The journal review is very careful, the opinions are very pertinent, and systematic research and analysis are required to be accepted.

(3) Thank | peng

Both the first review and the second review lasted more than half a year, and it took more than one year in total. It was finally accepted. Thanks to the reviewers, the review comments were professional, which greatly helped improve the quality of the article.

(5) Thank | makeitbetter

Manuscripts submitted in June 2018; revision notice received at the end of April 2019. The three reviewers gave a good overall evaluation of the paper and a lot of revision comments. It was revised for one and a half months, and a large number of analyses and experiments were added. The revision comments were returned in early June. Accepted in the middle of July. Thanks to the reviewers for their professional comments, which greatly improved the quality of the paper.

(10) Thank | cdd

IEEE TKDE is undoubtedly the most authoritative journal in the field of data mining in the world, with a high reputation in the international arena. There have been many publications in the field of computers, but now many business schools in the United States have widely accepted them as a list of A-level journals in business schools in areas such as MIS/MS/OM/MEM.

(1) Thank | Anonymous

How similar they are, it's too difficult.

(0) Thank | 再让我中一次

The first review took 6 months, with one major revision and one rejection, which the editor gave. After UR was sent back to the editor, it took one month to receive the result.

(0) Thank | AQYH

The official website has the LaTeX file, you can refer to that for modifications.

(0) Thank | 再让我中一次

Could you please tell me what are the requirements for submitting an article to this journal? I am a little confused about the format for the references section.

(0) Thank | Yoko0806

May I ask what are the requirements for submitting a review article to this journal? I am a bit confused about the formatting of the references section.

(0) Thank | Yoko0806

Update, 5.7 UR, 6.11 Reject (1 minor, 1 major, 1 reject)

(0) Thank | 再让我中一次

6 June 2025: Submission Started
7 June 2025: Under Review

(0) Thank | 永恒的谜团

I don't know. Maybe the paper has been sent back to the editor from the reviewer.

(0) Thank | 橙色小字

First UR changed to Ur, then Ur changed to UR, and now it is UR.

(0) Thank | AQYH

Shouldn't it be UR instead of Ur? The review speed of the journal is also too slow.

(0) Thank | 橙色小字

Are you still Ur? My Ur from last week has changed to UR.

(1) Thank | AQYH

Brothers, I submitted my paper in November in the old system and now I want to remind the reviewers, but the page is showing an error. Do any of you have a similar situation? How did you solve it?

(0) Thank | 橙色小字

Did you submit your paper through the IEEE Author Portal (new system)?

(0) Thank | 杨

I saw others saying that Xiaor has been submitted for review, and currently, that is the status.

(0) Thank | 再让我中一次

Have you submitted for review in three months?

(0) Thank | sun3939

Do you want to ask if you have submitted for review after three months?

(0) Thank | sun3939

Just want to ask you, have you submitted for review in three months?

(0) Thank | sun3939

Brothers, is the review cycle for this journal about a year? This speed is too slow.

(0) Thank | 橙色小字

Not a review, regular paper.

(0) Thank | stonechao

Bro, are you reviewing the synopsis?

(0) Thank | llllerrrrr

The paper was submitted on February 25, 2024 and is still under review. Despite numerous reminders, it has been six months since the last update, with the excuse of waiting for the final reviewer. Multiple follow-ups have been made since then, but there has been no progress. Has anyone experienced such slow reviewing process before? It has been one year and a half since the first review and still no outcome.

(0) Thank | stonechao