It took two months. Accepted after a minor revision! It's pretty fast, and the quality is not bad. It focuses on theoretical research!

(1) Thank | Cage Sun

3 month review. 1 year publication. Substantial backlog.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Sending emails to the journal through the system was not helpful. I directly emailed the editor-in-chief YB, who replied on the same day saying that the manuscript was in the hands of the foreign editor JN and provided immediate acceptance feedback. Two days later, I received the acceptance notification.

(0) Thank | 放假

Hello, may I ask if you also chose the foreign editor? I noticed that there is only one mechanical editor. My submission has been under review for 2 months without any news, it feels very slow.

(0) Thank | liangling

Hello, are you the foreign editor that you chose? When I submitted my manuscript, I only saw one editor who was a machine, so I chose the foreign editor. My speed is very slow.

(0) Thank | liangling

Submission on 30th December 2024
Minor revisions on 8th February 2025
Revised on 4th March 2025
Still under external review on 8th June 2025
Still under external review to this day, sending emails is also useless, anyone else have the same experience?

(0) Thank | 放假

Is the major repair directly hired? So impressive.

(0) Thank | zeke

20250401 Submission
20250503 Major revision (three reviewers)
20250602 Revised
20250604 Accepted
The journal is very efficient, with YB Yang as the editor processing submissions very quickly. Each time a submission is made, it is sent for review on the same day or the next day. Wishing the journal continued success.

(0) Thank | diudiu

It seems that some of the reviewers have provided feedback.

(0) Thank | 简宁

Bro, what does "Under Review Star" mean?

(0) Thank | zeke

What does "Under Review star" mean?

(0) Thank | zeke

Submitted on March 20, 2025
Under Review on April 1
Returned with Major Revision on May 1
Revised version returned on May 14
Under Review again on May 16
Accepted on May 31
Overall submission experience was very good, with insightful comments from the reviewers and additional comparative analysis. Accepted for publication directly after major revision within two weeks. The entire process from submission to acceptance took 2.5 months, showing high efficiency. Many thanks to Editor-in-Chief C M Wang.

(0) Thank | 简宁

Only one.

(0) Thank | YugiOh

Does this journal have a latex template?

(0) Thank | ma shidong

Submission on March 20, 2025
April 1, UR
May 1, Major Revision
May 14, MR Sub
May 16, UR... Currently, the major revision is under review.

(0) Thank | 简宁

Bro, several reviewers

(0) Thank | zeke

Submitted on January 11
Revised on February 6
Revised again on April 10
Accepted on April 20
The feedback was professional and greatly helped improve the content of the article.

(0) Thank | yoyo_qie

The journal is very efficient, the opinions are also quite professional, overall it is very good.

(0) Thank | 刘

Received June 4, 2024
Accepted November 28, 2024
Published January 17, 2025

(0) Thank | 2412

After the rework, it was not sent for external review and was directly accepted by the editor.

(0) Thank | YugiOh

Sent out on November 14, 2020, major revision on January 3, revised on January 26, minor revision on February 23, revised again on February 26, accepted on February 26. The whole process was very fast and not dragging.

(0) Thank | 奋斗的小柒

Submission on 20241128
Minor revision on 20250212 (1 comment from editor, 4 comments from reviewers)
Returned for revision on 20250219, looking forward to the results.

(0) Thank | YugiOh

Also can.

(0) Thank | yoyo_qie

24 12 26接受。Accept 24 12 26.

(0) Thank | yoyo_qie

7.18 submission
10.3 major
11.1 rework
12.8 accepted

(0) Thank | mxjjj14