The approximate timeline of submission: 2020.04.12, submission; 2020.04.28, under review; 2020.06.12, major revision; 2020.07.28, revision submitted to journal; 2020.08.10, under review; 2020.09.12, accepted. The review speed was very fast; it took 5 months from submission to acceptance. However, there were 7 reviewers invited; more than 30 pages of reply to the reviewers’ comments were written.

(5) Thank | complex01

Submitted on September 17, 2018. September 22, 2018, under review. On November 9, 2018, four reviewers and an AE: one negative comment and four affirmative comments. Major revision was required by AE. On November 26, 2018, the revised submission was uploaded, which was accepted on December 17, 2018. In general, the reviewer's comments were pertinent, and the negative comments turned out to be that the paper was not suitable for people in other majors.

(0) Thank | Hawk-ZD

Approximate submission process: 2019.02.20 submission; 2019.03.19 under review; 2019.04.17 required review completed; 2019.04.21 Decision in Process. Why is it so fast? What a flattering! Even if it was rejected, I will still be happy. At least the review process has been accelerated! But let's wish a major revision later, good luck!

(1) Thank | 控制菜鸟

Very competitive. Slow. Reputation and IF continues to increase.

(2) Thank | Anonymous

Is there an editor invited status before under reviewer?

(0) Thank | 自动化

30 Apr 2025 Under Review

(0) Thank | weaponer

What are the stages between submission and rejection?

(0) Thank | 自动化

What stage are we at now?

(0) Thank | 自动化

At what stage are you now?

(0) Thank | 自动化

Does changing from "editor invited" to "Editor Declined Invitation" mean the submission will be rejected?

(0) Thank | 自动化

What does it mean when the submission status changes to "Editor Declined Invitation" on 25.4.28?

(0) Thank | 自动化

xd, have you been hired yet?

(0) Thank | 迪士驾到

xd, have you been hired yet?

(0) Thank | 迪士驾到

4-8号 变成With Editor了

The manuscript from 4-8 has been marked as "With Editor."

(0) Thank | weaponer

07 Apr 2025 Returned due to formatting issues, revised and resubmitted, now Submitted to Journal.

(0) Thank | weaponer

Submitted to Journal on April 4th, 2025.

(0) Thank | weaponer

Brother, what does it mean when it says "editing has entered the system"?

(0) Thank | X流

Hello, excuse me, have you experienced the "editor invited" status, or did we just go straight to "ur" after "we"?

(0) Thank | 阿巴阿巴狗

At this point, the editor should have entered the system.

(0) Thank | 迪士驾到

2024.6.4 Submitted to Journal
2024.6.5 With Editor
2024.7.15 Under Review
2024.8.15 Required Reviews Completed
2024.9.26 Decision in Process
2024.10.2 Major Revise
2024.11.25 Revision Submitted
2024.11.25 With Editor
2024.12.22 Under Review
2025.1.3 Required Reviews Completed
2025.1.18 Decision in Process
2025.1.26 Accept

There were four reviewers, none of whom had difficult questions, but seemed to lack understanding of control theory and placed more emphasis on practical applications. Overall, the process was relatively smooth.

(1) Thank | Silente

Currently: with editor.

(0) Thank | jasky

Brother, when I returned for the second major repair, I ended up like this too, feeling numb all over.

(0) Thank | X流

Submitted in July 2024, returned for major revisions after six months. Upon resubmission for the second round of revisions, the status changed from "with editor" to "editor invited," and now it has reverted back to "with editor." Can anyone tell me if there is still hope? What does this mean?

(0) Thank | X流

Hello, I also want to know why it changed from "with editor" to "editor invited" today, and then changed back to "with editor" later.

(0) Thank | 阿巴阿巴狗

我想去海边度假，享受阳光、沙滩和大海的美丽风景。

(3) Thank | 王淑雯