Half a year has passed, and I suddenly want to provide this submission experience, only for your reference~ 2019.8.06 submission; 2019.9.11 receive review comments (Minor Revision) (two reviewers, each proposed 4–5 constructive suggestions on some details such as research content, figure legends and table headers. No experimental supplements were involved) 2019.9.17 submit after minor revisions; 2019.9.28 accepted. The overall feeling is that this submission period is the shortest in my history. Editors and reviewers were very rigorous and responsible. They were strict with the research content and text details. The speed and process of reviewing a manuscript may vary greatly in different research directions. I wish everyone a smooth acceptance and I wish ET an early advancement to Q3!

(6) Thank | SDream

2019.12.06, submission; 2020.01.18, revision comments were received, and major revision was required (2 reviewers, the first one raised 2 comments, the second one raised 28 comments); 2020.03.02, the article was submitted after revision (it was delayed during the period, the second was too careful and too responsible to point out the punctuation of the references); 2020.03.07, accept. P.S.: Overall, the work is meticulous, and the requirements for innovation is not high. Be careful when replying to reviewers' comments, and the articles would not be difficult to be accepted. Finally: I wish the journal gets better and better!!!

(4) Thank | 康师傅脑残酸菜面

2018-12-14, submission; 2019-01-24, review comments returned (minor revision); 2019-02-21, first revised manuscript submission; 2019-03-27, review comments (major revision); 2019-04-03, second revised manuscript submission; 2019-05-22, review comments returned (minor revision); 2019-05-26, third revised manuscript submission and no review comments haven’t been given still now.

(5) Thank | Terminal

1 month review. 5 reviewers. Used an editing service to avoid language and formatting issues. This journal prioritizes practical applications.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Does their company hire only by selecting whether to do OA?

(0) Thank | Yang 13

Hired, waiting for proofreading!

(0) Thank | sing

Do you have a summary figure to submit?

(0) Thank | Yang 13

Boss, ask when the journal will choose OA and non-OA!

(0) Thank | sing

Boss, may I ask when this journal will choose between OA and non-OA?

(0) Thank | sing

Boss, may I ask when this journal will choose between OA and non-OA?

(0) Thank | sing

Boss, may I ask when this publication will choose between OA and non-OA?

(0) Thank | sing

Boss, may I ask when this magazine chooses OA and non-OA articles?

(0) Thank | sing

Boss, could you please tell me when this journal selects OA and non-OA articles?

(0) Thank | sing

June 15, 2025 Major Renovation

(0) Thank | sing

2025.05.04 Submission
After that, it has been showing "Under review" all the time.
2025.06.26 Rejection
This journal seems to reject once a reviewer rejects, making it difficult to submit. Additionally, during the submission process, there is also no detailed review progress visible, overall the experience is not good.

(0) Thank | rainday

Submitted on September 24, 2024
Major revision on October 25, 2024
Minor revision on November 20, 2024
Accepted on December 11, 2024
Limited academic ability, please refer to 10.1080/09593330.2024.2447627 for more citations.

(0) Thank | 我不是李佳龙

Could you please advise on how to complete the proofreading? The website is always not accessible, which is causing me a lot of anxiety.

(0) Thank | 晴天

2024.10.25 Submitted
2025.2.02 Major Revision
2025.3.28 Revised
2025.5.08 Accept

(0) Thank | 谈论雨天晴天

2024.10.25 sub
2025.2.02 Major Revision
2025.3.28 revised
2025.5.08 Accept

(0) Thank | 谈论雨天晴天

Under Review 26-Apr

(0) Thank | 马里奥-小C

Under review 4-26

(0) Thank | sing

May I ask what is your current status and how long it has been going on for?

(0) Thank | sdhfs

After submission, the manuscript goes under review, and then the reviewer comments are received directly.

(0) Thank | 冰雨灬

How long does it usually take for a submission to be under review after submission?

(0) Thank | sdhfs

Hello, I would like to ask why is it always showing as "uploading" when I try to save my cover letter after uploading it?

(0) Thank | 唐三