After the paper was submitted, it required nearly two months for external reviews to take place. Of the three reviewers, two were two positive, but one was extremely negative, directly saying that the research I did was rubbish, and they did not give any constructive review comments! Finally, the editorial department rejected my manuscript. However, the other two positive experts pointed out some problems that I did not notice. They were very professional.

(0) Thank | wentong21@163.com

Submission on August 27, 2024
Feedback returned on November 14, 2024
Revised manuscript uploaded on December 24, 2024
Accepted on March 10, 2025

I didn't expect this journal to be so efficient, but the impact factor ranking by the Chinese Academy of Sciences is disappointing. I hope it can at least be upgraded to Zone 2.

(0) Thank | AcceptOne

Yes, you can only see the manuscript information in the submission author system. I also cannot see the manuscript information in my own system, but the emails sent by the editor can be received by all authors, so you will definitely receive an email once the review is completed.

(0) Thank | AcceptOne

Is there anyone kind-hearted, please, please.

(0) Thank | 高一凡

Hello everyone, may I ask if non-corresponding authors can see the status of the manuscript? The teacher is the corresponding author, and it was his account that was used to submit the manuscript. I have been waiting for a few days, but in my system, it still shows 0 and there is nothing there.

(0) Thank | 高一凡

Hey brother, how did it go? I'm also under review soon

(0) Thank | ChenRui_1998

Ancient and authoritative top journal in the field of structural engineering, submitted two articles, the first one was rejected, the second one was accepted. The editing process was fast and patient. There were several issues during the submission process, but they provided suggestions and resolved them. 

Submitted on December 19, 2022. 
Received feedback on April 13, 2023. 
Resubmitted on May 10, 2023. 
Accepted on June 7, 2023.

(0) Thank | KIDDARK

The LetPub review website for this journal has two URLs:
https://www.letpub.com.cn/index.php?journalid=9553&page=journalapp&view=detail
https://www.letpub.com.cn/index.php?journalid=5190&page=journalapp&view=detail

It would be better to merge them into one.

(1) Thank | = =

Posted on October 19, 2020
Returned on October 20, 2020 due to formatting issues
Revised and resubmitted on October 20, 2020, now under review

(1) Thank | gshy

I submitted it in April this year, it has been almost four months, and it has been under review all this time. It's also quite slow.

(0) Thank | ikakaluote

From submission until now, there has been one revision in the middle. It has been nearly a year and a half and there is still no result. It's really too slow...

(0) Thank | peter_stru

speed is not fast or very slow

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Journal HomepageWebsite: http://ascelibrary.org/sto/

(0) Thank | Anonymous

A comprehensive communication outlet for the science of structural design, this journal publishes peer-reviewed technical papers on state-of-the-art topics andEngineers, consultants, and professors detail the physi

(0) Thank | Anonymous