Submission: 2020.03.29; First review and revision: 2020.06.20; Revision: 2020.07.20; Acceptance: 2020.08.04; Online publication: 2020.09.02. The manuscript was submitted at the end of March 2020 and accepted in August 2020. The editor processing speed is very fast, but the submission cycle is relatively long, which may be mainly affected by the epidemic. In the review comments, a reviewer mainly gave suggestions on details such as language expression, experimental parameter selection, and interpretation. Another reviewer mainly gave opinions on the innovation and research significance of the paper. Due to the high requirements of the journal, it took a long time to carefully revise according to the comments of the reviewers. After the revised submission, the editor dealt with it quickly, and the reviewer agreed to accept it. In general, the editors and reviewers are very responsible and give quite pertinent opinions. In addition, the language expression of the paper and the quality of the pictures should be taken seriously.

(4) Thank | Harry

The review speed was very fast, without wasting my time. Especially for graduate students preparing for the doctoral entrance examination, this is very critical. The quality of this journal was obviously much better than that in previous years. Coupled with being a leading journal, it is estimated that the requirements will be higher and higher. The review was very strict, and several students’ manuscripts were rejected. My manuscript went through two major revisions. The reviewers were very professional, and you knew they were experts at the first glance. Although making revisions was painful, I still learned a lot. My first paper was published in CJA, which can be regarded as a fate with CJA. Finally, I wish CJA better and better.

(31) Thank | Zw1

Received: 4 March 2019; Revised: 5 August 2019; Accepted: 16 July 2019. I’m a direct doctor in a 985 university in the capital of China. Three stages of “revision-revision-employment" was included for this paper. There was a total of three reviewers. The first review took about one and a half months, and the review comments given by the three reviewers were all professional and sharp, which greatly helped improve the quality of the manuscript. Then, it took nearly 20 days for us to make major revisions and submit it again. Almost a month and a half later, the second comment was received. One reviewer had no comments, and the other one asked one question, requiring me to explain. The third one was satisfied with the response to the previous comment, and then asked another one, which was very clever and meaningful. Next, I spent about five days revising it, adding a new section of content, and submitted it again. In less than two weeks, I was notified that it was accepted, so I modified it as required and submitted the final version.

(3) Thank | Runx

I am a doctoral student and I have contributed two articles in the teaching and research section of this journal. CJA strictly controls the quality of the journal, and the review process is very strict. It gives me the feeling that there are many reviewers involved, which is also very strict.

(5) Thank | 中国期刊加油

Under review has been a full month, with one change in date.

(0) Thank | Z77

This journal is excellent, with a high level of quality. I recommend submitting to it more often.

(0) Thank | Bruce Lee

Hello, may I ask if you are using a Word template or an old Latex template? Can the old Latex template still be used now? Will it be rejected directly?

(0) Thank | imx_101

Hello, may I ask if you submitted your paper using the old Latex template or the Word template? I'm not sure if using the old Latex template at this stage will result in a desk rejection. Best wishes for your paper!

(0) Thank | imx_101

Can I still submit my manuscript using the old Latex template for CJA journal? It seems a bit different from the Word version, but Word is indeed troublesome. If my paper is accepted, can I make corrections using Word for proofreading?

(0) Thank | imx_101

Later, I asked the editor, and the editor said that there is a large volume of submissions, and if there is even one negative opinion, it will be rejected. I feel that not receiving any feedback is considered a rejection.

(1) Thank | qqwqs

Is it so terrifying that even a neutral opinion would be rejected?!!!

(0) Thank | 顺风顺水接accept

Can I ask which journal you have submitted to, boss?

(0) Thank | 顺风顺水接accept

I submitted two articles, one was rejected after a month of review and then accepted by JGCD, the other was not even reviewed. The reason given by the editor was very unreasonable and hard to believe, but there is no choice but to submit again, as it is a top journal in this field.

(0) Thank | 檐上踏月客

Excuse me, do I need to follow the provided template? I noticed there are requirements for copyright transfer and confidentiality, do I need to provide those as well?

(0) Thank | 冈崎朋也

This journal requires submissions to be in Word format.

(0) Thank | zhangshengguo

Question!!! This journal requires submissions to be made using a LaTeX template. If accepted, will it need to be converted to a Word version? Or is it necessary to submit a Word version in the end?

(0) Thank | tt

2024.11.12 Submitted to journal
2024.11.15 With editor
2024.11.20 Under Review
2024.11.29 Major Revision
2024.12.16 Revision submitted
2024.12.17 With editor
2024.12.17 Under Review
2024.12.24 With editor
2025.03.10 With editor

(0) Thank | 你好我叫朵拉

I'm sorry, but "lj" does not provide enough context for me to accurately translate the text. Could you please provide more information or context so I can help you with the translation?

(0) Thank | 不会拉粑粑

Trash journals, editors lacking intelligence.

(0) Thank | 不会拉粑粑

Can I not use the journal template first? If accepted, can I change it to the journal template later?

(0) Thank | 小白菜111

Can I ask which option did you finally choose?

(0) Thank | 小白菜111

Hello, do you have an answer yet?

(0) Thank | 小白菜111

20250305 With Editor

(0) Thank | 不会拉粑粑

How can I expedite this?

(0) Thank | 不会拉粑粑

Submitted to Journal on 20250304.

(0) Thank | 不会拉粑粑