Almost everyone who does research into computational mathematics has one article published here. In the words of my boss, it is not very difficult to be accepted, but it's not as easy as you think. The difficulty is medium or quite high. It's not as mysterious as what the downstairs said. It was exalted or belittled too much.

(44) Thank | flwuc

There is no doubt that the quality of this journal is very high. In the field of applied mathematics (with emphasis on computational mathematics), whether it is a classic problem or a cutting-edge new method, if you have confidence in your work, this journal is definitely the first choice. Scientists in Europe and the United States highly recognize this journal, even if it is not Top 1, it is definitely within Top 3.

(33) Thank | IamAReader

I researched into the fluid mechanics. In this field of the algorithm category, it is absolutely Number 1. Many famous algorithms are published in this journal. Those people who do algorithms are proud to publish a paper in this journal. The first article was submitted in March 2018. The three reviewers were very professional and gave dozens of comments, both large and small comments were in detail. After two rounds of revisions, which lasted for one year, it was accepted in February 2019. They greatly helped improving the quality of the paper. At present, I have submitted two more articles here and hope that there will be good results. I will have no regrets if I can publish three articles in this journal during my Ph.D.

(25) Thank | particle-laden

My study was about a numerical method on computational fluid dynamics. Four months from submission to accept. Good review experience.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

2024.12.23 submitted
2025.1.10 with editor
2025.1.12 with editor
2025.1.14 under review
2025.3.2 major revise
2025.3.10 submitted
2025.3.11 under review
2025.4.11 review complete
2025.4.14 minor revise
2025.4.14 submitted
2025.4.21 accept

The total submission time was exactly four months, with one and a half months given by the first associate editor for initial review. Three reviewers were assigned for the first review, but only two returned their feedback by the deadline, providing nearly 60 comments that greatly improved the quality of the article. Approximately 9,000 words were added in response to the reviewers' feedback. The second round of review allowed for one month.

(0) Thank | 温水煮青蛙

In the field of computational fluid dynamics, it is absolutely Top 1. Many famous algorithms have been published in this journal, and those who develop algorithms consider it an honor to publish a paper in this journal.

(0) Thank | 计算流体

Since the change of editor-in-chief last year, it has been impossible to select recommended editors. I submitted my manuscript in early September last year, received the first round of comments in November, revised in December, responded to another round of comments, and finally got accepted in March this year. It took about six months on average for this journal, but the publication process was quite fast, as it was published online in less than 10 days after acceptance.

(0) Thank | ANSLKF

Hello, may I ask if it is not possible to specify an editor now? I see someone below has specified one, but I didn't see that option when I submitted my request.

(0) Thank | nputud

Could you please tell me how long it will take for the external audit to be completed?

(0) Thank | wishing

Thank you! Will the journal inform me when they find reviewers? It has been 32 days under review and I still haven't been informed if they have found reviewers. What will be shown when they find reviewers?

(0) Thank | tomkeen

It has been 47 days, and the deadline was 45 days. One reviewer completed the submission at 42 days, but the other reviewer has not taken any action. There are a total of three reviewers.

(0) Thank | 温水煮青蛙

How long have you been?

(0) Thank | tomkeen

May I ask how long it takes for the first review of this journal to be sent to the reviewers?

(0) Thank | 温水煮青蛙

Bro, have you made any moves? I haven't moved an inch in the past half month.

(0) Thank | 温水煮青蛙

I may not make it in time for the Christmas holiday.

(0) Thank | WE_Teacherma

Could you please confirm if it has been submitted for review?

(0) Thank | 温水煮青蛙

2024.12.19提交给期刊
2024.12.19编辑收到

(0) Thank | WE_Teacherma

It's been several days since it was received by the editor, how long do we usually wait in this state?

(0) Thank | 髒嗳冢蔟MC丶熊哥

I was about two weeks into it when the chief editor recommended switching tracks because the direction was not a good fit. However, a new chief editor took over in September, and my experience was no longer relevant.

(0) Thank | 快乐打工人

May I ask how long the "received by editor" status will last? I have been waiting for over 20 days and it is still in the "received by editor" status. Can I follow up on my submission?

(0) Thank | DOOMDUKE

2024.08.07 提交给期刊
2024.08.07 编辑收到

(0) Thank | 快乐打工人

Physics machine learning field top 2 journal, but the review speed is relatively slow, and the requirements for the mathematical part are higher compared to computer journals.

(0) Thank | Pierre2021

Hello, may I ask which editor you have chosen?

(0) Thank | whuwanji

Submitted on July 28, 2023
Completed the first round of review on October 21, 2023, with major revisions
Revised on February 4, 2024
Completed the second round of review on March 21, 2024
Accepted on April 12, 2024

It took 8 and a half months in total, which is half the time compared to the first submission that took 17 months!!!

(0) Thank | 半月痕

2023.5.7 Small revision, major revise
2023.7.23 Careful modification returned
2023.9.6 One accepted, major revise
2023.11.6 Major revision again, too painful
Currently waiting for feedback, hoping for the best, best wishes

(0) Thank | leeroket