The level of the journal is average, and two articles have been published in it, and the impact factor has risen a bit fast. I know a senior who has a relationship with the editorial board of this journal. He said that it would be acceptable if basically the work was complete, and the requirements for innovation were not high. The quality of the articles was uneven. In recent years, the main work of this journal should be how to increase the impact factor as soon as possible. Please don’t blame me and I just tell the truth.

(11) Thank | Anonymous

Rejection was received within one week. No significant steps forward in the field of optical methods applied to engineering problems can be found in such a submission. Then it is recommended to transferred to journals focusing on antennas and optical communications.

(0) Thank | dreger

A great journal, always publishes many high-quality papers that don’t lose to the papers in Q1 journals. I submitted the manuscript twice. The first time the reviewers did not seem to be very expert, raising a dozen comments, and it was rejected. However, after I resubmitted the manuscript, attaching my responding to last review comments, new reviewers were arranged. Then it was accepted with minor revisions again. The second submission went smoothly and it was accepted after a minor revision. My direction is 3D measurement.

(17) Thank | Admirer

This journal is really fast, about a week to reply, but my paper was rejected. I admit that my paper structure really needs improvement

(0) Thank | Anonymous

I haven't heard anything from my editor for two weeks.

(0) Thank | 深度学习不深度

Within one week with the editor.

(0) Thank | chen

Excuse me, how long have you been with the editor?

(0) Thank | 深度学习不深度

February 9, 2025 - Submission
March 17, 2025 - Minor revisions
April 15, 2025 - Acceptance
April 22, 2025 - Publication

(0) Thank | chen

Will the impact factor of the journal drop to the third quartile next year as it has been decreasing year by year?

(0) Thank | Andy

Hasn't it been submitted for review for a month yet?

(0) Thank | 好发发发发

The AIGC test is not very accurate, as it is possible for reviewers to only use AI for polishing and still be detected. Therefore, you can report the situation, but the results are uncertain.

(0) Thank | lin_sen6

One of the reviewers clearly provided a review generated by AI (confirmed by AIGC detection). Can we address this issue in the editor's rebuttal?

(0) Thank | wzaxl123

I haven't submitted it for review for a month.

(0) Thank | yeye809

Submitted to journal on 15th March 2025. With editor on 17th March 2025. It's been a week and still not sent for review, so frustrating.

(0) Thank | xuaner1111

2024.08.23 Submitted to journal
2024.08.25 With editor
2024.08.26 Under Review
2024.12.31 Under Review
2025.01.11 RRC
2025.01.15 revised
2025.01.29 With editor
2025.02.06-2025.03.16 Under Review
2025.03.16 RRC
2025.03.17 DIP
2025.03.17 Minor Revision
2025.03.21 With Editor
2025.03.23 Accept

It took 7 months, during which no emails were sent to urge the editor. The status changed on the mini-program for the first review, inviting 19 reviewers but only two agreed to review. The second review took two months, and it was later discovered that a third reviewer had been invited. The editor and reviewers were very responsible and provided many constructive suggestions. Wishing OLE continued success and hoping that everyone's submissions will be accepted soon.

(0) Thank | 那咋办嘛

May I ask if after the journal revision, will a new track link be provided? Is the link supposed to look like this: https://track.authorhub.elsevier.com/?uuid=XXXX?

(0) Thank | chen

25.3.3 sub
25.3.4 with editor

(0) Thank | 遇然

25.3.3 sub
25.3.4 we

(0) Thank | 遇然

Is it possible for this journal to drop to the third quartile?

(0) Thank | 虾米

May I ask how long it takes for the DIP to get results?

(0) Thank | 如幻。

How long does it take for DIP to have results?

(0) Thank | 如幻。

May I ask if you were rejected later?

(0) Thank | yutongguo0808

Required Reviews Completed 03/08/2025. 3 reviewers agreed, and 2 reviewers completed their reviews.

(0) Thank | ljw

May I ask how is the result? How long does the dip take?

(0) Thank | ljw

Submitted to Journal 02/18/2025
With Editor 02/18/2025
With Editor 02/20/2025
Under Review 02/21/2025 7-1-0
Under Review 03/01/2025 7-1-0
Under Review 03/03/2025 14-3-0

(0) Thank | ljw