Submitted in early November, sent for review after nearly a month, 12.09 minor revision required, 12.10 revision submitted, 12.13 accepted. Overall, it is quite fast.

(0) Thank | Shouyao Liu

I haven't submitted to this journal for several years. It seemed to be faster in the past. In this time, a major revision was required after two months of review. In addition to the main issues of principle, there are 25 opinions for revision. It took 2 weeks to revise and resubmit it. After 2 weeks, requirements for minor revisions were received, which was mainly about text corrections. It was resubmitted after revisions and got accepted on the same day. The reviewer is still professional.

(1) Thank | 分享者-1973

This journal is relatively strict in terms of the requirements and is not very easy to be accepted. Most of the reviewers are editors and the review is tough.

(0) Thank | 热衷科研

It has been 50 days and still no news, how is everyone doing?

(0) Thank | Juntao Zhu

It has been 10 minutes since the submission and it is still in this status.

(0) Thank | 丁虹达

Hello, fellow "academicians, Changjiang scholars, distinguished young scholars, outstanding young scholars". I would like to ask, is this manuscript currently under external review or in the hands of the editor?

(0) Thank | 开心的马卡龙

Submitted on May 23, 2024
Major revisions based on feedback received on June 30, 2024
Revised on July 2, 2024
Minor revisions based on feedback received on July 8, 2024
Revised on the evening of July 8, 2024, and received acceptance message just over ten minutes later. Overall, it was quite quick and smooth.

(0) Thank | Lee

It's amazing, I submitted it at 9:59 and got rejected at 10:10, I have to admit, that was quick

(0) Thank | 迷路的火星人

It's really not easy, thank you editor, thank you judges and teachers. I hope part L will get better and better. It's very likely that the impact factor will rise to Tier 3 next year. The quality of this journal is good, but it took a lot of effort to accept only two articles... It's definitely a fighter in Tier 4...

(0) Thank | 天涯的心跳

There is nothing to say about this journal. The editor-in-chief is good, but the judges feel a bit obsessive. The review process is not very fast, which makes it quite difficult.

(0) Thank | 天涯的心跳

Classmate, did the editor ask you to modify the language?

(0) Thank | keeper

From submission to acceptance, it took only one month. That's pretty fast. I submitted it in the evening, and it was reviewed the next morning.

(0) Thank | stevenson

The speed is really fast. I submitted it at 9:31 in the evening, and just 13 minutes later, I received a rejection email. This efficiency is impressive. I can't even finish reading my own article in 13 minutes, and editors are just editors!

(6) Thank | younger！

Journal Homepage URL: http://pil.sagepub.com/

(0) Thank | Anonymous

The review speed is slow, but it is easy.

(1) Thank | Anonymous