It’s miserable. I thought it was the top in Q1, but it suddenly dropped to Q3 in the field of Soil Science. My God!

(0) Thank | ......................

It was forced out of Q1 and could not even retain Q2. I am bitterly disappointed.

(1) Thank | 寂玄道隐士

A classic journal of soil science with high quality articles. The editor was very professional and responsible, and even helped to modify the language.

(4) Thank | keepflying

This journal is very good. The quality of the articles is very good, and German articles account for a large part. International submission is still a bit difficult.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

2025.07.31 Under review (after rework)

(0) Thank | No 89757

On June 30, 2025, there was a major revision. The chief editor worked very quickly, giving feedback to the EIC in the morning and receiving comments in the afternoon. One reviewer provided a major revision (with over ten suggestions) and the other provided a minor revision, which the chief editor accepted. Thanks to the chief editor and the two reviewers.

(0) Thank | No 89757

Awaiting good news from the chief editor by 2025.06.30.

(0) Thank | No 89757

2025.06.26 Awaiting DE Recommendation. After more than half a year, the status has finally changed.

(0) Thank | No 89757

Yes. It has changed from "awaiting reviewer assignment" to "under review".

(0) Thank | Nick

Is it in the old submission system ScholarOne?

(0) Thank | No 89757

Currently under review.

(0) Thank | Nick

What is your current status? Nick.

(0) Thank | No 89757

Hello, OP! Any response to the reminder letter? It's been two months since I submitted mine...

(1) Thank | Nick

2024.12.10 (Submitted)
2024.12.11 (Awaiting DE Assignment)
2024.12.18 (Awaiting reviewer Assignment)
2024.12.28 (Under review)
2025.01.26 (Awaiting reviewer Assignment)
2025.03.08 (Awaiting Reviewer Scores)
2025.05.10 (Still Awaiting Reviewer Scores)
I sent a reminder email on 2025.05.06 and still have not received any response. The submission system status has not changed either. I feel very desperate, what should I do...

(0) Thank | No 89757

It has been almost a month since the submission, and the status has now changed to Awaiting Reviewer Assignment.

(0) Thank | Nick

Carolmachong, how long has your under review status been going on for?

(0) Thank | Nick

After two months of submission, received major revisions comments, the reviewer was very good at PUA, in short, the overall direction was fine, but a lot of detailed suggestions were given. After one month of major revisions, waited for almost half a year, probably the original reviewer could not be found, and had to go through two more rounds of major revisions, only to be rejected directly by the editor-in-chief. It is suggested not to submit to this journal if your study leans towards engineering applications, as the reviewer's questions were very amateurish.

(0) Thank | YIMU0000

Does non-OA require additional page charges?

(0) Thank | Mia_LV

Do we need to pay additional page charges for non-OA publications?

(0) Thank | Mia_LV

May 5, 2024 - Submitted
September 21, 2024 - Major revision
October 11, 2024 - Revised
October 20, 2024 - Minor revision
October 21, 2024 - Revised
October 24, 2024 - Waiting for AE

(0) Thank | KSLX

8.6 Minor repair
8.14 Minor repair
8.20 Accepted! Hahahaha...

(0) Thank | 向云端嗯嗯嗯

Keep going, give it one last push, looking forward to more good news, wishing you all the best.

(0) Thank | 望乡

7.19 awaiting reviewer assignment
7.20 awaiting reviewer scores
During the initial revision, the editor provided 5 comments, while the two reviewers provided a total of 17 comments. In the week before the revision, the editor changed it to a minor revision, which was quite magical!

(0) Thank | 向云端嗯嗯嗯

7.15 Submit revised manuscript
7.17 Under review (ADM: Rathinavel, Dharani)

(0) Thank | 向云端嗯嗯嗯

I couldn't get in touch with the original reviewer, so I had to change to a new one for the second review. I've been waiting for 4 months for the second review. I'm really scared that the original reviewer has disappeared!

(0) Thank | 向云端嗯嗯嗯