The review cycle is very pleasing: submitted (11.27), firstly the editor reviewed it, then it was under review, and then we waited for reviewers to be assigned (12.24). Then, Awaiting Reviewer Scores (started from 12.24). This was equivalent to spending one month for the external review and scoring.

(7) Thank | 学界啄木鸟

I had two articles reviewed here. The first one was assigned for review in May 2018, submitted in July 2018, and revised in December 2018; the second review notice received in January 2019, review comments returned in March 2019, and review comments received in July 2019. Two reviewers; manuscript accepted. The second paper was assigned for review in March 2018, submitted in June 2018, and revised in September 2018; the second review notice received in September 2018, review comments returned in November 2018, and review comments received in July 2019. Four reviewers; manuscript rejected. This journal can be said to be extremely slow, with the second review for 7 to 8 months.

(6) Thank | zarathustr

Very difficult. From submission to acceptance, it lasted for one year and three months, with four revisions. The editor played an arbitration role. The journal focuses on novelty, practicality, and emphasizes the contrast with articles of the same theme.

(0) Thank | zhangshengguo@tsinghua.org.cn

Hello, what is your current status now? I also voted on the 16th.

(0) Thank | Cchy1

20250616 提交
20250617 等待SE分配

(0) Thank | 朱佳佳

Hey buddy, are you the one handling it today? I submitted on the 15th, still in Awaiting SE Assignment status.

(0) Thank | Cchy1

Rejected due to not being in line with the direction.

(0) Thank | sqdxc

But it feels like asking is useless, the answers are very perfunctory.

(0) Thank | AllAccepted

It feels like the editors of this journal are all part-time, and when encountering such procrastinating reviewers, they won't take the initiative to deal with it without being asked.

(0) Thank | chengyanghi

20250613 提交并等待管理员处理
20250614 等待SE分配

(0) Thank | sqdxc

The reviewers have been scoring for 49 days... Is there no limit to this journal?

(0) Thank | AllAccepted

TE and SE, are they going to fight...

(0) Thank | 希望早点顺利毕业

Why does it keep jumping back and forth between TE and SE, so strange.

(0) Thank | 希望早点顺利毕业

May I ask if a biography of the author is required for the first submission?

(0) Thank | 菜鸟9935

This kind of reviewer feels really unethical... completely lacks a sense of time... If they don't want to review, they should just accept it directly and be done with it...

(0) Thank | AllAccepted

I have been waiting for reviewers for 45 days today. The second review is also so slow...

(0) Thank | AllAccepted

11-Jun-2025 Awaiting SE Recommendation, this speed is a bit outrageous.

(0) Thank | 希望早点顺利毕业

In the same second review, the reviewer has been reviewing the manuscript for nearly 80 days, and there is still no result. At around 40 days, an email was sent to the editor, who replied that they are waiting for another reviewer and are hesitant to push for a faster review.

(0) Thank | chengyanghi

After I experienced your RR submission, an additional reviewer was added. It is estimated that the first reviewer added another 5 items (feels like a new reviewer), and gave a Major. I submitted again, hoping for a direct acceptance like you.

(0) Thank | 表面无所谓

After rejecting and resubmitting, will new reviewers be added?

(0) Thank | RAI

Please translate the following paragraph into English: It must not exceed 11 pages, with some minor deletions in other areas.

Thank you!

(0) Thank | Porsche

The reviewer's comments suggest a "reject with invitation to resubmit", and it is clearly stated in the email that the resubmission should not exceed 11 pages. However, the reviewer has provided many comments. Can the resubmission exceed 11 pages?

(0) Thank | qimao

You are so fast! I submitted my paper in September last year, received the first round of reviews in February, submitted revisions in early April, and I am still awaiting reviewer scores.

(0) Thank | Cicely12

It took me just over forty days as a reviewer.

(0) Thank | AllAccepted

You guys are already considered fast, it took me three months for the first trial and three months for the second trial. Now with the minor revisions, I don't know how long the third trial will take, probably another two months.

(0) Thank | 乌龟压死猪