Aug 13, Submitted to journal; Aug 13, With Editor; Aug 13, Under Review; Aug 18, Under Review; Aug 22, Under Editor Evaluation; Aug 23, Under Review; Aug 25, Under Review; Sep 02, Under Editor Evaluation; Sep 03, Under Review; Sep 22, Major Revision (It was sent to four reviewers, one required a major revision, two required minor revisions, and one agreed to accept it); Oct 11, Revision Submitted to Journal; Oct 13, Under Review; Oct 14, Under Review (I was sent to the fifth reviewer); Oct 30, Required Reviews Completed; Oct 31, Accept; Nov 05, Online. The processing speed of the editor is still very fast, mainly because the external review takes about a month. Thanks to the editor Thiagarajan Gnanasekaran. I wish the journal better and better.

(0) Thank | 哈哈哈是我呀

5.15, submitted; 5.19, with editor; 5.22, under review; 6.2, under review; 7.2, under review; 7.4, under review; 8.4, under editor evaluation; 8.4, major revision; 8.17, revision submitted to journal; 8.18, with editor; 8.19, under review; 8.20, under review; 8.31, required reviewer completed. 9.2, major revision; 9.15, revision submitted to journal; 9.16, with editor; 9.24, under review; 9.25, under review; 9.27, accepted. Thanks to Jin Li, Ph.D.

(3) Thank | 乐园小仙女

5.20 Submit; 5.22 With editor; 5.24 Under review; 6.5 Under review; 7.1 Under review; 7.7 Under review; 7.26 Under Editor Evaluation; 7.27 Minor Revision; 8.3 Revision Submitted to Journal; 8.4 With editor; 8.4 Accept; 8.6 Online. I saw everyone’s comments saying that it was slow and I was very worried, but overall it felt okay. Two reviewers, the first one was very positive and only suggested the language to be modified; the second one raised 6 comments. A minor revision was were finally required by the editor. The editor was Professor Xiao from Zhejiang University. The manuscript was processed very fast. The manuscript was accepted within 2 days after the revised manuscript was submitted, which was great. But it took a long period for the Under review in the early stage of review, and the review comments returned after two months. This was my first SCI paper in a top journal, and I can finally graduate. I wish you all the best in scientific research!

(20) Thank | Material-CHD

2.14 submitted to journal; 2.16 under review; 2.20 under review; 2.26 under review; 3.5 under editor evaluation; 3.7 under editor evaluation; 3.11 under editor evaluation; 3.20 major revise. 4 reviewers, three positive and one negative. The editor gave one month for revision. I applied for a delay because of the epidemic. 5.29 revision sent to journal; 6.1 with editor; 6.2 under review; 6.8 under review; 6.19 required review completed; 6.20 major revise. 3 reviewers, two recommended acceptance, one asked four questions; 6.28 revision sent to journal; 6.29 accept. It has been 4 months in total. However, the editor of Northwestern University of Technology, Professor Fan, processed manuscripts very quickly.

(3) Thank | daiviee

Mar 03 2020, submitted to journal; Mar 06 2020, with editor; Mar 11 2020, under review; Mar 12 2020, under review; Apr 11 2020, under review; Apr 30 2020, under editor evaluation; May 03 2020, major revision; Jun 02 2020, revision submitted; Jun 03 2020, with editor; Jun 15 2020, under review; Jun 23 2020, required reviews completed; Jun 28 2020, accept. Thank you, editor Jennifer Aitken; the review was still very fast. Friendly reminder: The editor selected at the time of submission is uncertain, and the journal may reassign according to the research direction.

(7) Thank | 生如夏花08

The 380th floor continued. It was really too slow. If you have time requirements, please submit your manuscripts carefully. 8.14 submitted to journal; 8.24 with editor; 9.5 under review; 9.29 under review; 10.21 under review; 11.5 under review; 11.17 under review; 12.04 under review; 12.24 under review; 2020.1.06 under revision; 20201.17 major revision. All the comments were to change English in the recommendation of major revision. Three reviewers recommended acceptance after minor revisions. 2.14 with editor; 2.28 major revision. The first reviewer still thought English was poor and required modifying the language. My English is not good, but it would not be like this. It is not so good. I found an editing agency the journal approved to polish it and issue a polishing certificate. Then I submitted it. (The polishing agency basically did not change a few places, purely for earning money). 3.14 with editor; 3.24 minor revision; 3.29 finally accepted.

(2) Thank | 论文虐我千百遍

The editor is slow. A few months for the review period.

(4) Thank | zzq

Please translate the following paragraph into English: 

"好的，我会尽快处理您的请求，并尽力满足您的要求。谢谢您的耐心等待。"

(0) Thank | coating future

The journal is scheduled for publication on August 12th, Wednesday.

(0) Thank | coating future

12/08/2025 UR (Reviewer 1 completed review and sent to Reviewer 13)

(0) Thank | 如此彻底

12/08/2025 WE (Reviewer 1 completed review and sent to Reviewer 13)

(0) Thank | 如此彻底

8.13 still stj.

(0) Thank | 热障涂层的未来

Please translate the following paragraph into English: 8.12 rrc

(0) Thank | NNnnnnNNNnn

It should be a holiday, my consensus is with the editor.

(0) Thank | Resion

8.6 stj
8.11 is still stj, what's going on?

(1) Thank | 热障涂层的未来

8.9 重新提交，与编辑
8.10 正在审阅

(0) Thank | NNnnnnNNNnn

Some, but some reviewers did not follow this, which is very uncomfortable, and I dare not urge them.

(0) Thank | 增材达人

Submission was made on April 24th and as of August 7th, it has not been reviewed yet. Is there no deadline for the review process at JAC?

(0) Thank | 深呼吸要中啊

5.28 submit to Journal
6.5 with editor
6.23 major revision (two reviewers)
7.23 return with editor
7.31 RRC
8.7 Accept

(0) Thank | 雁过无痕

Just wait, the review process is indeed slow right now.

(0) Thank | 增材达人

It has been four months and I am still at UR, what should I do?

(0) Thank | 深呼吸要中啊

Energy storage

(0) Thank | NNnnnnNNNnn

It should be two people.

(0) Thank | 辣椒炒肉冲击

How many experts' review comments does JAC need? I saw that one expert has accepted the review and provided feedback, but the other three have not accepted the review. Looking forward to everyone's response.

(0) Thank | 梦到中了

6.23 STJ
6.25 WE
6.30 UR (inviting 3 reviewers, with reviewer 1 agreeing to review on the same day; reviewer 2 agreeing to review after 3 days; reviewer 3 agreeing to review after 8 days)
7.15 RRC
7.18 Major revision
7.28 WE
7.29 UR
8.5 Accept
Wish everyone a successful acceptance!

(0) Thank | 增材达人