Submitted in early November 2024, it is already the end of April 2025 and it is still Under Review. It has been six months since the first review and it still hasn't been completed. Dizzy...

(0) Thank | 羊羊爱吃草

Continuing from the timeline above:
2025.3.3 Awaiting EIC Decision
2025.3.3 Accepted

(0) Thank | 人在皮天在看

My first review took six months, with the following timeline:
July 3, 2024 - Submitted to journal
December 30, 2024 - Awaiting Editor-in-Chief Decision
December 30, 2024 - Major revisions requested by two reviewers, feedback was addressed promptly
January 4, 2025 - Revised
February 4, 2025 - Editor recommends publication

(0) Thank | 人在皮天在看

How long does it take for the boss to review it?

(0) Thank | 小徐子子

Does anyone know how long AE Recommends usually takes? It has been two weeks and my status hasn't changed.

(0) Thank | 人在皮天在看

12.21 submitted
Still awaiting administrator processing
Editor, you can take your time

(1) Thank | opd欧派

2024.9.29 Submitted
2024.10.8 Awaiting Administrator Processing (may be earlier than this date)
2024.10.14 Awaiting Associate Editor Assignment
2024.10.30 Reviewers Score
2024.12.19 Awaiting EIC Decision
2024.12.19 Rejected

(0) Thank | jociejj

The status was under review for 6 months, then it changed to reviewer scores, and after a few days it became AE Recommends. Does anyone know what this means now?

(0) Thank | BeCalm

Okay, thank you.

(0) Thank | jociejj

The reviewers' information is not visible in the IEEE Transactions, but it seems that journals under Elsevier may reveal the reviewers' identities.

(0) Thank | babysteps

Can we see the status of reviewers after entering the reviewers score state? For example, how many reviewers have accepted, etc.

(0) Thank | Lucky

Have you encountered any issues with not being able to open it?

(0) Thank | agsdfgmm

The review comments are all valuable, here is a timeline for your reference:
2023.11.22 submit
2024.6.20 major revision
2024.8.30 major revision
2024.10.7 minor revision - ae recommends
2024.10.15 accept
The first round of major revision was given one month, the second round was given half a month, the third round was not sent for external review, the associate editor directly decided, and the results were returned in a week.

(0) Thank | 社恐的五花肉

IMPORTANT! This site no longer takes submissions. Please use the following link to submit: https://ieee.atyponrex.com/journal/tcss

This site only accepts invited submissions.

(0) Thank | 向大牛学习

I can't log in to the old system, as recommended in the email.

(0) Thank | 社恐的五花肉

Do you see this status as recommended by the old system AE?

(0) Thank | Ye0310

Submitted on 29th September 2024. In the old system, the status is still Awaiting Administrator Processing. However, in the new system, the status is Under Review on the day of submission. Do you know why the old system is always like this?

(0) Thank | Lucky

The feedback is that AE recommended acceptance, but it still needs to be revised before final approval, without sending it for external review. How long will this stage approximately take?

(0) Thank | 社恐的五花肉

May I ask where can I check this status? I can only see "under review" on the submission page.

(0) Thank | 社恐的五花肉

2024.8.1 submit
2024.10.8 AE Recommends

Is this AE Recommends already Recommends or Awaiting Recommends?

(0) Thank | Ye0310

Initial Submission
Submitted on 21 August 2023
Revision 1
Revised on 16 September 2024
Accept
Accept on 30 September 2024

(0) Thank | 麻中麻

Could I ask the original poster, how long does it usually take for reviewers to submit their feedback during the tcss revision process? When can we generally expect to receive feedback on articles that you review? Thank you.

(0) Thank | EleaM Josen Haplacg

I invested at the end of May, currently recommended by AE, but I don't know the result yet.

(0) Thank | hxj007

The paper I reviewed went through a total of three rounds, spanning a total of seven and a half months. The paper I submitted myself has already been in the first round of external review for four months.

(0) Thank | 野指针

OP, any updates on the outcome?

(0) Thank | hxj007