I contacted the editorial department and said I would inform the editor during the decision-making stage. However, it has been a week and there has been no change. I don't understand why a decision would take more than a month.

(0) Thank | zysssss

Has your condition changed?

(0) Thank | kycccc

The submission on January 7, 2025 is still under review. This journal is really slow.

(1) Thank | 黑夜中的星辰

It's time to remind ER that it has been a month.

(0) Thank | Spike Mill

Tomorrow will be the 28th day, should I wait a little longer or send an email to inquire?

(0) Thank | zysssss

The second round of minor revisions should be satisfactory to the reviewers. Throughout the process, it will be edited internally by the editor, and will not be sent back to the reviewers. Currently, the associate editor responsible for your article has recommended it for publication, and we are waiting for the final decision from the editor-in-chief. This process may take some time, as I also experienced a three-week wait in the final decision stage last year, only to be rejected by the editor-in-chief.

There is no need to rush the submission, as the efficiency of this journal's editing process is quite high. If there is no response in another week, it will not be too late to follow up. Good luck to you.

(0) Thank | Spike Mill

I have returned for rework after the second review. I have been under review the entire time (without a big U) and went straight to the ER. It has been 18 days now.

(0) Thank | zysssss

The minor revisions for the second review have been ongoing for half a month now. Should we follow up on this?

(0) Thank | kycccc

How many rounds of review have passed? If you are still discussing revisions with the reviewer (the stage where the article is fully assessed by the AE), the ER status will usually be available in three to five days, and sometimes even faster, maybe within one or two days. It seems that the final decision from the editor-in-chief may take a little longer. I waited almost three weeks for the final decision from the editor-in-chief last summer.

(0) Thank | Spike Mill

It has been half a month.

(0) Thank | kycccc

I have been working here for half a month, and it feels really slow.

(0) Thank | kycccc

How long have you been waiting here at the ER? It's been 14 days for me now and there's still no progress. I feel like the whole process has slowed down a lot now.

(0) Thank | zysssss

I sent an email to the editor on February 23rd, but I have not received a response until now. It is indeed rare to not receive a reply. I have submitted to this journal twice before, contacting them a total of 4 times, and each time they responded promptly. The fastest response was on the same evening.

(0) Thank | Spike Mill

I sent an email to the editor on February 23rd, but have not received a response yet.

(0) Thank | xianyang

In theory, capital R refers to external review, while lowercase r refers to internal review. It could be that feedback has come back, the AE will look at the feedback and also review your article; or it could be that the reviewer has declined to review, and the AE will invite a new reviewer; or it could simply be that the AE is reviewing your article.

(0) Thank | Spike Mill

Hello, what's going on with my capital R and lowercase r constantly switching back and forth?

(0) Thank | 博格达

Still under external review, waiting for the reviewers' response. The efficiency of this journal editor is quite high, so I suspect the reviewers are delaying. Five months for external review is quite long, in my experience, others usually take one or two months for a round. It's been so long that we could write a letter to urge them, asking the administrator to forward the reminder letter to the Associate Editor to push the reviewers to submit their comments faster.

(0) Thank | Spike Mill

"Is the reminder letter sent through Contact Journal in ScholarOne?" 
Yes, the editorial team will reply to you within two days.

(0) Thank | Spike Mill

I feel like this journal has slowed down a lot. Someone I know submitted to this journal, but got rejected after one and a half months of review. Both reviewers were quite strict. Is it because the number of submissions has increased, causing the speed to decrease?

(0) Thank | Spike Mill

May I ask if the reminder letter is sent through Contact Journal in ScholarOne?

(0) Thank | kycccc

Hello everyone, I submitted my paper on 2024-9-18, and it has been 5 months so far. The ScholarOne and Wiley submission status for this journal has been showing "Under Review" all this time. Has anyone else encountered this situation? Can anyone provide some insights on what might be the reason for this delay and offer some advice?

(0) Thank | 羡阳

Brother, my situation is similar to yours. After battling through two rounds of reviews, all four reviewers agreed, and the associate editor was likely to recommend it for publication. However, the editor-in-chief ultimately rejected it with a "out of scope" vote. I wrote a letter arguing against this decision, and the response stated that it was within the editor's discretion. Although they apologized, they will not reconsider publishing it. By the way, brother, you are reviewing for this journal so slowly, in my experience, it usually takes one round per month.

(0) Thank | Spike Mill

This is the first time in my career that I have encountered such a terrible journal! Submitted in January 24, rejected in May, no problem.
Submitted major revisions in June 24
Sent a reminder in October 24, was told that one reviewer was delayed and the associate editor has been informed to resolve it.
Contacted a few more times from November 24 to January 25, each time was told they have contacted the associate editor, but no response. Tried to contact the associate editor's personal email directly, no reply.
Requested to withdraw the submission and cc'd the editor. The editor replied this manuscript is out of scope. F***...
Anyway, managed to withdraw it smoothly, wasted 8 months...will never submit again, it's not like it's some high-level journal, there are plenty of alternatives.

(0) Thank | RAI

+1, the second review has been 2 and a half months already.

(0) Thank | kycccc

Hello, I have also encountered the same situation, what's going on?

(0) Thank | 博格达