@Floor 49. It would be nice to see the comments on the 49th floor!!! You thought “in the aspect of Geoscience, the professionalism degree and reviewers’ rigor of IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing (TGRS) is not as high as those journals of seismic exploration, such as Geophysics or Geophysical Journal International”. I have just submitted an article to Geophysics, and now the associate editor is inviting the review experts. The impact factor of this journal is 2.793; it was just included in Q2 in 2020. If it won’t be accepted by Geophysics, then I will transfer it to TGRS. According to what you said, it's possible to get good out of misfortune. You think the article on geophysics should be submitted to TG.

(0) Thank | zhanghx031

Let me share how the recent two papers were going. After whole 1 year and 9 months, one manuscript was accepted at last~~. I was not really satisfied with the associate editor who was in charge of my manuscript. It took more than 2 months even for the manuscript with minor revisions to be accepted. 2018.3.6 submission; 2018.7.8 rejected and resubmit; 2018.11.3 submission after revision; 2019.6.14 major revision; 2019.8.6 submission after revision; 2019.9.18 minor revision; 19.9.28 submission; 2019.11.29 Editor-in-Chief accepted. The timeline of the other manuscript was follows. Since the associate editor changed, the efficiency of review process was significantly faster~~ 2019.7.20 submission; 2019.8.18 major revision; 2019.9.21 submission after revision; 2019.11. 24 acceptance.

(4) Thank | 解放西路刘德华

TGRS has high requirements for innovation, and the reviewers are of excellent lever. They’re very serious about the technical details and experiments of the article. The review speed was uncertain for it may be fast or slow, depending on the mood of the reviewer and the associate editor. The fastest one was completed for 3 months, and the other one was still under reviewing after 1 year and 2 months. One of the articles: submitted on February 15, 2019; major revision was made on March 29, 2019; submitted on April 12, 2019; accepted on May 15,2019.

(18) Thank | 解放西路刘德华

TGRS is preferred for more innovative findings. Good for mechanistic articles.

(17) Thank | Sam L

After submission, how long does it usually take to be sent for external review, and there is no possibility of desk rejection.

(0) Thank | 中中中12

Hello, may I ask if you resubmitted after being rejected, and what was the result?

(0) Thank | Qqqqsb

I have been waiting for almost 4 months, but it is still under review.

(0) Thank | tang11100

Boss, with the same question as the comment above, can I resubmit a rejected article within a month after rejection with the note "Rejected, not eligible for resubmission on 2024/11/1" and have it reviewed again? I am facing the same issue and would like to give it another try. Thank you for your response.

(0) Thank | ershisan23

Boss, regarding the same question as the comment above, can I resubmit for review within a month after being rejected with the reason "rejected, cannot be resubmitted" on 2024/11/1? I am currently facing the same issue and would like to give it another try, thank you.

(0) Thank | ershisan23

Likewise, thank you for the information. Can the rejected manuscript be revised and resubmitted for review?

(0) Thank | ershisan23

Hello, may I ask if the status after you submit is "submitted"? Why does it show "UR" right after I submit my contribution?

(0) Thank | dd_zz

Hello, will you send an email to the author when sending for external review?

(0) Thank | dd_zz

Yes, after submitting the article, it will be displayed as UR directly.

(0) Thank | 吃饭不吃南瓜

Submit 2024/09/20;
Major maintenance notice 2024/12/3
Submit revisions 2025/02/24 (Three months were given for revisions, other matters were relatively more)
Accept 2025/03/27

(0) Thank | maguolin

Excuse me, did the editor mention that resubmission is allowed? Did you resubmit?

(0) Thank | mudoI

How long does it usually take from "submitted" to "under review"? It has been two weeks since I submitted my manuscript and it is still showing as "submitted".

(0) Thank | yzh1111

How long does it take from submitted to ud?

(0) Thank | yzh1111

Could you confirm if you went directly from submission to revision? Thank you for your response.

(0) Thank | yzh1111

I am too. It has been two weeks since I submitted.

(0) Thank | yzh1111

May I ask if you went straight from submission to revision?

(0) Thank | yzh1111

I have also submitted two weeks ago.

(0) Thank | yzh1111

May I ask if it has been two weeks since you submitted? Are you going straight from submission to revision?

(0) Thank | yzh1111

Hello, I would like to ask if it is necessary to rewrite a new Cover Letter when returning from a major overhaul. Thank you.

(0) Thank | william

Hello, I received feedback after about 2 months of first review.

(0) Thank | william

I would like to ask everyone what to do if I discover a major error in my submission after submission and want to withdraw and resubmit. I have sent an email to the editor-in-chief but have not received a reply, and the manuscript is still under review.

(0) Thank | jiyujiyu