I have been stuck in the "unconsideration" state for 72 days, what's going on?

(0) Thank | asistent

CEE is relatively new after all, its reputation still needs a long time to be established, and its influence is average. For me, it is slightly better than a typical first-tier journal, but definitely not as good as top journals in the field like EPSL, GCA, and geology.

(0) Thank | 一条躺平的咸鱼

Was NC slipped down to the review?

(0) Thank | 北油沉积小陈

The external review of NC was rejected, with two positive and one negative feedback. The editor suggested submitting to CEE and possibly sending it back to the original reviewers. What are the chances of acceptance in CEE? How influential is CEE in the field of Earth sciences compared to EPSL and GCA?

(0) Thank | 北油沉积小陈

Bro, I also received the editing twice and it is under consideration. Can you please explain what's going on?

(0) Thank | 阴天快乐11

If you use the transfer function within the nature system, it will package all the review information from the previous round, including editor comments, and send it to the next journal, so it will be sent back to the original reviewer.

(0) Thank | 51cd

Updating the time did not change the status, it seems that you have switched to another editor (the previous editor may not have had the time or the direction was not suitable for him and he refused).

(0) Thank | 再回童年敲敲门

I submitted my article on February 24th and it reached the editor on the 25th. It has been half a month since then and it is still in the "Under Consideration" status. On the 5th, the Start Date was updated but there was no change in status. Is this a mistake by the editor? Have you experienced this situation before?

(1) Thank | Tembin

Awaiting the results...

(0) Thank | 再回童年敲敲门

Update: 2025/02/04 officially accepted, the editor had sent it back once before for some minor formatting issues to be revised;
2025/02/13 officially online, a few days before that the proofreading and payment, it seems that the layout fee does not need to be received in order for the article to be officially published.

Under consideration means it is with the editor, Under Review means it is in the peer review process.

(0) Thank | 美国政府将

The current status of the review process is as follows, awaiting the review results, hoping for major or minor revisions. 
Under Consideration	16th Feb 25
Under Review	18th Oct 24
Under Consideration	3rd Oct 24
Editor Assigned	3rd Oct 24
Manuscript Submitted	2nd Oct 24
Submission	2nd Oct 24
Manuscript Transferred	21st Sep 24

(0) Thank | 毛毛

I hope to add a friend to inquire about the submission process for CEE.

(0) Thank | 徐悻悻

It is a very promising journal under the Nature brand. The entire submission process is very rigorous and meticulous. It was revised a total of 3 times, with very good suggestions from two reviewers in the first two revisions. In the final revision, the editor also provided valuable suggestions for the title, abstract, and content. It was a very nice submission process with a lot of gains. However, the submission cycle is relatively long.

2024/05/01 Submitted
2024/05/06 Editor assigned
2024/05/14 reviewer(s) invited
2024/08/06 Editorial decision: revise

2025/01/07 Submitted
2025/01/29 Editorial decision: revise (acceptance in principle)

2025/02/09 Submitted
2025/02/12 Editorial decision (accept)

(1) Thank | 账户名

Stage Start Date
Under Consideration 7th Feb 25
Editor Assigned 7th Feb 25
Manuscript Submitted 7th Feb 25
Submission 4th Feb 25

The above is my current status. What is the difference between "Under Consideration" and "Under Review"?

(0) Thank | 徐悻悻

Update:
Formally received on 2025/02/07, had to return for some formatting issues; then on 2025/02/09, proofreading and payment of OA fees;
Currently waiting for online processing.

(0) Thank | 美国政府将

Record for reference:
Round 1: Submitted on 07/07/2024, under review on 08/02/2024, under consideration on 10/09/2024, minor revisions on 10/31/2024 (the comments from two reviewers are very positive, the decision letter indicates minor revisions)
Round 2: Submitted on 12/02/2024, under review on 12/03/2024, under consideration on 01/06/2025, accepted in principle on 01/16/2025 (need to fill out two checklists, make final formatting changes and resubmit)
Round 3: Submitted on 01/17/2025, no further updates on status until now, waiting for final acceptance and publication.

(0) Thank | 美国政府将

About a week before the external audit, and 45 days after the external audit, it was rejected.

(0) Thank | Geo_DY

Do you have any updates on the latest results? How long does it take to receive a response under consideration?

(0) Thank | zaixiaarui

December 3, 2024, around 6 a.m., rejected稿.

(0) Thank | robb

Has it been submitted for approval?

(0) Thank | wuchao342626

At around 5:00 PM on November 14, 2024, the vote was cast.

(0) Thank | robb

Just submitted, wishing for a quick review.

(0) Thank | 多发论文哦

NC conversion, modified and received, very fast speed.

(0) Thank | Permanent

How likely is it for the small NC to switch sides and be sent for review?

(0) Thank | 水文小学生20

It has been one month since the first review and it is still under consideration. Has it been sent for external review or is it still with the reviewers?

(0) Thank | Geo_DY