18 Sep, first submission; 19 Sep, editor assigned.

(0) Thank | Yufei Zhang

Which quartile is this journal now? This kind of journal that categorized in Q3 for large category, and Q2 for small category should be counted as which quartile?

(0) Thank | 青豌豆

For various types of articles the review time for different research directions varies greatly.

(2) Thank | Anonymous

How is the reviewing speed?

(0) Thank | 仙灵东宇

Hello, how long does it usually take for reviewers to be assigned? And what does the changing date represent?

(0) Thank | totalG

Hello, how long does it usually take for Reviewers Assigned? It changed to this status today.

(0) Thank | totalG

This submission process was quite fast. The review period for each submission is approximately 25 days, less than a month. However, it was still quite frustrating as it required three revisions in total. The editors hold significant power as they can invite other reviewers if the editor approves but the reviewers do not. The review process is very detailed, and the comments provided are constructive and valuable. Overall, it is a good journal.

As for the journal's classification, the advanced version has been upgraded to the second tier, while the basic version has been downgraded to the third tier. It is quite perplexing as to what the final classification will be.

(0) Thank | douboshi

May I ask if there has been no progress after completing the reviews?

(0) Thank | douboshi

Submitted: 3.10, 2021
Reviews Completed: 4.27
Reviews Completed: 5.28
Reviews Completed: Ongoing

I feel that the speed is very slow. The acceptance rate on the journal's website is 25%, and it is classified as a level 2 journal in the Chinese Academy of Sciences' subcategory and level 3 journal in the main category. The cost-effectiveness is not very high. This is my first time submitting to this journal, so I don't know how reputable it is.

(0) Thank | 小人

District 3, usually domestic universities and research institutes pay attention to the JCR partition of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, so you only need to look at the partition of the major categories in front...

(0) Thank | Yufei Zhang

Review Speed: 3.0 
Experience Sharing: May I ask which zone is this journal classified under now? How would you categorize it in terms of major, moderate, or minor zones

(0) Thank | Beverly Yule

The editor of this journal is very responsible,Modifying it back and forth three times, the language requirements are particularly high, I have finished the language twice before passing.A very responsible journal is also an old journal, but how can IF not go up, it is always three districts, when is it to the second district

(0) Thank | 小瓶盖

The editor of this journal is very responsible, and it is modified three times. It has a very high language requirement. I have finished the language twice.Very responsible journals, but also old journals, but how can IF not go up, it is always three districts, when is the second district ah

(0) Thank | 小瓶盖

Review speed: 10.0 Experience sharing: The editor of this journal is very responsible. After revising it three times, the language requirements are particularly high. I polished the language twice before it was accepted. It is a very responsible journal, although it is an old journal, but why can't it be promoted to the second district? It has always been in the third district. When will it be promoted to the second district?

(0) Thank | 百花碧儿

The editor of this journal is very responsible. After three rounds of revision, the language requirements are particularly high. I polished the language twice before it was accepted. It is a very responsible journal and has been around for a long time, but why hasn't it been upgraded to a higher level yet? It has always been in the third tier. When will it be upgraded to the second tier?

(0) Thank | Robin Macaulay

has reviewed the manuscript of this journal twice. The deputy editors are required to return the review comments within 20 days. Maybe I am more disciplined, and I will submit the review comments within 20 days.Perhaps other reviewers are too busy to submit review comments on time, so some comments on the manuscript review are postponed.

(4) Thank | Anonymous

Review Speed: 6.0
Experience Sharing: I have reviewed manuscripts for this journal twice, and both times the associate editor requested the review comments to be returned within 20 days. Perhaps I am more rule-abiding, as I always submit the review comments within 20 days. It is possible that other reviewers are too busy to submit their comments on time, resulting in delays in the review process for some manuscripts

(0) Thank | 金梅小可爱

Journal Homepage URL: http://http://www.springer.com/l ... ology/journal/10750

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Super slow, it's been 4 months and the initial review hasn't finished yet

(0) Thank | 凌霄高洁

Chief Editor Koen Martens

(0) Thank | 独孤安天

Editor Koen Martens

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Review speed: 3.0 | Submission hit rate: 50.0 Experience sharing: It took a year to submit and publish a paper

(0) Thank | 五轮博达

sent an article, one year before and after one year

(0) Thank | Anonymous

My article is in the Editor Invited state for one month, no language

(2) Thank | Anonymous

The review speed is very fast. The articles on domestic lakes and reservoirs will generally invite domestic experts to review the manuscript, so it is necessary to pay attention to the lack of Chinese.this problem.

(2) Thank | Anonymous