The editor who processed this submission is the editor-in-chief Johannes A Lercher in this journal. 10.30 submission; 10.31 editor invited; 11.22 The decision letter said that they were sorry that it took so long to process, and there was no external review. It was said that the insight of the mechanism should be rephrased and then submitted. Well, let’s resubmit. 11.28 submission; 11.29 editor invited. The processing editor should still be Johannes A Lercher. 12.12 it was still editor invited... It directly took three weeks, and it seemed that it is the normal for the editor-in-chief’s processing speed. I don’t know why not let other deputy editors to handle it if the editor-in-chief is so busy! Pity on this article, more than forty days have passed, and I haven't taken the first step yet!

(1) Thank | chemeng

20200123 submitted; 20200125 with editor; 20200128 under review; 20200229 major revision; 20200327 request for extension of the deadline; 20200525 request for extension of the deadline; 20200615 revision submitted; 20200615 accepted. The review speed was very fast, the reviewers were very professional, and they have made many pertinent suggestions. The revised manuscript made great progress after revision. Due to the inability to return to school to supplement the data during the epidemic, I applied for two extensions. Thank editor-in-chief Graham John Hutchings very much for his high efficiency!

(53) Thank | wholland

Received at Editorial Office 18 Feb 2020; Article revised 4 Jun 2020; Article accepted for publication 7 Jun 2020. DOI: 10.1016/j.jcat.2020.06.010. Five revisions, thank the editor S. T. Oyama for providing a lot of valuable comments. After five revisions, the quality of the article has been greatly improved, and the content has also been enriched. Many typeset articles are 18 pages. In particular, I learned the calculation of dynamics under the guidance of the editor. It is the third catalytic article after Applied Catalysis B and ACS Catalysis, I hope that there will be better work to submit to JC next time. After all, it is an authoritative journal in the field of catalysis.

(132) Thank | acs chemistry

24 days to first decision. Here's what I have to say: 1 Be sure to read the guideline for authors in detail; 2 Recommending reviewers is very important.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Rejected on 23rd March 2025, now transferred to the international hydrogen energy sector.

(0) Thank | 在读理工生

Is the probability of rejection high after being under review?

(0) Thank | wade9527

Decision in Process should be rejected.

(0) Thank | 在读理工生

Still with editor on 17th March 2025.

(0) Thank | 在读理工生

Now.

(0) Thank | 123Wu-Lei

2025/3/13 is still with editor.

(0) Thank | 在读理工生

Change back to "with editor" on 3/10/2025.

(0) Thank | 在读理工生

No changes in status as of 2025/3/9.

(0) Thank | 在读理工生

2025/2/28 submission
2025/3/1 under review by editor
2025/3/3 editor invitation issued

(0) Thank | 在读理工生

DIP was rejected for a week.

(0) Thank | ZZ

Dear masters, have you ever encountered DIP? I have been waiting for 3 days and still haven't received any news. Is it common for DIP to be rejected?

(0) Thank | ZZ

Any updates on the follow-up results after asking the editor? It has been a week since DIP, but there has been no news.

(0) Thank | liberty990

Is there any follow-up? I haven't heard anything yet. Does it mean it has been rejected?

(0) Thank | 可可哦

Hello, any progress now?

(0) Thank | Wang chengliang

Any progress?

(0) Thank | Wang chengliang

How is the result of the DIP now?

(0) Thank | kkllswz

Could you please clarify if all authors need to click on the confirmation link in the email?

(0) Thank | Wang chengliang

Friend, may I ask if all authors need to click the confirmation link in the email?

(0) Thank | Wang chengliang

Can I ask the following friends, do all authors need to click the confirmation link in the email?

(0) Thank | Wang chengliang

I wrote a letter to the editorial department at 12:30, and received a rejection notice in the afternoon of the 31st. Why did it take so long with the editor?

(0) Thank | nanjingapple

The process was very fast, taking only two months from submission to acceptance.

(0) Thank | ppzzz