I think that for linear physics and soft matter physics, this PRE is still a very good journal; the editor is very dedicated, and the reviewer's opinion is also very pertinent. I published in the journal last year. This journal is also the top journal in soft matter and nonlinear physics. The IF is not that high, though.

(3) Thank | Anonymous

15Apr25	Editorially approved for publication
04Mar25	10Apr25 Review request to referee; report received
27Feb25	Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author
11Feb25	26Feb25	Ed. decision and/or ref. comments to author; response rcvd
02Jan25	08Feb25	Review request to referee; report received
02Jan25	08Jan25	Review request to referee; report received
02Jan25	Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author
17Dec24	Acknowledgment sent to author
16Dec24	Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author

(1) Thank | 初子佳

Submitted on December 5th, 24
Received reviewer comments on February 28th, 25
Revised and completed on March 5th, 25
Accepted on March 25th, 25
Working on quantum algorithms

(0) Thank | 彳余 禾刂

Status: submitted 10th December 2024
With editors 10th December 2024
With referees 12th December 2024
With Authors 10th February 2025 (for revisions)
Resubmitted 12th March 2025 (response already submitted)
Blessings...

(0) Thank | 一念执着

Record submission process
2025.03.05 Submit & With editor

(0) Thank | 咸鱼一条

Latest update: Received feedback from two reviewers, currently with editors, fingers crossed...

(0) Thank | 一念执着

Blessed be with referees on 12Dec24.

(0) Thank | 一念执着

The information is not showing up in the system, but I found it by checking the status through the link https://authors.aps.org/Submissions/status/. It's so magical!

(0) Thank | 一念执着

Boss, help me!! The article I submitted today was already in the hands of the editor, but when I logged into the system just now, the article has disappeared! Even the submission record is gone! Why is this happening? Was it rejected? I haven't received any emails either!! Have you ever encountered this situation?

(0) Thank | 一念执着

Boss, help!! The article I submitted today is already in the hands of the editor, but just now when I logged into the system, the article mysteriously disappeared! Even the submission record is gone! Why is this happening? Was it rejected? I didn't receive any email either!!! Have you ever encountered this situation?

(0) Thank | 一念执着

Big guys, help!!! The article I submitted today is already in the hands of the editor, but when I logged into the system just now, the article has disappeared! Even the submission record is gone! Why is that? Was it rejected? I didn't receive any email!!!

(0) Thank | 一念执着

Blessed...status: submitted 10dec2024
With editors 10dec2024

(0) Thank | 一念执着

Status: Submitted 10Dec2024
Blessings...

(0) Thank | 一念执着

The comments from the PRE reviewers are extremely professional, rigorous, and constructive! It is truly a top authority journal in the field of nonlinear physics and statistical physics, with high recognition and worth investing in! If luck is a little better, there are already 3 papers now! Unfortunately, I encountered a very, very unpleasant reviewer in the middle, but it is still very lucky to be able to publish 2 papers! I hope the journal will continue to improve!

(1) Thank | Dynamics

Submitted on March 26
Revised on July 2
Re-revised on August 6
Accepted on August 23
Published on October 8

(1) Thank | shujunyy123

After being rejected, Tata Kai succeeded in the second submission with minor revisions and was accepted directly

(2) Thank | lydasein

A very good journal in the field of nonlinear physics, unfortunately classified as a third-tier journal by the Chinese Academy of Sciences. After minor revisions, the paper was accepted, taking exactly 4 months from submission to publication

(2) Thank | yang255125

If the article is highly innovative, it is recommended to submit to PRE. Two articles have been published, and the summary is that the acceptance of innovation by reviewers and editors is very high. A series of journals highly recognized in the physics community

(18) Thank | Yutyyy

My dream magazine, post a few waistcoats and they will be stiff

(92) Thank | 比鲁斯

Undoubtedly a great journal of nonlinear physics! There are many high-quality works in it, and L is the one

(34) Thank | 纳维

23 Feb 2023  submit
27 Feb 2023  under review
17 May 2023  review completed, major revision. 
15 Jun 2023  responses submitted.
10 Jul 2023  review completed.
14 Jul 2023  accepted.

Translation:
23rd February 2023  - Submitted
27th February 2023  - Under review
17th May 2023  - Review completed, major revision. 
15th June 2023  - Responses submitted.
10th July 2023  - Review completed.
14th July 2023  - Accepted.

(1) Thank | 狂飙_NDyn

The industry influence is still significant. It was submitted on March 21 and accepted on June 20. It emphasizes explanations based on physical mechanisms and the questions asked by the reviewers are relevant. It is a good journal.

(0) Thank | 一块积木

What is the final result of the revised and resubmitted?

(0) Thank | dingdang001

The JCR of WoB is divided into tiers every 25%, resembling a bucket shape. On the other hand, the JCR of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (CAS) is divided in a pyramid shape, with a smaller proportion for the first tier, fewer for the second tier, and an increase in the number of journals in the third and fourth tiers.

(0) Thank | EchoGee

The journal has good quality, high recognition within the industry, and the reviewers are extremely professional. The questions they raise are sharp and to the point. The editors are also responsible and there is a noticeable improvement in the quality of the articles from submission to acceptance.

(6) Thank | YDDDu