5-9 submitted to JOM; 5-10 deadline passed; 5-25 returned to author, details and language; 5-29 returned to author language; 6-5 submitted to JOM; 9-30 major revise; 10-12 submitted to JOM; 10-15 returned to author, details; 11-10 minor revise; 11-13 returned to author, details; 11-19 once that is revised, I will recommend the manuscript for publication. 11-25 decision in process. 12-18 accepted

(2) Thank | RicKillMercy

5-9, submitted to the Journal of The Minerals, Metals & Materials Society (JOM); 5-10, deadline passed; 5-25, returned to author, the revision of details and language was required; 5-29, returned to author, the revision of language was required; 6-5, submitted to JOM; 9-30, major revision; 10-12, submitted to JOM; 10-15, returned to author, the revision of details was required; 11-10, minor revision; 11-13, returned to author, the revision of details was required; 11-19, “once that is revised, I will recommend the manuscript for publication”; 11-25, “decision in process”.

(4) Thank | RicKillMercy

The reviewers of this journal are very professional and they review the manuscript very quickly, but the formatting requirements are very strict. If there is a small error in the format, they will send it back to you for correction. It is recommended to read the author instructions carefully before submission. At the end of Aug. 2018, submitted to journal; 2018.9.10, with editor; 2018.9.24, under review (the format was revised twice during the period from submission to review); 2018.10.17, major revision made (It lasted for 2 months); 2018.11.6, revised submission; 2018.11.17 submitted to journal (during this period, the format was required to modify); in December 2018, with editor; 2019.1.31, second major revision made (It lasted for one month); 2019.2.30, revised submission again; early in Apr. 2019, accepted.

(11) Thank | 296323924

50 days for review. The journal has high requirements on the format and number of submissions. It has been back and forth several times.

(3) Thank | qfang525@sina.com

My opinion has not changed, but my previous article has been revised three times, possibly by changing one reviewer at a time.

(0) Thank | fafafafa!

Is it normal for "under review" to keep changing after submission, with an average of one change every 10 times, and it has changed five times already?

(0) Thank | Lucky_x

February 22 submitted for revision, with a deadline for revisions until March 3.20 (10 days for modifications, and additional testing required). Revised on March 26 and resubmitted on March 28 with high-quality images. Accepted on April 22 after being under review since April 14. The status was extremely unusual, as it was still under external review on the night of the 21st and accepted in the early hours of the 22nd.

(0) Thank | fafafafa!

Brothers, are there any formatting requirements for this journal? Can someone provide guidance?

(0) Thank | 造势

Brother, are there any formatting requirements for this journal? Can you provide some guidance?

(0) Thank | 造势

Hello, may I ask how many reviewers are there in total?

(0) Thank | Lucky_x

Hello, may I ask how long it has taken you to complete the project up to now?

(0) Thank | lucky-sp

Hello, I was just hired. May I ask how long it will take for me to be able to access the system?

(0) Thank | 林泉

This journal is so slow! There aren't many submissions either. I've been waiting for 13 days now.

(0) Thank | lucky-sp

Is it normal for it to take almost a month with the editor?

(0) Thank | zx-

How is Karen Doyle's editing? Submitted to the journal on the 14th. Rejected on the 15th for formatting changes. Resubmitted on the 15th. Currently with the editor. Still in the "we" stage. Approximately how long will it take to be reviewed?

(0) Thank | lucky-sp

2025.03.02 under review.

(0) Thank | Rene113

He has been under review for over two months and the date has changed three times, with a change happening every month. What's going on?

(0) Thank | h d j s j s

11.14 submitted
12.29 under review
1.26 The date changed but still under review
2.25 The date changed again but still under review
Is it normal for the date to change every month like this, or have we not found a reviewer yet? It has changed three times now, each time after a month.

(1) Thank | h d j s j s

2025.02.10 submit
2025.02.11 with editor
No news, just...

(0) Thank | Rene113

How long does it take for proofreading, online and retrieval after acceptance?

(0) Thank | aimon

How long does it take for the manuscript to be edited, published online, and indexed after acceptance? Thank you.

(0) Thank | aimon

In the editor's hands for a month, rejected, slow.

(0) Thank | quan110

2024.11.12 Submitted to journal
2024.11.15 With editor
2024.11.19 Under review
2024.12.7 Major revision
2024.12.15 Revision submitted to journal
2025.1.4 Minor revision
2025.1.7 Revision submitted to journal
2025.1.13 Decision in process
2025.1.18 With editor
2025.1.20 Accept

(0) Thank | lidayu

Congratulations on successfully crossing the tribulation.

(0) Thank | lidayu

How are you doing now?

(0) Thank | LC.