It lasted for nine months and was inexplicably rejected! 14 Jun 2019 Reject; 29 May 2019 Author Revision; 20 Apr 2019 Editor Decision-Minor Revision; 31 Mar 2019 Author Revision; 06 Mar 2019 Editor decision-Major Revision; 30 Jan 2019 Author Revision; 02 Dec 2018 Editor decision -Major Revision; 11 Sep 2018 AU-Submission Confirmation.

(2) Thank | Adonty

The journal is pretty good. IF has increased every year and I hope it will reach 4 next year. 2019.4.1 submission, 2019.7.28 major revision required; 2019.8.5 submission after revision; 2019.8.22 acceptance!!

(2) Thank | 微风下的垂柳

I submitted the manuscript in the mid-September 2018, and it was accepted at the end of January 2019, one major revision, one minor revision, comments from editors and reviewers were very useful. After revision, I felt that the article was much better.

(0) Thank | haloua

Fairly smooth process, but slow. About 8 months.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Hello, I would like to ask, approximately how long does it take for the network to be launched after being sent to production?

(0) Thank | ddxiaodh

Hello, I would like to ask, approximately how long does it take for the network to be launched after being sent to production?

(0) Thank | ddxiaodh

Hello, I would like to ask, after sent to production, how long does it take for the network to release it?

(0) Thank | ddxiaodh

The results have been submitted but are still unknown. We hope to publish them as soon as possible.

(0) Thank | bk

2025.03.04 Submission received
2025.03.05 Editor assigned
2025.03.07 First reviewer(s) invited
2025.04.02 Revision received
2025.04.10 accepted

(0) Thank | 西瓜喵喵

Excuse me, how long after receiving the admission letter will the proofreading be done? It's been almost two weeks since I received the admission letter, but I haven't received any proofreading news yet.

(0) Thank | 挺帅无法取代

Hello, may I ask how long it takes to receive the proofreading notification after receiving the admission email? I have been waiting for two weeks without any further updates.

(0) Thank | 挺帅无法取代

Hello, may I ask how long it will take to receive the proofreading notification after receiving the acceptance letter email?

(0) Thank | 挺帅无法取代

Hello, may I ask how long it will take to proofread after receiving the acceptance notification email? I received the acceptance email two weeks ago, but I have not been asked to proofread yet.

(0) Thank | 挺帅无法取代

It's a pretty good journal, difficult to get accepted, with high-quality articles. The initial review to revisions takes around three months, and subsequent revisions take one month. But now it has become a fourth-tier journal, which is quite surprising and really hard to understand its evaluation.

(0) Thank | shakingj

The two replies to the reminder for submission are both templates, with exactly the same content...

(0) Thank | QianW

Submission on 24.11.05
Invitation to the first batch of reviewers on 24.11.28
Received comments from the first reviewer on 04.12.04
As of 25.02.06, still have not received comments from the first reviewer
(A reminder was sent on 1.16, and was informed that the paper had been assigned to a second reviewer, but the status did not change)
What is the situation? Do we need to send another reminder? Does anyone know what the issue is?

(0) Thank | QianW

Classmate/teacher, may I ask which direction you are voting for?

(0) Thank | NIUQIUYAN

The proofreading behind the scenes is done by the corresponding author, I'm not very clear about it.

On October 8th, Submission is in publishing and rights, the teacher forwarded this to me, there is an online correction work, because I have several references that didn't match, so they asked me about this reference, and I answered it.

On October 14th, Publishing and rights complete, the teacher operated it and I don't know what they did, I selected non-OA for submission so there is no fee required; the current interface prompt says: We've sent your submission to production. Our production department will be in touch with your proofs within 2 weeks of receiving your submission. They will email the corresponding author with all further updates.

(0) Thank | Lee55

Hello, may I ask how long did your initial review take?

(0) Thank | ddxiaodh

Acceptance and proofreading emails are sent within a 2-week period.

(0) Thank | 兽兽1

Hello teacher/classmate, I would like to inquire about how long it usually takes to receive and review the school's draft email. Thank you.

(0) Thank | 李狗蛋

The corresponding author will receive a publishing agreement to sign as well as an electronic galley proof email.

(0) Thank | 兽兽1

Hello teacher/classmate, I would like to inquire about what operations need to be done by the corresponding author after the EGH article is accepted. Do we need to choose open access/traditional subscription and then wait for the correction email? Will these notifications be sent on the day the article is accepted or will there be another email sent separately? I hope for your guidance, thank you very much.

(0) Thank | 李狗蛋

Hello teacher/classmate, I would like to inquire about what further actions need to be taken by the corresponding author after the article is accepted. Do they need to choose open access/traditional subscription and wait for the proofreading email?

(0) Thank | 李狗蛋

Sediments, organic pollutants
Submission on August 10, 2024
Sent for review on August 23, 2024, with 4 reviewers accepting the review
First review on September 11, 2024, major revisions required based on feedback from 3 reviewers, one of whom stated that the overall structure was very poor (likely leading to rejection)
One reviewer from India, who had previously reviewed another paper of mine, provided similar feedback this time and even requested citation of his work
Two weeks allowed for revisions
Accepted on October 1, 2024
Grateful for the kindness of the editorial team at EGH, as typically journals do not provide a chance for revisions if one reviewer rejects a submission, but EGH allowed me the opportunity to make changes, for which I am very thankful
Hoping for the journal to continue improving and increasing in quality.

(0) Thank | Lee55