It’s miserable. I thought it was the top in Q1, but it suddenly dropped to Q3 in the field of Soil Science. My God!

(0) Thank | ......................

It was forced out of Q1 and could not even retain Q2. I am bitterly disappointed.

(1) Thank | 寂玄道隐士

A classic journal of soil science with high quality articles. The editor was very professional and responsible, and even helped to modify the language.

(4) Thank | keepflying

This journal is very good. The quality of the articles is very good, and German articles account for a large part. International submission is still a bit difficult.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

It has been almost a month since the submission, and the status has now changed to Awaiting Reviewer Assignment.

(0) Thank | Nick

Carolmachong, how long has your under review status been going on for?

(0) Thank | Nick

After two months of submission, received major revisions comments, the reviewer was very good at PUA, in short, the overall direction was fine, but a lot of detailed suggestions were given. After one month of major revisions, waited for almost half a year, probably the original reviewer could not be found, and had to go through two more rounds of major revisions, only to be rejected directly by the editor-in-chief. It is suggested not to submit to this journal if your study leans towards engineering applications, as the reviewer's questions were very amateurish.

(0) Thank | YIMU0000

Does non-OA require additional page charges?

(0) Thank | Mia_LV

Do we need to pay additional page charges for non-OA publications?

(0) Thank | Mia_LV

May 5, 2024 - Submitted
September 21, 2024 - Major revision
October 11, 2024 - Revised
October 20, 2024 - Minor revision
October 21, 2024 - Revised
October 24, 2024 - Waiting for AE

(0) Thank | KSLX

8.6 Minor repair
8.14 Minor repair
8.20 Accepted! Hahahaha...

(0) Thank | 向云端嗯嗯嗯

Keep going, give it one last push, looking forward to more good news, wishing you all the best.

(0) Thank | 望乡

7.19 awaiting reviewer assignment
7.20 awaiting reviewer scores
During the initial revision, the editor provided 5 comments, while the two reviewers provided a total of 17 comments. In the week before the revision, the editor changed it to a minor revision, which was quite magical!

(0) Thank | 向云端嗯嗯嗯

7.15 Submit revised manuscript
7.17 Under review (ADM: Rathinavel, Dharani)

(0) Thank | 向云端嗯嗯嗯

I couldn't get in touch with the original reviewer, so I had to change to a new one for the second review. I've been waiting for 4 months for the second review. I'm really scared that the original reviewer has disappeared!

(0) Thank | 向云端嗯嗯嗯

It's been about a month and a half, but I am awaiting reviewer scores. In the old system, I could check the status of the review, the first review took about two months, then awaiting AE recommendation, followed by awaiting DE recommendation, and finally awaiting EIC decision. In fact, the handling by the associate editor, editor, and chief editor is relatively fast, adding up to only about a week. I suspect the slow process may be due to difficulty in finding reviewers. After my major revisions, one of the reviewers could not be contacted and had to be replaced, leading to a 4-month wait for the second review before ultimately being accepted. I suggest you can send a polite email to inquire with the editor, usually they will give you a response. Good luck!

(1) Thank | Earth Worker

May I ask how long it took for the initial review to start after you submitted your application? Mine has been under review for over two months now.

(0) Thank | ，了，，

The first submission to EJSS was accepted after a major revision. The review process was very strict, with many comments from the reviewers and editors. The review process was not fast, so patience is needed when submitting an article.

(1) Thank | Earth Worker

6.21 Major Revision, major revision. I went to the editor in the morning and received feedback on the major revision in the afternoon!

(0) Thank | 向云端嗯嗯嗯

6.21 Awaiting EIC Decision.

(0) Thank | 向云端嗯嗯嗯

6.7 Awaiting DE Recommendation

(0) Thank | 向云端嗯嗯嗯

6.6 Awaiting AE Recommendation

(0) Thank | 向云端嗯嗯嗯

The 8000-word limit for this journal refers to the word count excluding references, not the entire text being limited to 8000 words. This condition should be fairly easy to meet, right? Mine is around 6000 words excluding references

(0) Thank | 向云端嗯嗯嗯

Hello friend, I have seen your traces in many journals and feel that we should be in related fields. May I ask if the word limit of this journal (8000) is very strict? Thank you~

(0) Thank | 24March

Okay, thank you

(0) Thank | carolmachong