May 18, 2020, submitted to journal; May 18, 2020 with editor; May 19, 2020, Under Review; June 18, 2020, Revise. The editor's opinion plus three reviewers' opinions, a total of more than 30 comments were received. A month was given for revision. The first reviewer was more interested in the content of the article and generally satisfied with the manuscript. The comments he raised was also more pertinent and comprehensive (12 comments were made by him alone). July 14, 2020, revision submitted to journal; August 5, 2020 revise. The second review comments returned. The editor had two requirements for formats. Reviewer 1 raised 6 more questions based on the replies to the first review. Both reviewers 2 and 3 said that there are no more questions. This time 15 days were given for revision. August 17, 2020, revision submitted to journal; August 17, 2020, with editor; August 18, 2020, Under Review; August 24, 2020, Accept. It seems that there was information from the editorial office still needed to be filled in. The new IF this year has also reached 8.2. It is a very responsible and efficient top journal, and I will continue to support ECM in the future.

(7) Thank | Lovely_Sunshine

Submitted to Journal: 2019.11.11; With Editor: 2019.11.12; Under Review: 2019.11.13; Under Review: 2019.11.21; Under Editor Evaluation: 2019.12.11; Revise (Recommendation-From Reviews and Editor) within one month: 2019.12.19; Revision Submitted to Journal: 2020.1.13; With Editor: 2020.1.14; Under Review: 2020.1.14; Accept Pending Journal Confirmation: 2020.1.22 (choose one to confirm from ECM and ECMX; the latter is open source; we selected ECM, only replaced the Cover Letter, and other files cannot be modified and replaced); Revision Submitted to Journal: 2020.1.25 (the first day of the year Geng Zi); With Editor: 2020.1.27; Completed-Accept: 2020.1.27.

(3) Thank | 仝了个仝飞

This was my first submission; the speed was very fast. The editors and reviewers were very professional. There were more than 50 comments given by the 5 reviewers and editor in the first review, which was helpful to the revision and improvement of the manuscript! Share you the process: Submitted to journal: 11.09; with editor: 11.10; under review: 11.10; under editor evaluation: 11.24; under editor evaluation: 11.29; under editor evaluation: 11.30; revise (modify—general changes): 12.02; revision submitted to journal: 12.20; with editor: 12.22; under review: 12.22; under editor evaluation: 01.24; revise (revise—specific changes): 01.24; revision submitted to journal: 01.26; with editor: 01.28; accept: 01.28.

(34) Thank | 小神鹿

7 month review.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

A while ago, I saw a post on Xiaohongshu that someone had recorded in their hands. They were quite lucky, as they always seemed to catch her online. My article was submitted for second review on June 24, and I was told to wait 2 weeks for a response. The review was completed on July 3, but since then there has been no further communication. I have followed up multiple times, and the journal manager has also tried to help by saying they will contact me, but there has been no response. I have also sent emails to the editor, but they have not been read.

(0) Thank | 风清扬

Brother, currently I am also this editor, Valerie Eveloy, Ph.D. The second reviewer also ran away, and now the editor has invited a new reviewer, but it has been a month and no new reviewer has accepted the review. Should I follow up on this situation, did you follow up with the editor at that time?

(0) Thank | Accept

I am now also a reviewer who has finished reviewing and stopped processing. I want to know if there are any submissions accepted by Amy, and I would like a complete submission timeline for reference.

(0) Thank | Pei·Chen

One of them was only reviewed on July 4th, and it's still dragging on. We contacted them on WeChat and they said they would speed up the process, but it's still the same now. Sigh.

(0) Thank | syh

Has anyone encountered this before?

(0) Thank | laolunterose

Siir KILKIS, Ph.D.

(0) Thank | hw

Why does my display show that 2+ reviewers have been invited, where can I see the specific number?

(0) Thank | Yukun Ma

2025-07-27 RRC 10-4-3

Could you please translate the above sentence into English?

(0) Thank | 海优外青

So fast! Come on!!!

(0) Thank | Fortnight

2025-07-23 RRC, 10-4-2

Could you please translate the following paragraph into English: 2025-07-23 RRC, 10-4-2

(1) Thank | 海优外青

Good luck and receive good fortune!!~

(0) Thank | Fortnight

Thank you for your friendly reminder! Wish you all the best!

(0) Thank | Fortnight

July 20, 2025 With Editor

(0) Thank | Fortnight

I really don't understand why it's so slow now. It's not easy to maintain a good reputation for ECM.

(0) Thank | 蓝蓝蓝洛

The paper has been submitted, wishing all my buddies could also be smoothly accepted. The processing speed is quite fast.
2025.5.7 Submit
2025.5.7 with editor (Submission is also)
2025.5.8 with editor (The time has changed, but the status has not)
2025.5.8 Under review
2025.6.22 Revise (Three more experiments need to be added, one month given for revisions)
2025.7.8 Under review
2025.7.14 Required Reviews Completed
2025.7.17 Accept
Hope this is helpful for my buddies.

(0) Thank | 玉皇飞云

May I ask why it has been 10 days since acceptance and still no online?

(1) Thank | Accepted！！！

On July 17, 2025, your 10-4-1 had a reviewer who finished reviewing in 12 minutes, it's incredible...

(0) Thank | 海优外青

It's been 20 days and we're still.

(0) Thank | Pei·Chen

Congratulations, congratulations! Which editor handled this? It feels like the speed is quite fast.

(0) Thank | 风清扬

Congratulations! Which editor handled this?

(0) Thank | 风清扬

This journal, this speed, does he want to drop the next issue? ... Next time just submit directly to Energy ATE, it's been a month without review ... In the past it was rejected on the same day, now, sigh, one month WE.

(0) Thank | 蓝蓝蓝洛