Two months were given for major revision, but as there were a lot of things in the middle, it took three months to make the revisions and resubmit it. One month later, it got accepted. It is a slightly lower journal in the mainstream publications of nonlinear science. I feel that the journal is not rigorous enough. However, it belongs to Q2 and can be used as a paper to guarantee the graduation. I will not publish my best work on CSF.

(50) Thank | 追光野猫

A very good journal. During two months, I published an article on Fractals and Chaos respectively. In comparison, it is faster in Fractals. It took more than 20 days to be accepted. But this one is obviously difficult than fractals, and it deserves to be classified as a top journal.

(122) Thank | chong

I submitted 2 papers to this journal, and they were all accepted. The review lasted for 3 months, and the review comments were very professional. I feel it is a good journal, and it is difficult to be accepted without innovation.

(13) Thank | lion-lion

Our group submitted our manuscript on May 4 this year, and it was with the editor through the end of August. Ugh. By early October, we received a notice from the editor that our manuscript had NOT been sent out for external review and that it had been rejected. The editor stated that the level of scientific merit didn’t meet the requirements of the journal. I can’t believe our manuscript was with the editor for 5 months.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Has another reviewer been added? I submitted my paper and currently only one reviewer has accepted the review.

(0) Thank | chennnnnnnn

Have you ever reviewed for this journal before? How long does it usually take for the first review to be completed by the reviewers?

(0) Thank | Jay的秋刀鱼和猫

Almost one and a half months.

(0) Thank | 顺利接收

May I ask how long it takes for your reviewers to return their comments? I only have one reviewer for my manuscript, who has accepted the review but has not yet provided any feedback. It has been nearly 2 months now, and I'm not sure what to do.

(0) Thank | infinity-inf

What a coincidence, I am the same way. After being invited by the editor, shouldn't it be "under review"? What was your status changed to later on?

(0) Thank | Jay的秋刀鱼和猫

I am also like this now, how have you been since then?

(0) Thank | Jay的秋刀鱼和猫

20250527-with editor
20250528-editor invited

(0) Thank | Jay的秋刀鱼和猫

Record the submission process again.

(0) Thank | Jay的秋刀鱼和猫

Can I ask everyone a question? Only one reviewer has provided feedback on the manuscript. In this situation, should I act as the reviewer myself and make some additional revisions, or should I submit it for review again?

(0) Thank | 顺利接收

My revision has been submitted, but only one person has completed the review. In this case, will there be any additional reviewers after the revision?

(0) Thank | 顺利接收

I am also one of the reviewers. One reviewer accepted the review in early April and has not yet returned any comments, suspecting that the reviewer has disappeared. Since the editor invited five reviewers in early April, there have been no further invitations to other reviewers, and it feels like the editor has also disappeared. Currently in a state of waiting in the dark, I don't know why some papers in this journal are reviewed so quickly.

(0) Thank | infinity-inf

A person cannot revise their work unless the editor acts as a reviewer and provides feedback. Elsevier requires at least two reviewers.

(0) Thank | Jay的秋刀鱼和猫

Excuse me, it has been over a month since the review process started, and there is only one reviewer. Will there be additional reviewers in this situation, or can the same reviewer request revisions?

(0) Thank | 顺利接收

No problem, just keep waiting for the news.

(0) Thank | Jay的秋刀鱼和猫

Can I ask everyone, after submitting a manuscript, it went from "with editor" to "editor invited". Does this mean it will be rejected? Has anyone experienced this before?

(0) Thank | 丸子王

May I ask what the reason for refusal is?

(0) Thank | kakachaotic

Wow, I'm so lucky! It's the first time I've seen something happen so quickly.

(0) Thank | 丸子王

The first SCI paper written by myself, submitted in March, revised in April, accepted in May, published in a top journal.

(0) Thank | 大大大小白

Submitted on April 5, 2025, received reviewer comments on April 27, with two revisions requested. Submitted revised manuscript on May 1 and accepted on May 7.

(0) Thank | nat.pho

Can you please translate the following paragraph into English?

(0) Thank | sssdasdada

Hello, can the review progress of this journal be checked on the Elsevier official account recently?

(0) Thank | infinity-inf