November 24: Submitted to Journal; December 4: The status has not been changed and it has not yet been sent to editor.

(4) Thank | pitt512

06-Jan-2020 submission; 11-Feb-2020 major revision; 10-Mar-2020 response to major revision; 25-Mar-2020 minor revision; 31-Mar-2020 response to minor revision; 01-Apr-2020 acceptance.

(3) Thank | 张张张zqs

Only one reviewer, whose comments were very pertinent, the review speed is quick, and the editing processing cycle was less than 1 week. It took about 3 months from submission to acceptance. I don’t know when it will be published in the journal. I hope that the impact factor will be stable. If the work is detailed and the data is sufficient, it is very promising to be accepted after sending for review and revisions.

(3) Thank | Adobe-2015

The review process took about 4.5 months. I have submitted to other journals before, and I have revised it several times according to the review comments. With this journal, there wasn’t much to modify.  The overall feeling of the journal is that it is of good quality but  the review is slow.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

May I ask about the status of the journal submission? It was "with editor" on Friday, and the date changed on Monday but the status is still "with editor". Can this indicate anything? I previously submitted an article and it was rejected within the second or third day, so I did not pay attention to any changes in the "with editor" status.

(0) Thank | ljjj

Could you please let me know what it means if a submission to this journal shows as "with editor" on Friday, and then the date changes on Monday but the status remains "with editor"?

(0) Thank | ljjj

I submitted on March 10th, and currently my submission has the reference number 490. Can you please tell me if this journal is easy to get accepted in, and if the review process is fast or not?

(0) Thank | lucky-sp

It should be dealt with together, the second review was not submitted for review and was directly accepted! It's also invincible.

(0) Thank | 爱搞学术的小傻子

January 3, 2025, receive best wishes for good luck!

(0) Thank | tyytytyt

On January 1, 2025, the submission deadline for the journal is approaching. I guess they might be on holiday or the editors are busy. Since the submission volume of this journal is so low, I assume there are not many editors. Just wait patiently. Good luck!

(0) Thank | tyytytyt

What is your current situation? I am in the same situation as you, have been revising submitted to the journal since December 22nd.

(0) Thank | 爱搞学术的小傻子

12.28 Still submitted to the journal, the manuscript has not been processed by the editors yet.

(0) Thank | tyytytyt

12.22 Return manuscript

(0) Thank | tyytytyt

Overall, the experience was very good, and I hope that this year the impact factor can also be maintained. Anything is possible.

(0) Thank | kekeshijie

12.2 The second reviewer agrees to review
12.9 Review completed, two reviewers, minor revisions

(0) Thank | tyytytyt

12.2 Invite new reviewers.

(0) Thank | tyytytyt

11.13 One person has completed the review, but no one has accepted it yet.

(0) Thank | tyytytyt

There should be no limit on the word count. I have about 7000 words, submitted for review on October 18th, with 2 reviewers assigned. Currently, there have been 0 acceptances.

(0) Thank | tyytytyt

I didn't read the specific requirements, so I just submitted it directly... A few days ago, I saw an article from this journal, and coincidentally I had one in hand that I planned to submit.

(0) Thank | tyytytyt

Hello, does this journal have to strictly limit to 5000 words or less?

(1) Thank | d11d

I would like to ask if this journal strictly requires submissions of less than five thousand words.

(0) Thank | d11d

Submitted on 10/14, it seems like this journal goes directly to the editor.

(0) Thank | tyytytyt

The editorial process was very efficient, the review was quick, and we encountered two highly efficient reviewers who provided feedback within a month. We hope the journal continues to improve.

(0) Thank | 终极！

What does it mean when it says "with editor" after the review process is completed?

(0) Thank | 科研奇才

After this review is completed, why does "with editor" appear again?

(0) Thank | 科研奇才