Rereview Decision 23 November 2020; 23 November 2020 Manuscript Accepted; Rereview 03 November 2020; 23 November 2020 Rereview Complete; Final Manuscript Decision 28 October 2020; 03 November 2020 Repeat Review; Author Revision 13 October 2020; 28 October 2020 Author Revisions Complete; First Manuscript Decision 12 October 2020; 12 October 2020 Major Revisions Required; Peer Review 22 August 2020; 12 October 2020 Peer Review Complete; Submit Manuscript 20 August 2020; 20 August 2020 Submission Complete. It should be originally available within two months, but unfortunately I met unreliable reviewers, which took a lot of time without giving any useful comments. Fortunately, it got accepted at the end.

(1) Thank | 浮生过客

It is the first article during my master period. There were 2 reviewers, and it was not very difficult. 2020.10.16, production; 2020.20.16 style checked; 2020.10.16, production; 2020.20.14, final manuscript decision; 2020.10.16, manuscript accepted; 2020.10.06, author revision; 2020.10.14, author revisions completed; 2020.10.04, reproduction review; 2020.10.06, author revision; 2020.10.04, first manuscript decision; 2020.10.04, major revisions required; 2020.10.04, rate reviewers; 2020.10.04, reviewer rating completed; 2020.08.19, peer review; 2020.10.04, peer review completed.

(1) Thank | 新城

OE now has a 15-day response limit for reviewers. The three reviewers of the article gave very good opinions. The editor required a major revision, and the editor directly accepted it in 10 days after resubmission. It did not exceed one month from submission to acceptance. 12 May 2020 Production; 10 May 2020 Final Manuscript Decision; 12 May 2020 Manuscript Accepted; 01 May 2020 Author Revision; 10 May 2020 Author Revisions Complete; 30 April 2020 Preproduction Review; 01 May 2020 Author Revision; 30 April 2020 First Manuscript Decision; 30 April 2020 Major Revisions Required; 15 April 2020-30 April 2020 Peer Review; 15 April 2020 Assign Editor; 14 April 2020 Submit Manuscript.

(7) Thank | ying0620

My most recent paper was rejected from this journal, and I disagree with some of the reviewer’s comments. I wrote to the staff noting this. However, the editor quickly replied to the message "I believe there are good reasons why this manuscript is not suitable for Optics Express.” Frustrating. My Conclusion: If you are unfortunately rejected, especially in the OSA journal, unless it is an editorial mistake, no matter how justified your opinion, you are out of luck.

(11) Thank | 匿名人士

Can only the corresponding author or all authors receive the proofreading and payment emails? Can we see the proof in the submission system? It has been a week since production started, and there have been no further updates. My boss hasn't forwarded me any emails, so I feel awkward asking for an update.

(0) Thank | 小鸣

Who will receive the proofreading email and payment email, only the corresponding author or all authors? Can we see the proof in the submission system? It has been a week since production started, but there have been no further updates. My boss has not forwarded me any emails, so I am hesitant to inquire further.

(0) Thank | 小鸣

Can only the corresponding author receive the proofreading emails and payment emails, or can all authors receive them? Can we see the proofreading status in the submission system?

(0) Thank | 小鸣

Help, I have a reviewer who completed the review in less than a week, I am so scared.

(0) Thank | wzfans

I have been on rework for three weeks as well, I don't know if it's because of the summer vacation.

(0) Thank | 华小烟

It has been 23 days since the decision to review was made and there has been no progress, which is outrageous.

(0) Thank | 陈晨晨

7.29 Assign Editor, is it normal for it to still be in this state? Are there any experts who understand this, please advise, thank you.

(0) Thank | nian_ai

I am 7.29 Assign Editor, still in this status until now, and there is no email to urge. It doesn't feel like the speed of OE +1.

(0) Thank | nian_ai

No movement, it's too unbelievable.

(0) Thank | 陈晨晨

The manuscript has been accepted in the evening, without a second review, and will be accepted directly after one week of editing.

(0) Thank | dafafasfa

I am the same, gained nearly 10 pounds after the renovation, how about you?

(0) Thank | dafafasfa

Is this the speed that OE should have? It's one thing to wait for five months for the first review, but to have no updates for ten days after the final draft is accepted?

(0) Thank | 陈晨晨

On July 16, three reviewers agreed to accept the submission, and the editor requested a major revision.

(1) Thank | emohappy

My journal was rejected in Optics Express, and they are suggesting I transfer it to another journal of Optica, which has a low impact factor. Should I do that?

(0) Thank | hih

@川2025
That's fast.

(0) Thank | nil

2025-07-03 提交
2025-07-03 同行评审5

(0) Thank | 川2025

No editor is assigned for more than two weeks. I am afraid. Is it a sign of desk rejection?

(0) Thank | Random

No editor is assigned for more than two weeks. I am afraid. Is it a sign of desk rejection?

(0) Thank | Random

No editor is assigned for more than two weeks. I am afraid. Is it a sign of desk rejection?

(0) Thank | Random

No editor is assigned for more than two weeks. I am afraid. Is it a sign of desk rejection?

(0) Thank | Random

Hello, may I ask if there is any news yet?

(0) Thank | 我要accept