The editor of this journal is particularly responsible. The submitted manuscript will be first reviewed by the editor, and they will even help you correct the grammatical errors in the text and mark them. This will help increase the speed of external review. Then for the external review, the submitted manuscript will be sent to the reviewer in about 2 to 3 days, and the reviewer will reply quickly. The total process lasted for 89 days, with one major revision and two minor revisions being made.

(1) Thank | star

The article was submitted on July 1; The comments of the two reviewers were received on September 1; The email was received on September 2, and it was returned to the reviewers after revision. During the period, it took a long time to invite the reviewers, and the actual review time was quite short. One month was given for the revision. The revised manuscript was actually resubmitted on September 14. The editor returned it to the reviewers on the next day. The comments of the two reviewers were received on September 22, and it was accepted. The acceptance letter was received on September 24. Summary: The review was fast, but the process of inviting the reviewers was really too slow. The editor processed the article very fast, and it was basically processed on the next day. The editor was nice, and it was worthy of submission.

(7) Thank | 12580小灰灰

It took about 90 days to find a reviewer and examine the draft. The process moved much faster after the second reviewer. There are no substantial problems in the two major overhauls, that is, some explanations were added. I found a language polishing service to resolve the grammatical issues, and then the paper was accepted.

(0) Thank | 真RAY

Finding reviewers is relatively slow. The paper went through major and minor revisions for a total of over 7 months before being accepted.

(0) Thank | 学爸

Isn't this harmful? It's been so long.

(0) Thank | Thanos

I have been reviewing for half a month, and there are many comments on the manuscript.

(0) Thank | Thanos

Submitted in mid-November 2024, accepted at the end of February 2025, the process was quite fast. After the article was published, the publication did not provide the author with the full text. Does anyone know how to contact the editorial office to request the full text?

(0) Thank | 悲伤的牛牛

The search for reviewers has been ongoing for one and a half months and we still have not found any. Has anyone else experienced a similar situation?

(0) Thank | 炒蛋不+番茄

The manuscript was revised once and took 214 days from submission to acceptance. One of the reviewers took longer than the other. There were a total of two reviewers for my submission.

(0) Thank | SUDA0107

2024.7.01 Submission
2024.7.25 Under external review (first reviewer)
2024.8.10 Under external review (first reviewer's comments returned)
2024.8.23 Under external review (second reviewer)
2024.9.03 Under external review (second reviewer's comments returned)
2024.9.05 Review comments returned: Major revisions
2024.9.18 Revision
2024.9.29 Second review
2024.10.19 Accepted

(0) Thank | 姜家小宇宙

I am also in Associate Editor Assigned status, and it has been 14 days.

(0) Thank | 悲伤的牛牛

How long is the submission period for this journal, how long does it take to review, and have there been any results?

(1) Thank | redandred

Hello, I am also in the same situation. May I ask if you have any updates?

(0) Thank | yang

Could you please tell me how long it takes for the journal to assign an Associate Editor? It's been 10 days and I haven't heard anything yet. Thank you.

(0) Thank | 投必中冲啊

Big brother, my paper has been in a state of "Submission Check by Journal Office Failed" since submission, what's going on?

(0) Thank | tjuer

What state are you in right now?

(0) Thank | goodluckkkk

Hey there, is the email for proofing of the paper sent already? What is the status? I received an email but it says, “You will receive an email from us when your proofs are ready for your review and after publication, you will be provided with additional information for ordering reprints.” Is there another email coming? I'm worried I might miss it

(0) Thank | 如谷之歌

The submission was made in May, and in July it was rejected for resubmission. After major revisions, it was resubmitted. At the end of November, it was given a "Revise Only (Minor revision required.)" The editorial department replied: "Both reviewers are satisfied with the revised version, but suggest making some minor edits to the numbers. I agree that Figures 16-19 should be redone using symbols or different line types to make them easier to distinguish in black and white or color-challenged printing. Please make these changes." How long will it take to get results after the modifications? Do you know, friends?

(0) Thank | goodluckkkk

Reviewing is quick, comments are professional, the main delay is in finding reviewers!

(0) Thank | goodluckkkk

The decision is being prepared, will it be a rejection?

(0) Thank | zhuzuobin

It's happened twice, and it's always like this. Has anyone else experienced this situation? The format has been adjusted very well, so what's the problem? It's really frustrating

(0) Thank | 如月夜

It's been seven days, help me!!! Everyone else seems to be doing well

(0) Thank | 陈大事

How long will it take approximately? It has been 4 days with no updates.

(0) Thank | 文章中中中！

But it has been many days for me like this, constantly in this state, am I going to be rejected?

(0) Thank | zoeyzuozuo

I also specifically checked, the next step is Decision Letter Being Prepared. As for the matter of before and after (I am referring to the same day), let's wait for further notice.

(0) Thank | 辣个男人