22-May-2020 to 04-Jul-2020, R1: Two opinions, one minor revision, one acceptance; 31-Jul-2020 to 04-Aug-2020, R2: Accepted. The article is mainly about experimental research on similar material gaps and model building. I personally feel that the journal is biased towards application. It is recommended to indicate the specific application background when writing the article.

(0) Thank | Rockyyoung

Relatively slow. Quite difficult.

(4) Thank | hpqz19911215

2024.06.09 submit;
awaiting ea checklist
2024.06.16 awaiting referee selection
2024.09.23 major revision
2024.10.24 receive referee comments
10.24 to present Awaiting Editorial Office Checklist

(0) Thank | 十年旧梦寻心

Too slow, incredibly slow, have sent an email to withdraw the submission.
01-Aug-2024 Awaiting EA Checklist
29-Aug-2024 Awaiting EA Checklist

(0) Thank | 张帆

May I ask what topics this journal covers?

(0) Thank | hwy0216

Could I ask the host, is it a total of 4-5 months from submission to acceptance?

(0) Thank | ccccc

2024.06.09 submit;
Awaiting EA Checklist
2024.06.16 Awaiting Referee Selection

(1) Thank | 十年旧梦寻心

2022.06.09 submit

(1) Thank | 十年旧梦寻心

The only journal that saved me from failing to graduate has a very slow turnaround time, taking 4-5 months to respond. However, I feel that the reviewers are quite professional and can provide an objective evaluation of my work. I am extremely grateful and thankful to this journal! Brothers and sisters seeking speed should consider carefully

(1) Thank | 希希606

Comrades, you have never seen a well-connected person before. A certain Dr. C9 submitted an article to this journal, and it was accepted on the second day after submission

(0) Thank | 真正的四区哥

2022-08-29  submit
2022-10-10  has passed initial screening and is now awaiting reviewer selection
2023-03-08  Major Revision
2023-03-16  submit
2023-04-04  awaiting reviewer invitation
2023-09-06  Minor Revision
2023-09-20  submit
2023-09-26  accept
Overall, the editorial processing speed is relatively timely (ps: editors rarely reply during the contact), the speed mainly depends on the external review experts, and after the first revision, one external review expert delayed for a long time

(0) Thank | vengo

2023.8.3 Reception

(0) Thank | NICE_小白

May I ask how many reviewers' opinions you have received? I only have one.

(0) Thank | yu..

2023.03.08 Reject. From 2022.06.28, it took over 8 months to receive feedback from the first review, and now you're telling me it's rejected??? What a trash journal. I will never submit to it again.

(0) Thank | Galactic Hearts

Translate the following text into English: "2023.3.8 大修 给三个月时间修改"

"2023.3.8 Major renovation, three months given for modifications."

(0) Thank | NICE_小白

What is the result? Was it accepted?

(0) Thank | yu..

2023.03.06: Still awaiting editor-in-chief decision. This state has been ongoing for about 50 days, and it has been over 8 months since submission without any first-round results. The speed is truly touching. If it is ultimately rejected, there will be nowhere to cry.

(0) Thank | Galactic Hearts

2023.02.17 Still awaiting editor-in-chief decision. This state has been going on for a month now. It has been almost 8 months since submission, and the initial review results are still not out... What a slow pace.

(0) Thank | Galactic Hearts

May I ask if you have obtained the results for this?

(0) Thank | NICE_小白

Waiting for the editor-in-chief to make a decision on 2023.2.16.

(0) Thank | NICE_小白

Dumbass Journal, submitted in July, sent for review in October, incredibly slow, always "awaiting referee selection", all because of this Li editor-in-chief, I've sent five or six emails and received no response, I even sent one in Chinese, extremely time-wasting!!

(0) Thank | DDD

2022.12.30: Awaiting scores from the referee.
2023.01.22: Awaiting decision from the editor-in-chief.
2023.01.28: Awaiting decision from the editor-in-chief.

(0) Thank | Galactic Hearts

2023/1/12 Awaiting Editor-in-Chief Decision. 

Translation: We are waiting for the decision of the Editor-in-Chief on January 12, 2023.

(0) Thank | vengo

I see that both of the comments above were submitted over three months ago, and then on December 10th, they changed to "awaiting referee scores" - the external review status. However, my submission of over five months is still "awaiting referee selection." I don't know what's going on, it's frustrating.

(0) Thank | Galactic Hearts

The chief editor is Professor Li, Chengfeng.

(0) Thank | Galactic Hearts