 50.0
Experience sharing: The article submitted in November 2011 was assigned number 357. The number of articles published in 2011 was 201, so the estimated hit rate of the submission is around 50%. The article underwent one major revision and one minor revision before being accepted in June of this year

(0) Thank | 凌霄高洁

Will it drop to 3 points next year? If it drops below 3 points, it will not be worth it

(0) Thank | 凌霄高洁

Will it fall again next year? What should I do if it falls below?

(0) Thank | 凌霄高洁