It feels very fast. The review comments returned in one month, requiring a major revision. We revised it for a month and a half, then received a notification of acceptance around 20 days later. It took a total of more than 3 months. I am very optimistic about the journal, and I hope I will keep on trying my best.

(1) Thank | shuidaoerhao

2020.02.05 first submission; 2020.03.17 receive review comments; 2020.03.21 revised submission; 2020.04.16 acceptance.

(2) Thank | 补刀12

The review speed in the journal is extremely fast. It was submitted on September 30 and was directly rejected on October 1. The review comments given said that it was not innovative enough and there were no more novel research conclusions on the mechanism. The research I do is about plant drought physiology and ecology. In short, the journal focuses on the novelty of the mechanism.

(5) Thank | 小小游侠

Very slow for a rejection.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Could I ask, it has been two months since the external audit, and three reviewers have completed their reviews. The status is "Required Reviews Completed" for a week now. How long will it take to receive feedback?

(0) Thank | 树懒颖

The journal review process is a bit slow, it has been almost three months since submission, and it is still under review...

(0) Thank | 耿耿

24.5.26 Under review
Unable to find reviewer, 34 have been invited, just need one more reviewer, asking kind reviewers to help review the child, thank you!

(0) Thank | 小博的毕业之路

Submission progress:
24.4.17 submitted
24.4.18 with editor

(0) Thank | 一定要中！

Okay, thank you

(0) Thank | 阿超不会飞

3 reviewers

(0) Thank | 否极终泰来

2024.2.4  2 reviewers accepted the review
2024.2.4  4 reviewers accepted the review
2024.2.12  1 review feedback returned
2024.2.15  2 review feedback returned Required Reviews Completed
2024.2.18  3 review feedback returned Required Reviews Completed

(0) Thank | 阿超不会飞

One reviewer has accepted the review. Thank you very much. We only need one more reviewer to complete the process

(0) Thank | 阿超不会飞

2024.1.25 under review. The editor invited 15 reviewers, but still no one has reviewed

(0) Thank | 阿超不会飞

2024.1.6 Submit to Journal
2024.1.7 With editor
2024.1.9 Under review
2024.1.12 Under review
2024.1.17 Under review
Can't find reviewers for the manuscript, editor has invited 13 already. Kindly request reviewers to help review the manuscript for the child, and provide some suggestions for revision. Thank you

(1) Thank | 阿超不会飞

Please translate the following paragraph into English and Japanese, and title them as "English Translation:" and "Japanese Translation:"

(1) Thank | 翡翠台沸腾鱼

Hello, how many reviewers are you?

(0) Thank | 阿超不会飞

Hello, how are your reviewers doing? Do they have many comments?

(0) Thank | 阿超不会飞

Is your test result out?

(0) Thank | 阿超不会飞

Best submission experience ever, editor processed it promptly, and reviewers were also very nice

(0) Thank | 张小飞

Submission record
23.12.08 submit
23.12.09 with editor
23.12.10 under review
23.12.18 under review (status unchanged, date updated

(0) Thank | 翡翠台沸腾鱼

The editing process is very fast, the reviewers are very careful, and it feels quite good. Share the submission progress:
8/23/15: Submit
8/23/19: Under review
9/24/23: Major revise
10/10/23: Revised manuscript submitted
11/12/23: Minor revise
11/15/23: Received in revised manuscript
11/18/23: Accept

(2) Thank | 否极终泰来

How long does it take to receive proof after ordering online?

(0) Thank | Margaret711

22.8/23 submit - Submitted on August 22nd
22.9/15 under review - Under review since September 15th
22.10/12 major revise - Major revisions required on October 12th
22.11/10 revised MS submit - Revised manuscript submitted on November 10th
22.11/21 accept - Accepted on November 21st

The first round of submission was slower, but the other stages were fast. The editor was helpful.

(0) Thank | undefined

2022.10.22 submitted
2022.10.25 with editor

Translation: The submission was made on October 22nd, 2022. On October 25th, it was with the editor.

(1) Thank | ziii

Hello, do we only need confirmation from one author? I have confirmed, but it still says "with editor". How long does it take to submit for review?

(0) Thank | ziii