Please notice the following situations. I submitted an article in September last year, and it was rejected until early February this year, after a major revision in December. What’s worse, due to the epidemic, my graduation was postponed. I will not submit manuscripts to it again. But to be honest, the review comments were very professional. The three reviewers gave comments of a total of almost 5 pages, but what I am curious about that you reviewed four months and then only gave me four weeks to make major revisions and make up a bunch of experiments.

(0) Thank | 我不合适做科研

This journal’s review period is slow. The data requirements are comprehensive and the page fees are estimated to be about 10,000 yuan. It is published very quickly online. If you are not anxious about your graduation timeline, you can consider it.

(1) Thank | Anonymous

Review Speed: 1.0 | Submission Hit Rate: 50.0
Experience Share: submitted to journal 1 Nov
Editor assigned 7 Nov
under review 18 Nov
under review 05 Dec 
under review 25 Dec
Reviews Completed 29 Dec 
Major revision 4 Jan
Editor assigned 2 Feb
under review 6 Feb
under review 7 Feb
Reviews Completed 10 Feb
Minor revision 18 Feb
Revision Submitted 25 Feb
Accept 1 March
Online 8 March
Total 4 months, friends, come on and strive to break 10~

(0) Thank | 霹雳香卉

Rarely a few toxicology journals in the first district, with an annual inclusion of about 50 articles, and they are also open-source, so it is normal for their impact factor to be around eight or nine. If Toxicological Science becomes open-source, its advantage is estimated to not last long. However, the quality of peer review is still good!

(0) Thank | 顺子

Review speed: 2.0 | Submission acceptance rate: 5.0 | Page charge: 3565.0 
Emphasized research direction: environmental pollution 
Experience sharing: Submitted on January 2, 2021, accepted on May 20, with two major revisions in between and five reviewers. This was a rare submission experience. The reviewers were very professional and dedicated. The process was very challenging, replying to the reviewers' questions was painful, but I did learn a lot!

(0) Thank | 雨巷少年微月

Review speed: 3.0 Experience sharing: The article has been accepted

(0) Thank | 靖薇baby

Review speed: 1.0 | Submission hit rate: 25.0 Experience sharing: 8.577 - 2-year Impact Factor 9.628 - 5-year Impact Factor 2.165 - Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP) 2.742 - SCImago Journal Rank (SJR

(0) Thank | 靖薇baby

Review speed: 1.0 | Submission acceptance rate: 25.0
Experience sharing: Recently submitted an article, 4 reviewers, over 40 major and minor issues, carefully revised for 3 months, then came back with over 10 more issues, revised again, and still no results. Overall feeling, the requirements are quite strict, reviewers are very serious, and all are authorities in the field

(0) Thank | 靖薇baby

Review Speed: 3.0 | Submission Hit Rate: 25.0 Experience Sharing: Submitted on June 26th, rejected on August 27th. Four reviewers provided sharp comments, mainly criticizing the lack of clear mechanistic explanation in the paper, which was deemed more descriptive in nature. It is indeed difficult to submit to a top toxicology journal, with very high standards, especially in terms of mechanistic requirements. The reviewers are experts in the field and their comments were insightful. However, could the review process be faster? It took over two months to receive a rejection, which wasted time

(0) Thank | 凌霄高洁

I published an article after 12 years, which was about the toxicity of nanomaterials. The review process was very slow. I submitted it in February and it was finally accepted in September. It went through two rounds of revisions during this period. The reviewers were very responsible and always raised several pages of questions each time. The data requirements were quite comprehensive and there were also page charges. It cost around 10,000 RMB. The online publication was very fast, so if you are not in a rush to graduate, you can consider submitting your work

(0) Thank | 暴风长志

Bullish, will it rise again next year?

(0) Thank | 凌霄高洁