Is this journal OA? How much is the total page fee in Chinese Yuan?

(0) Thank | 广武地

Is this journal open access? Is there a fee? I saw you mentioned that you paid a fee, how much did you pay?

(0) Thank | 广武地

They are all published by the same journal publisher IAENG. As for the issue you mentioned, it may be that the editor felt your article was more suitable for this journal and transferred it, or it could be that you made a mistake when submitting. My suggestion is to write to the journal's editor to inquire. I have only submitted to this journal once, so I cannot give you a definite answer.

(0) Thank | 该用户已注销_

I would like to ask the host, when I submitted my paper, it was through Engineering Letters journal, but the email for revisions received mentioned International Journal of Computer Science. Are these two journals the same? Engineering Letters is in the fourth quartile, while International Journal of Computer Science is not indexed.

(0) Thank | 暴龙战士

I would like to ask the host, when I submitted my paper, I selected Engineering Letters as the journal, but the email I received for revisions mentioned International Journal of Computer Science. Are these two journals the same?

(0) Thank | 暴龙战士

Another point of complaint about the journal is the formatting issue. The journal has very strict requirements for formatting (a PDF file of around 26 pages), and any deviation from these requirements will require revisions. Some of these requirements are quite difficult to meet: for example, figures cannot be inserted within paragraphs, and they cannot cause blank pages due to their placement. However, the journal is in two columns, so some large images have to be changed to single-column format, which can lead to the aforementioned issues. Additionally, the journal requires submissions in .doc format, and all files for submission and revisions cannot exceed 8MB in total. Revisions must include a modification statement, as highlighting on the original file is not allowed, and a separate statement must be provided in a specific format. In short, there are many trivial rules that must be followed.

As for the journal fees, as stated on the official website, they are not expensive, which is also a plus. In conclusion, for Master's students busy meeting graduation requirements, if impact factor is not a concern, it may be worth a try.

That's my entire experience, and I probably won't be back on Letpub in the future, so those who read this post can just take note and there's no need to add me as a friend anymore.

(0) Thank | xing

Personal experience:

First of all, regarding the review process, the feedback from the major revision was very general. For details, please refer to my replies to comments in the comments section. After searching online, I found that the major revision feedback given by this journal is quite general to many people. Due to the reviewer's comment on the poor English level of the paper during the major revision, I had it polished by a language editing service. However, the minor revision feedback after resubmission was basically consistent with the major revision feedback. Overall, the review process of this journal seems a bit abstract.

Next is the speed of the journal. One advantage is that throughout the submission process, they will send you emails informing you of specific deadlines. For example, for the first round of review, they will clearly inform you of a deadline, and if there is no response by that date, you can inquire. In reality, they generally stick to this deadline. However, a point of complaint is that some editorial responses also have a deadline, usually two weeks, but they usually respond every 7 days. For example, in my case of formatting changes, the three rounds of communication took me almost a whole month, even for minor issues, they still responded every seven days. The responses were a bit quicker during the plagiarism check and payment stage.

(0) Thank | xing

Sharing personal experience about this journal:
1. Process
Submitted on August 15th, the editorial department replied with receipt of the submission for external review after 7 days.
First review result came out after 2 months, with major revisions needed.
Returned for major revisions on November 11th.
Second review result came out on November 30th, with minor revisions needed.
Returned for minor revisions on December 5th.
On December 12th, the editorial department sent an email to start the formatting modification process, which lasted until December 26th.
Requested plagiarism check on December 26th.
On January 1st, the editorial department requested payment information and choice of payment method.
Payment link was provided on January 6th.

(0) Thank | xing

Why does it feel like this journal gives the same review comments to everyone? The first time I reviewed, it was major revisions, and the comments were exactly the same as yours. The second time, the comments were exactly the same as the first. Then I searched on Xiaomuchong and found that the review comments this journal gives to others are the same few sentences.

(0) Thank | xing

Where can I check the delivery status? I submitted successfully without registering, which feels strange.

(0) Thank | SAKURA搞科研

I submitted my work in July and received a revision email in September. Below are the revision comments I received, which only included a passing grade without any specific feedback.

(0) Thank | Swwwww

I submitted my manuscript on August 25th, may I ask if there is a webpage where I can check the progress of my submission, such as the review and editing process?

(0) Thank | 我的手机有点头疼

Submitted at the beginning of August 2023
Two major revisions and one minor revision
Accepted in April 2024

(0) Thank | QWEQFW

Please reply with the current status

(0) Thank | maxyyyy

Hello, senior, have you ever submitted to this journal?

(0) Thank | shauishuai

Anyone submitted any entries?

(0) Thank | 郭大胆