2024.10.11 Submission Under Review
2025.02.19 Revise for Re-Review (45-day revision period)
2025.04.05 Revised
2025.04.08 Under Review

(0) Thank | AdorAbleWoon

In mid-January, an email was sent to inquire about the progress, stating that the manuscript was still being reviewed and assigned to reviewers by the editor. On February 19, feedback from the reviewers and a rejection decision were received. It was indeed quite slow.

(0) Thank | Paradoxlf

We haven't been able to find a reviewer yet.

(0) Thank | 云优

Submitted at the end of March last year, still under review. Feeling a little hopeless now.

(0) Thank | D.K

Submitted on September 18th
It has been three months and still in "Under Review" status
Do you know what stage this is? Is it appropriate to email the editorial department to urge for feedback?

(0) Thank | Paradoxlf

Please record the timeline as follows:
2024.2.2 submitted
2024.7.20 Major revision (review for re-review) opinions are quite positive, all are very affirmative of the work
2024.8.13 resubmitted
2024.9.18 accept

(0) Thank | peike

How long after being hired will the publication be released?

(0) Thank | lucky211

Well-established journal with decent quality. Not too demanding in terms of innovation, articles are quite easy to pass through. The only issue encountered is the constant back and forth revisions for copyright details on images

(0) Thank | ziqi yang

I would like to ask at which stage is the manuscript currently in if it shows "Under Review"? Is it still under editorial review or has it moved on to external review?

(0) Thank | yesou

How many times did you revise in total?

(0) Thank | 投稿bz

It takes too long

(0) Thank | majunli

Submitted on May 15th
Major revision due on July 10th
Revision due on July 19th
Decision on November 6th - Minor revision for Editor Only
Decision on November 15th - Accepted as is

(1) Thank | zcczzccz

Hired at the beginning of June, the review comments of this journal have been in the hands of the editor for quite a long time. The publication and release date of the journal are still unknown. Overall, it has indeed taken quite a long time, after all, it is a quarterly journal.

(0) Thank | 管理宇宙

You, as a reviewer, are relatively fast. The journal I submitted to has a basic cycle of around six months.

(0) Thank | 管理宇宙

Basically, the recovery period is about three months.
Submitted in July 2022, it was rejected with a suggestion to resubmit after making changes.
Resubmitted in September 2022.
Received reviewer's comments in December 2022, with minor revisions suggested.
Revised and resubmitted in February 2022.
Accepted in May 2022.
Overall, it was not very difficult, but the review was thorough and there were several issues.

(0) Thank | ma20083022

April, no news, will update when there is a status.

(0) Thank | 管理宇宙

Posted in early June 2022.
Announced major revisions in December 2022, to be revised that month.
As of the end of March 2023, the results are unknown.
It took a considerable amount of time, so please be cautious when submitting.

(1) Thank | 管理宇宙

From submission to acceptance, it took 10 months with two revisions, each review taking 4 months. It was very slow.

(0) Thank | Futurist_Yang

The review period is extremely long. Generally, it takes two to three months to receive a response after making revisions, and it took 18 months from submission to acceptance...

(0) Thank | W312meng

Journal Homepage URL: http://ascelibrary.org/upo/

(0) Thank | Anonymous