A total of four reviewers were invited, and it was accepted after four rounds of revisions. Each round was with editor for a long time. It took about 6–8 months from submission to the review results received. The review results included “revise and resubmit”, “conditionally accepted”, and “accept”. There is no “major revision” option in this journal. In the whole process, all reviewers were replaced after two rounds of “revise and resubmit”, which is equivalent to restarting. Conclusion: submit carefully.

(63) Thank | lacuna

The predecessor was IEEE Transactions on Robotics and Automation. It was divided into IEEE Transactions on Robotics and IEEE Transactions on Automation Science and Engineering. It is difficult to be accepted. 2018.11, submission; 2019.06, major revision; 2019.07, revision submitted; 2019.12, minor revision submitted; 2020.03, accepted. I do research on decision making, and it is a relatively important journal in the industry. There were 6 reviewers, but fortunately, it was accepted.

(38) Thank | gitter

Let me make a correction that the above ranking is corresponding to the category of the robotics-SLAM, not limited to all robotics. The comprehensive ranking that includes mechanical control, structure learning, etc., is probably IJRR, TRO, JFR, TMECH, TIE, TASE, TCYBER, TCST, TSMC, TIM, TCDS. The latest review record is as follows: it was submitted on May 28, 2018, conditionally accepted as a short essay on December 13, 2018, returned after revision on January 3, 2019, and accepted as a long essay on September 17, 2019. It took about 17 months and the review speed was relatively slow.

(46) Thank | zarathustr

The fourth-ranked journal in robotics, the first three are IJRR JFR TRO.This is the second time for acceptance. The time is as follows:Submitted 27-Dec-2017Revise and Resubmit 11-Jun-2018Revision Submitted 04-Aug-2018Accept As Regular 13-Dec-2018T-ASE is the second quarterly journal of SCI. It publishes about 150 manuscripts a year, and contributes about 1,500 copies in the whole year. The rejection rate is about 90%

(3) Thank | zarathustr

Some brothers have it, I have turned back to Awaiting Reviewer Scores.

(0) Thank | PQOGJCK

Has the status of "Awaiting reviewer scores" been eliminated since mid-April? After the review process begins, all statuses are now unified as "Under Review". Is there still a status of "Awaiting reviewer scores" now?

(0) Thank | Zoyrea

I submitted my paper at the end of December last year, and the status of the first review changed from "Awaiting reviewer scores" back to "Under review" in mid-April. It has been two weeks since then and it is still "Under review". I want to send an email to inquire, but who should I send it to?

(0) Thank | Zoyrea

Who should I send the reminder email to, EA, ED, or EIC?

(0) Thank | Zoyrea

It took 9 months, and personally I feel that the review process in the IEEE Transactions was relatively fast. The reviewers were professional and their feedback truly improved the overall quality of the paper. Communication with the journal staff was also smooth and friendly, and I hope the journal continues to improve! Finally, I hope everyone's submissions will be accepted smoothly!

(0) Thank | 予以繁星

The complete submission timeline is as follows:
2024.08.18 Awaiting Admin Processing
2024.08.28 Under Review
2024.12.18 Awaiting Associate Editor Recommendation
2025.01.23 Awaiting Reviewing Editor Decision
2025.01.23 Revise and Resubmit
2025.02.26 Awaiting Admin Checklist
2025.02.26 Under Review
2025.03.04 Awaiting Reviewer Scores
2025.04.05 Awaiting Associate Editor Recommendation
2025.04.28 Awaiting Reviewing Editor Decision
2025.04.28 Accept as Regular

(0) Thank | 予以繁星

How did it end in the end?

(0) Thank | 东大秀秀

Is it that bad? It's been two months already, desk reject?

(0) Thank | amerrr

Please translate the following paragraph into English: Released that day Awaiting Reviewing Editor Decision that day rj

(0) Thank | 岁寒ros

No, still waiting for the decision. It's strange, after two rounds of back and forth, they made the decision directly.

(0) Thank | amerrr

Today is directly Awaiting Reviewing Editor Decision.

(0) Thank | 岁寒ros

Awaiting Reviewing Editor Decision. Is there any follow-up?

(0) Thank | 岁寒ros

Did you pass, bro? Are you in the first review or the second review?

(0) Thank | shadow1

Yes, it is still under review.

(0) Thank | PQOGJCK

4.24 Awaiting Reviewer Scores

(0) Thank | AmMr

Are you still under review at the moment?

(0) Thank | Zoyrea

What is your current status now?

(0) Thank | Zoyrea

@ [shadow1] This completely depends on the Reviewing Editor, while another article has been waiting for nearly a month for the Reviewing Editor's decision.

(0) Thank | Jacky Tan

Is it normal for it to take so long from "Awaiting Reviewing Editor Decision" to receiving the outcome?

(0) Thank | shadow1

Can this journal still be invited to participate in the conference?

(0) Thank | shadow1

I submitted with a 2.7, and today it also changed from Awaiting Reviewer Scores back to under review.

(0) Thank | PQOGJCK