Review comments are very fast. However, the editor has a lot of sway and waits for a few months to reject it directly.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

May I ask how long it will take to receive the proof version after acceptance?

(0) Thank | laolaoxia

May I ask how long it will take to receive the proof after acceptance?

(0) Thank | laolaoxia

How many reviewers are there?

(0) Thank | 工大打工人11

Several reviewers

(0) Thank | 工大打工人11

You are too fast, accepting the reviewer within one day of receiving the report.

(0) Thank | 想法SCI

You sent it for review so quickly.

(0) Thank | 想法SCI

My friend, how many reviewers are you asking for? Five of mine have been externally reviewed for almost three weeks with no response.

(0) Thank | 想法SCI

I have followed up twice but still have not received any response. I suspect the reviewer has dropped the ball.

(0) Thank | soloooooo

The external review has been going on for almost three months, and it is still ongoing. Other members of the research group have already been accepted, but I am still in the external review process.

(0) Thank | soloooooo

The submission was made on May 20, 2025, and it is now June 20. It is still in the hands of the editorial department. Despite reminding them once before, there has been no progress. Therefore, I have decided to withdraw the submission.

(0) Thank | 电气学渣只求毕业

Have you submitted for review? It's been over twenty days for mine, so I'm thinking of transferring to IOP.

(0) Thank | Peng2506

Please record the following process:

Submitted on 03/25, reviewed and revised by editor on 03/26, submitted revised version on 03/28. External review.

Major revision on 05/16, reviewed by 3 reviewers. Requested to make revisions within 14 days.

Submitted revised version 2 on 05/27. External review.

Accepted on 06/09. Total time taken: 2.5 months.

(0) Thank | huaxianzi122

This journal is indeed very slow, there is no way to rush it in the early stage, urging is also useless. If the review comments come back, it is recommended to directly contact the editor's email to urge.

(0) Thank | jmwkgdy

Both the system and the email.

(0) Thank | jmwkgdy

Are the comments from the external audit visible on the system or are they sent back via email?

(0) Thank | yan

My external audit report has come back, but the editor has not sent it to me yet. It's been two to three weeks, help!

(0) Thank | yan

I also submitted my manuscript during the same period, but despite sending multiple reminders, there has been no resolution yet. I am still waiting, and the process is extremely slow.

(0) Thank | 会有猫的

I have never seen a journal that moves so slowly. I submitted on April 10th, passed the Technical check and Editorial assignment the same day, and entered the "With editor" stage. The problem lies in the "With editor" stage, and it is still there as of June 1st. I emailed the editorial department and they replied that the manuscript is currently undergoing preliminary evaluation by the editor. I am puzzled by how this preliminary evaluation can last for almost two months. If there is no response in a few days, I have decided to withdraw the submission.

(0) Thank | 梦想成为中科(工)院院士

I want to ask if the website cannot be accessed, is there a new submission website?

(0) Thank | 想法SCI

Friend, how is your paper going now? I haven't touched mine in a month either.

(0) Thank | 小二11

The review process is very fast, with minor revisions suggested in the first review, and the revised version was accepted.

(0) Thank | 天仔仔

It's been almost a month already, I don't know how much longer I have to wait.

(0) Thank | schebut

How long do we need to continue...

(0) Thank | wubei

It has been over 20 days with the editor, feeling a bit anxious about whether to remind them to submit the article.

(0) Thank | schebut