It is a very good journal, and it has a high requirement for English. 2020.1.25, submission; 2020.4.5, major revision; 2020.6.3, accept.

(0) Thank | star_me

Dec 24 2019, submission; Jan 31 2020, major revision; Feb 26 2020, the revision submitted; Mar 18 2020, minor revision; Mar 21 2020, the revision submitted; Mar 23 2020, accept. The review comments were pertinent, the review speed was also fast, and the editor read it carefully and pointed out some details and errors, which helped to improve the quality of the article.

(4) Thank | TingtingGaoXing

Questions raised by reviewers is very good, so my paper became more rigorous. Thank you very much. In addition, the review speed is relatively fast. The first time a major revision was required, and it was revised for almost a month and some experiments were added. After that, a minor revision to the grammar of the paper was required, and the results were returned within a week or two. The editors and reviewers were very nice. Welcome to exchange here at 561729076.

(1) Thank | 教书育人

CJ is a good SCI journal, although the impact factor is not high. This is probably because it is not under one of three major publishers. The past editor was very responsible; however, I know that they recently changed the editor-in-chief. The writing requirements are relatively high, so if you’re a non-native English speaker this may be a difficult journal to get published in unless you have submitted to a language editing service. From my experience, manuscripts are generally not sent to the recommended reviewers, and I personally feel that reviewers are often from top dogs in the field. The review time is usually between 3-5 months, so it can be a bit long.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

2025.8.7 Awaiting Admin Processing

(0) Thank | ssdsS

Why doesn't this journal have a Word format? Are there any other requirements besides single column double spacing?

(0) Thank | gtb

I submitted the manuscript in January last year and it is still going through the process. I am speechless.

(0) Thank | AESer

I sent an email last month but no one responded, then I sent another one two days ago, and it took 4 months to invite 5 people... Not even one person has been approved, this is still playing hard to get.

(0) Thank | 夜雨愿

Still in ur, I really can't stand this editor.

(0) Thank | 夜雨愿

Trashy journal, the manuscript submitted in January this year, has not been assigned to an editor for three months, and was directly transferred to another journal, wasting time.

(0) Thank | 椎名真白

I also want to know how long it will take for the editing assignment to be allocated. I have been waiting for a long time.

(0) Thank | zhao1108

My senior brother's submission was returned within a month, but mine is still under review after half a month. It's really slow.

(0) Thank | yyt1314

Submitted on July 1, 2024
Accepted on May 23, 2025

(0) Thank | a海拉鲁装修

It has been 6 months since the first instance trial, and it is still in the process of undergoing review. The process is taking too long.

(0) Thank | 飘向远方

Do you charge for this journal?

(0) Thank | 张果果

The slow pace is ridiculous, I feel like throwing up.

(0) Thank | 夜雨愿

The first and second reviews took a bit long, but the review comments were very professional and the questions raised were sharp. It feels good overall. If you can wait, you can submit it. If you are in a hurry to graduate, I do not recommend submitting before May 21, 2024 - major on September 10, 2024 - revise on September 28, 2024 - and accept on March 6, 2025. It took 10 months in total.

(1) Thank | undefined

Just submitted for review last week.

(0) Thank | 飘向远方

Is there any update now? The official website status has changed once a few days after submission, it has been several months and still no news.

(0) Thank | 往事~

Brother, what's the situation now?

(0) Thank | 椎名真白

Please make a note that it was submitted on February 9th and is under review as of February 10th.

(0) Thank | 夜雨愿

Hello, OP. Just wanted to ask, how long did it take for the second review after your repair?

(0) Thank | AESer

It has been almost a month since submission, but there has been no review yet. I want to ask everyone about the progress. I heard that the review process is fast for some people, but I didn't expect it to be so slow.

(0) Thank | 飘向远方

Awaiting Editor Assignment.

(0) Thank | LC

Could you please clarify the difference between "Under review" and "Under Review" in the submission status of this journal? Which status indicates that the manuscript has been sent out for external review?

(0) Thank | 往事~