I have submitted two papers to this journal; the first paper took about half a yr until it was accepted.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Very good journal, undergraduate students can also submit (for the senior project, because of the birth of the mentor, can only write and submit by themselves), no educational discrimination.
The review speed is also very fast.
submit 23-Sep-2024
Major Revision 04-Nov-2024 Five reviewers, gave more than 50 suggestions (many omissions in the first submission)
resubmit 28-Nov-2024
Minor Revision 10-Dec-2024 Three reviewers (not sure if the other two have disappeared), the fourth and fifth reviewers agreed to accept, the first reviewer gave three suggestions (one of which was that the images in the submitted manuscript did not display properly)
resubmit 11-Dec-2024
Formal Accept (17-Dec-2024)
PUBLISHED 27 January 2025
It also happened to be published on New Year's Eve in 2025. Not OA, encryption of images.

(0) Thank | L1nk_S3c

Hello, is this journal submission template in two columns or one column? I noticed that the template provided by IOP is in two columns, but the articles published in this journal are in one column format. Can you please advise?

(0) Thank | David_w

The Chinese company submitted the pre-acceptance 20 days in advance.

(0) Thank | qyghxx

May I ask how long it will take for you to produce the results?

(0) Thank | LLLLLLLXXXXXL

May I ask how long it will take to see the results in this situation?

(0) Thank | LLLLLLLXXXXXL

Hello, has the result of the second review come out? I have also been waiting for the decision of the second review for a week.

(0) Thank | qyghxx

How long does it usually take for Physica Scripta to provide the results after major revisions?

(0) Thank | LLLLLLLXXXXXL

May I ask how long it generally takes for the results of a major revision in Physica Scripta to be released?

(0) Thank | LLLLLLLXXXXXL

No need, usually this is an issue with the reviewer. If a reviewer does not review the manuscript, a new reviewer needs to be found. This happened to me before, the original reviewer did not review my work (rejected it in the first review), so another reviewer was invited to review it later.

(0) Thank | 好好的学

After half a month of major repairs, the status changed to "waiting for decision". After a week, it changed to "waiting for review report". Should I send an email to inquire about this?

(0) Thank | LLLLLLLXXXXXL

After the renovation, I encountered a situation similar to yours. Do you think it is necessary to send an email to inquire about it?

(0) Thank | LLLLLLLXXXXXL

After sending it out for four months, suddenly received a request to submit an author change form, but the form was not attached in the email. Sent an email to inquire but still haven't received a reply after a few days, it's a weird operation.

(0) Thank | MierBrother

Where did you find this flowchart?

(0) Thank | dyj1228

May I ask what is the status display after you have made the revisions? Why has mine been sent for external review again?

(0) Thank | dyj1228

You can check the current status on the website, whether it is temporarily accepted or waiting for reviewer comments. If it is temporarily accepted, then wait a little longer. If it changes to waiting for reviewer comments, then it has been submitted again, which means you have to wait again and may need to make revisions.

(0) Thank | 好好的学

I also temporarily accepted, it has been half a month now, there has been no follow-up news, but the email said it is 24 hours online, now I am also very anxious...

(0) Thank | MagicLoren

2025.03.18 Online

Can you translate the following paragraph into English: 2025.03.18 Online

(0) Thank | 叶微凉

2024.11.13 Submitted
2025.01.22 Major revision
2025.02.17 Revised
2025.03.18 Provisionally accepted
2025.03.18 Formally accepted

(0) Thank | 叶微凉

Recently, I don't know what's going on with this journal. I have submitted quite a few articles myself, and this is the first time I have encountered this situation. My article was accepted at the end of December, but it still hasn't been published. It's really frustrating. Now, I see a lot of articles from the end of last year piled up in the "accepted" section, and I'm still not sure how the editorial department is going to handle them.

(0) Thank | haozy

11.1 Transfer to PS Journal;
12.20 Revision (Moderate revision);
1.2 Revise;
1.14 Pre-acceptance;
2.12 Official acceptance;

(0) Thank | SCUTWG

This journal is not sure what is happening now. Last year, one revision was rejected. The editors all requested revisions. This year, it is estimated that the number of submissions will be strictly controlled, otherwise there will be a warning.

(0) Thank | O;AIHV

This journal is in a state of uncertainty. Last year, one article after another was rejected for revisions. The editors all requested revisions. This year, it is estimated that the number of submissions will be strictly controlled.

(0) Thank | O;AIHV

I have five reviewers, four agreed, one rejected. The editor rejected it, speechless.

(0) Thank | 雷诺111

Caution! After two months of submission, three reviewers were assigned. The first two reviewers gave one minor revision and one rejection. The editor sent it for a second review. The third reviewer provided minor revisions with very positive feedback. However, the final decision was a rejection, citing belief in the first reviewer's opinion. In just two sentences, they claimed my article lacked a model, showing they never really read it carefully! With one minor revision and one rejection, they ultimately rejected it, wasting over two months of time.

(0) Thank | O;AIHV