2020.03.03 Submission; 2020.04.01 First revision submitted; 2020.04.29 Second revision submitted; 2020.05.08 Accepted. The journal has high requirements for language, and focuses on the innovation.

(13) Thank | Lsb

3 articles were submitted, 2 was accepted and 1 was rejected. The first article was accepted within 1 year, the second article was accepted within 9 months, and the third article was rejected (the article did not emphasize our own innovations and was misunderstood by a reviewer as there is no innovation). It feels quite good to publish two articles during the undergraduate period.

(62) Thank | 菜鸟+1

I have submitted two articles. The first article was revised twice and it took 8 months in total before being accepted finally. The second article was a review, it was revised once, which lasted 5 months. It was finally accepted. It was not as demanding as I thought, but what did must be meaningful and attract editors and reviewers. My English is so bad, I was asked to change the language carefully in both reviewers’ comments I finally found a polishing company to polish it.

(9) Thank | Knelson

Two reviewers raised more than 30 questions. I revised the draft and answer the questions. It was accepted. The article is about the nature of the flotation bubble. The reviewer is very nice and his questions were good.

(3) Thank | LOVEJK

A very good journal, authoritative in the industry! The opinions of the reviewers and editors are very helpful. I hope MINERALS ENGINEERING will continue to improve and return to the top! 

Received: 13 Dec 2024
Revised: 08 Jun 2025
Accepted: 17 Jun 2025

(0) Thank | Donald W.

6.3 RCC

(0) Thank | 灰达也

My paper has been under review for a month, with only two reviewers, and there has been no progress yet.

(0) Thank | sjj99

Record:
5.20 Submission
5.21 Highlights are too long, need to be modified
5.22 Under review, hoping for good luck

(0) Thank | 灰达也

Admire the big shot, the speed is so fast, I have been waiting for the external audit for nearly two months, but still no news.

(0) Thank | Donald W.

25.2.24 Transfer
25.3.5 Renovation
25.3.14 Minor repair
25.3.24 Acceptance

(0) Thank | KK

已被拒 - Rejected

(0) Thank | yyffhh

Finally updated my status, finally submitted for review today, it's been almost five months in just over ten days.

(0) Thank | yyffhh

There is still no movement.

(0) Thank | syyyyyyyyyyyyy

Have you received any news?

(0) Thank | LY129

It has been four months with the editor, and the status has remained unchanged.

(0) Thank | 大地啊

Is the journal outdated?

(0) Thank | yyffhh

No, contacting customer service and urging them is useless... It's been 4 months, I'm already numb.

(0) Thank | asd112

Did you invest in October last year? Has there been any changes now?

(0) Thank | yyffhh

Has anything changed? Brother, mine is still WE status.

(0) Thank | yyffhh

The low efficiency of editing is infuriating.

(0) Thank | 烧炉老汉

It has been four months, and we are still in the same status.

(0) Thank | yyffhh

There has been no change at all, it's been three months already...

(0) Thank | asd112

Any news? Brother, it's been three and a half months, I've urged twice, but still no change.

(0) Thank | yyffhh

I have worked on it for three and a half months. Eighty percent of it was sent to the editor-in-chief at Imperial College London. This editor just sits in his position without doing anything. If he can do something, he does it; if he can't, he should have retired earlier. He delays things day by day, which is disgusting.

(0) Thank | gift-666

Will good brothers withdraw manuscripts? I want to withdraw.

(0) Thank | asdfdad