The review cycle is very pleasing: submitted (11.27), firstly the editor reviewed it, then it was under review, and then we waited for reviewers to be assigned (12.24). Then, Awaiting Reviewer Scores (started from 12.24). This was equivalent to spending one month for the external review and scoring.

(7) Thank | 学界啄木鸟

I had two articles reviewed here. The first one was assigned for review in May 2018, submitted in July 2018, and revised in December 2018; the second review notice received in January 2019, review comments returned in March 2019, and review comments received in July 2019. Two reviewers; manuscript accepted. The second paper was assigned for review in March 2018, submitted in June 2018, and revised in September 2018; the second review notice received in September 2018, review comments returned in November 2018, and review comments received in July 2019. Four reviewers; manuscript rejected. This journal can be said to be extremely slow, with the second review for 7 to 8 months.

(6) Thank | zarathustr

Very difficult. From submission to acceptance, it lasted for one year and three months, with four revisions. The editor played an arbitration role. The journal focuses on novelty, practicality, and emphasizes the contrast with articles of the same theme.

(0) Thank | zhangshengguo@tsinghua.org.cn

Hey bro, did you change the reviewer for the second review?

(0) Thank | AllAccepted

Bro, have you invited the new reviewer?

(0) Thank | AllAccepted

April 26, 2025 Major Revision

(0) Thank | Shawn Yue

Is anyone else's second review under review? Mine has been for 9 days already, what does this status mean?

(0) Thank | AllAccepted

Hello everyone, may I ask whether the revision suggestions from SE and TE, as well as the comments from the reviewers, should be addressed together in the response? Or should the suggestions from SE and TE be addressed in the cover letter, and the comments from the reviewers be addressed in the response letter? Thank you all!

(0) Thank | 问道者

Still in SE, wish you good luck.

(0) Thank | 二刀得狂风

2025.4.24 Awaiting EIC Decision

(0) Thank | Shawn Yue

Okay, thank you for your answer, bro!

(0) Thank | 问道者

Any version must be within 11 pages, regardless of whether it is a first draft or a revised draft.

(0) Thank | 墨尔本幽灵

How many pages can be submitted at most for revision? Hope UU who knows can answer, thank you very much!

(0) Thank | 问道者

23-Apr-2025 Awaiting Reviewer Scores, feeling a bit risky.

(0) Thank | 希望早点顺利毕业

22-Apr-2025 Awaiting TE Recommendation
Um, the pace is a bit fast... a little worried.

(0) Thank | 希望早点顺利毕业

2025.4.21 Awaiting SE Recommendation

(0) Thank | Shawn Yue

There is no further review, it was directly SE'd. It feels like it's going to be cold.

(0) Thank | 二刀得狂风

It's a pity that we share the same illness. Is it because we couldn't find enough reviewers that our submission was rejected?

(0) Thank | Shawn Yue

I am also like this today.

(0) Thank | heihei2122

2025.3.3 Submitted
2025.4.17 Awaiting Reviewer Assignment
2025.4.18 Awaiting TE Recommendation
Never experienced Awaiting Reviewer Scores
Do friends know what is going on? Will such a large journal be returned directly because reviewers cannot be found?

(0) Thank | Shawn Yue

Brother, can I ask again, is the "R" in your UR capitalized or lowercase?

(0) Thank | AllAccepted

Okay, thank you, bro.

(0) Thank | AllAccepted

The document number is new.

(0) Thank | LKN

Brother, have you changed the article number after RR?

(0) Thank | AllAccepted

The two after RR are two of the previous three, without changing the reviewers.

(0) Thank | LKN