It took about 4 months for the review, I felt that the comments of the reviewers were very professional, and it was accepted after the major revision. The journal will format it.

(0) Thank | JJ_XU

That's right, it is an amazing journal. I submitted the manuscript in the early November (I revised it many times before submission). I urged it at the beginning of December, and the editor said that the reviewers had not been found and asked me to recommend. I recommended several professors in this field and waited for the result. In January, there was no reply, and I continued to wait. And the status didn’t change during the period, and it was always “Editor Assigned”, In the early March, I returned to school and found that there was still no response. I prepared to withdraw the manuscript, and sent an email asking about the progress with the mentality of having a try. As a result, I was emailed and told that it was accepted directly on the next day, and was asked to make “some minor modifications”, and it was done in 2 hours. It took 4 months and 2 days from submission to acceptance without revision; it was accepted directly, amazing!

(6) Thank | Roy

Two weeks after submission, a letter from editor was received; the manuscript was rejected directly and other journals were recommended which were inferior, and I will not submit anyway.

(0) Thank | dtt

You need to be patient when submitting to this journal. There is not a lot of communication while you’re waiting.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Hello, may I ask how long were you with the editor? I have been with the editor for three and a half months now and still in the same status.

(0) Thank | he安

Overall, it's not bad. I submitted it in March and was accepted in November. The only downside was that it took a long time to find reviewers in the early stages of editing, until the end of September. However, once the reviewers finished their work, the process moved quickly. After some minor revisions and a week of resubmission, it was accepted. The rest of the copyright and proofing process also went smoothly, with updates on progress being made the next day. Overall, it's not bad. Finally, I can graduate.

(1) Thank | 终于能毕业了

Hello, I have some questions about the journal and would like to consult with you. Could you please provide me with a way to contact you? Thank you

(0) Thank | 阿唐一定能发文

Sharing submission experience for reference only. Submitted in 2019 and it took six months for acceptance, which was acceptable at that time. However, in recent years, this journal is really terrible. The first review now takes over a year, making it the slowest journal I have ever seen

(0) Thank | tb96553712

It has been almost two years, and yesterday I finally got officially hired.

(0) Thank | leelei

Same, in June, I returned for a minor repair. This month, the Editor declined the invitation. It has been almost two years since submission.

(0) Thank | leelei

I waited for more than a year to give my feedback for modifications. The revisions were completed in May, but until now, I haven't received any communication.

(0) Thank | Vivida

How are you? Did you record it?

(0) Thank | 视角

I have been waiting for nearly two months, and I have sent reminders three times. There has been no response.

(0) Thank | 视角

Is nobody investing? Do you know what this journal is about?

(0) Thank | 视角

What journal is this? It has been Editor Assigned for two months. Did the editor die? What are they doing?

(0) Thank | 视角

It has been almost a month since Xiao Xiu submitted, and it is still in the "editor invited" stage. It is really slow.

(0) Thank | leelei

Missed it. Among the three reviewers, only one gave practical suggestions. The other two either immediately rejected it for not meeting the requirements (then what was the purpose of the initial review?), or scolded it for significant flaws without specifying which word had the flaw. Waited for 5 months to start the review, and after 3 months of review, this is the result. Extremely poor experience, I am speechless as a native speaker :)

(0) Thank | Hu_Alice

After 8 months of being rejected, I am truly grateful for any advice.

(0) Thank | Hu_Alice

31 May Minor versions. Lasted 14 months.

(0) Thank | leelei

28 May review complicated；
29 May editor assigned.

Translation: On 28th May, the review became complicated. On 29th May, an editor was assigned.

(0) Thank | leelei

Update: The status date changed once on April 10 and once on May 10, both times it was under review. On May 24, it changed to reviews completed. I don't know what will happen... I have a bad feeling about it.

(0) Thank | Hu_Alice

Is the original poster winning now?

(0) Thank | DRGU

Last December, it was under review, and today it has changed to "Reviewers Assigned" again. It's really too slow.

(2) Thank | leelei

投 - submit
Reviewers Assigned - Reviewers Assigned
至今还是这个状态 - Still in this state until now

Translation: Submitted in August 2021, reviewers were assigned on February 23, 2022, and it is still in this state until now.

(0) Thank | ygao

感觉有点不妙(TAT) translates to "Feeling a bit bad (TAT)" in English.

(0) Thank | Hu_Alice